Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Postage & Packaging: Free!
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
SHOPPING > DVDs > War > Where Eagles Dare (DVD) > Reviews

Where Eagles Dare (DVD)

from (5 offers) · Product Information

Where Eagles Dare (DVD)

Quote-start

Fly Like an Eagle

Quote-end

3 Jul 10th, 2004 

47 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Slam bang actioner with a great cast

Disadvantages:
Incomprehensible plot .  .  . slack direction .  .  .

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

dadmancat

dadmancat

About me:

People..please, no more telling me I misunderstood the Football Factory, if one more person even thi...

Member since:27.07.2000

Reviews:170

Members who trust:78

As MGM finished the 60s they watched their competitors scoring large hits, while all of their big budget releases faltered at the box office. 1968's 'Where Eagles Dare' hauled the studio up by it's jackboot straps and scored a massive hit all over the globe.

Produced by the British production arm of MGM based at the now defunct Borehamwood Studios, Alistair Macleans original screenplay leapt onto the screen boasting an accomplished cast, a tonne of hardware, and locations and setpieces to set the hair on end.

For all of the above though, 'Where Eagles Dare' is far from being a great film. Director Brian G Hutton, who would reteam with Eastwood and World War II for 'Kelly's Heroes', struggles with the epic length of the film, and fails to unravel the absurd complexities of Macleans screenplay.

A crack team of allied soldiers is despatched to rescue an American General, downed while flying to a crucial conference in Greece. Instead of reaching the Mediterranean where he would help to plan the Allied invasion of Europe, however German fighters brought his aircraft down over the motherland.

Fearful of the secrets he may reveal under interrogation, the Allies decide he must be rescued at all costs, and so a small team are dropped into the mountains surrounding the Schloss Adler, the Bavarian headquarters of the SS and home to an American General.

Perched atop a towering column of rock, the Castle seems accessible only by the air, but somehow the Allied rescue mission must storm the Castle of Eagles, and rescue General Carnaby.

A running time of 158 minutes suggests that all is not going to be that simple, and Maