Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Postage & Packaging: Free!
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
SHOPPING > DVDs > Comedy > Withnail And I (DVD) > Reviews

Withnail And I (DVD)

from (6 offers) · Product Information

Withnail And I (DVD)

Quote-start

What we need is harmony

Quote-end

5 Aug 10th, 2006 

8 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
remarkable, hilarious, beautiful, tragic

Disadvantages:
absolutely zilch

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

apple_scruff

apple_scruff

About me:

Member since:30.08.2005

Reviews:7

Members who trust:1

'Withnail and I' has now established itself a cult classic of British cinema. Adored by penniless students and the upper class alike, 'Withnail and I' will never fail to delight. The brain child of Bruce Robinson, 'Withnail and I' is loosely based on his own life. Withnail, cultivated from an old friend Viv who later died of cancer, and 'I' being Robinson's portrayal of himself; are two characters you will never forget. Like Laurel and Hardy, pepper and salt, no one will ever fit together in quite the same way they do.

PLOT
Set in 1969, Camden Town, London; the credits are simple, un-flashy and generally low budget. Excellent. We then sneak a peak at 'I' (Paul McGann), wild hair, panic stricken face, and spectacles that could have been stolen from Lennon himself. The first thing that flashes into your mind is what the hell is he doing? Between puffs of smoke he's examining his thumbs with bizarre intensity. As the camera pans out we see his surroundings. Squalor. Following him into the kitchen we see a vision which is more similarly suited to the blitz. We quickly learn that 'I', who is never actually given a name, is not alone. Indeed he is sharing his miserable existence with Withnail (Richard E Grant), an alcoholic dry tongued man, who despite his unfortunate situation, still holds some sort of nobility.
In a desperate bid to escape their dishevelled life, 'I' proposes a trip to the country in Monty's cottage, with disastrous and hilarious consequences. The pair encounter inhospitable neighbours, near starvation, a randy bull and Withnail's homosexual Uncle Monty (Richard Griffiths). Laced with embarrassing situations, 'Withnail and I' is heartbreaking and funny, you are taken on a journey you will never forget, even if Withnail does.

CHARACTERS/ACTING
The characters are brilliant, cultivated like pieces of art, each persona is perfectly crafted. The character of 'I' is a complicated mix of anxiety, seriousness and paranoia, thrown in are equal measures of love and dislike for Withnail. In contrast Withnail is selfish, witty and dry, disgusted he has come to this. Together they are the imperfect team. Paul McGann, a mostly unknown actor who later went on to become a successful television actor, plays the part of 'I' expertly, a natural in front of the camera you become convinced that McGann actually is this guy. Richard E Grant, who suffered personal trauma when his wife lost their unborn child in the making of this film, fit's the character of Withnail brilliantly. Withnail is a character so detached from Grant it's a wonder he could pull it off, Grant didn't smoke or drink, but remarkably he does; becoming one of the great cinematic characters of all time, the perfect anti-hero.
Griffiths is entirely convincing as Withnail's homosexual Uncle Monty, who invades the pairs private weekend with more than food and wine on his mind when he diverts his attentions to 'I'. A cringe inducing portrayal of the disappointed delicate Uncle, with an equal mixture of sorrow thrown in, you can't help but pity him. Ralph Brown who plays drug dealer Danny, makes a memorable but brief appearance in 'Withnail and I's' flat, is absolutely brilliant as the hippy with very few brain cells left. Delivering some of the best lines, this part could only have been reserved for one person, and luckily, he was able to make the shoot.

SETS AND LOCATION
Although featuring fewer sets than a Hollywood blockbuster, they are no less fantastic. The flat is the perfect picture of decay, despair and squalor. The kitchen is littered with withered posters, grease stained walls, a sink full of unwashed pots, and possible invasions of vermin. The sofas are grimy, the furniture unhinged, the mirror smeared with muck, random objects littering the floor, the atmosphere is filled with cigarette smoke and other substances. The represents the devastation and decay which had become the flat mate's lives. Another brilliant set which makes only a brief appearance is the café, especially the grease and both pubs featured shows equal scoops of depression. The cottage itself is fantastic. With the absence of Uncle Monty at the beginning of their stay, the cottage is drab, cold, dusty and poorly lit. When Monty arrives all this had disappeared and the place is filled with light, warmth and more importantly, food and booze. Similarly, when Monty leaves, the place is shrouded again. The perhaps best shows the glimpse of hope which enters the pair's life. Landscapes include fields of beautifully sweeping countryside, and a quiet humourless village.


WARDROBE
Each character is given their own identity when it comes to this department. As much as 'I' is reserved, Withnail is flamboyant. 'I' normally wears variations on jeans and sweatshirts, John Lennon style boots, white Y-fronts, long leather coat and a farmers hat (an attempt to blend in with the local folk?). This gives him a look of stability, the sensible one, a lean post for Withnail, casualness and a look of the unfussy. Withnail wears garb similar enough to rival a poor eighteenth century dandy, with tail coats, scarves, long shirts and battered waistcoats…and shoes made from plastic bags. This matches his personality, edgy and flamboyant. Monty in bodies the outfit of a country squire, all flat caps and raincoats, checks and walking sticks. Danny looks like a 70's glam rock star, smudged eyeliner, tight flairs and tight vest tops, all finished off with a mass of hair (Brown is actually entirely bald). As the film progresses Monty becomes even more 'camp', eventually donning nothing but a silky bathrobe and eye shadow. Towards the end of the film 'I' dons a 1940's style short cut, symbolising his desire to clean up his act.

THE SCRIPT
An absolute work of art. The genius of Robinson's penmanship is what makes 'Withnail…' an all time classic. Every line is nothing short of brilliant, whether it be hilarious or depressing, and there are too many classic quotes to mention. I highly recommend investing in the screenplay where you can read every sentence for yourself. The script also includes a couple of short scenes which never made it to big screen but which sound great on paper. I shall mention that one of my favourite quotes comes from Withnail, in a scene involving a confrontation "I have a heart condition. If you hit me it's murder."

STATS
This film had been rated 15 in the UK due to it's bad language and reference to drugs.
It's 107mins of pure delight.
Written and directed by: Bruce Robinson
Music by: (a very impressive soundtrack) David Dundas and Rick Wentworth
Co-produced by: David Wimbury
Executive Producers: George Harrison (yes, the former Beatle) and Denis O'Brien
Produced by: Paul Hellier
Made by Handmade Films

ALTERNATIVE ENDING
The story was originality meant to be turned into a novel by Robinson, with a rather alternate ending. At the end Withnail was meant to be alone in the flat. He was supposed to pour wine into a gun, both taken from Monty's cottage, swallow the wine and then shoot himself. Had this happened in the film the depressing message of the film would have been magnified over the humour.

COMEDY/TRADGEDY
'Withnail and I' is quite often referred to as a comedy. Obviously 'Withnail…' is hilarious and has huge comedic value. However, when watching the film I can't help noticing the message of desperation and depression which seeps beneath the humour. The plot and characters are really quite tragic, the characters are never really happy and continually desperate. They are broke, dregs of an era where anything seemed possible, left behind after the tirade happenings, and although there may be light at the end of the tunnel, you wonder if they'll hold on long enough to make it.

'Withnail and I' is cinema at it's best, my personal favourite, a continual delight to watch, and everyone should watch it. I purchased my copy for £2.99 in a sale at HMV, sadly I am too poor to purchase the copy of the DVD which includes an hour long documentary. My DVD version is extremely basic, with only a play option and the incapacity to skip chapters. However, this is no problem, and 'Withnail and I' is now my firm favourite. It's the one film I wish I had written.  

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Bob Roberts (DVD)

Bob Roberts (DVD)

Production Year: 1992 - Comedy - Director: Tim Robbins - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Ray Wise, Alan Rickman, Giancarlo Esposito, Tim Robbins

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 2.24

Only Fools And Horses - The Complete Series 1 To 7 (Box Set) (DVD)

Only Fools And Horses - The Complete Series 1 To 7 (Box Set) (DVD)

Comedy - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring: David Jason, Nicholas Lyndhurst, Lennard Pearce, Buster Merryfield, Gwyneth Strong, Tessa Peake-Jones

User reviews (27)

Buy now for only £ 31.85

The Truth About Love (DVD)

The Truth About Love (DVD)

Production Year: 2004 - Comedy - Director: John Hay - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Jennifer Love Hewitt, Jimi Mistry, Kate Miles, Dougray Scott

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 0.01

Laurel And Hardy (Box Set) (DVD)

Laurel And Hardy (Box Set) (DVD)

Comedy - Original Language: English - Classification: Universal, TBA - Starring: Stan Laurel, Oliver Hardy

User reviews (4)

Buy now for only £ 9.89

Blackadder - Complete Blackadder (Limited Edition Box Set) (DVD)

Blackadder - Complete Blackadder (Limited Edition Box Set) (DVD)

Comedy - Director: Richard Boden, Mandie Fletcher, Martin Shardlow - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Hugh Laurie, Miranda Richardson, Stephen Fry, Brian Blessed, Tim McInnerny, Tony Robinson, Rowan Atkinson

User reviews (13)

Buy now for only £ 16.99

Complete Only Fools And Horses (Box Set) (DVD)

Complete Only Fools And Horses (Box Set) (DVD)

Comedy - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring: Tessa Peake-Jones, Buster Merryfield, David Jason, Nicholas Lyndhurst

User reviews (12)

Buy now for only £ 49.98

Comments about this review »

Crimsonflame 10.08.2006 21:25

Sounds quite hilarious, great review with every aspect covered nicely. Crimps

Compare prices for Withnail And I (DVD) »

1 to 5 out of 6 offers for Withnail And I (DVD) Show all offers   sorted by: Price 
Withnail And I [1986] [DVD]

Withnail And I [1986] [DVD]

Set in 1969, the year in which the hippy dreams of so many young Englishmen went sour, ... more

1986's Bruce Robinson'sWithnail and Iis an
enduring British cult. Fellow enthusiasts cry
immortal phrases from the endlessly brilliant
script to one another like mat...

amazon marketplace dvd

Postage & Packaging£1.21
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace d...
Withnail And I [1986] [DVD]

Withnail And I [1986] [DVD]

Set in 1969, the year in which the hippy dreams of so many young Englishmen went sour, ... more

1986's Bruce Robinson'sWithnail and Iis an
enduring British cult. Fellow enthusiasts cry
immortal phrases from the endlessly brilliant
script to one another like mat...

amazon dvd

Postage & PackagingFree!
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon dvd
Withnail And I-DVD

Withnail And I-DVD

thehut.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityIn stock - Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
thehut.com
Withnail And I

Withnail And I

London. The '60s. two unemployed actors - acerbic, elegantly wasted Withnail (Richard E. ... more

Grant) and the anxiety-ridden I (Paul McGann) -
drown their frustrations in booze, pills, and
lighter fluid. When Withnail's Uncle Monty
(Richard Griffiths) offers...

LOVEFiLM.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityIn Stock
 Visit Shop  >
LOVEFiLM.com


More reviews »

Withnail And I (DVD) - review by Judgee

Advantages: Great, great film
Disadvantages: none

Withnail And I (DVD) - review by Judgee Judgee 15.10.2001 (16.10.2001) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Withnail And I (DVD)

Withnail And I (DVD) - review by james.bridgeman

Advantages: Hilarious performances all round, great soundtrack, one of the finest scripts known to humanity
Disadvantages: Not for the easily-shocked...

Withnail And I (DVD) - review by james.bridgeman james.bridgeman 14.04.2001 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Withnail And I (DVD)

Withnail And I (DVD) - review by toneboy7

Advantages: Superb humour, Richard E. Grant is top class
Disadvantages: Not one for the kids, women don't seem to like it either

Withnail And I (DVD) - review by toneboy7 toneboy7 29.08.2000 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Withnail And I (DVD)

Withnail And I (DVD) - review by Plissken

Advantages: A high point of British comedy.
Disadvantages: ....

Withnail And I (DVD) - review by Plissken Plissken 09.01.2001 (06.01.2001) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Withnail And I (DVD)

Withnail And I (DVD) - review by Shanksey

Advantages: Very witty
Disadvantages: May bore action fans

Withnail And I (DVD) - review by Shanksey Shanksey 16.11.2002 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Withnail And I (DVD)



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Withnail And I (DVD)? Click here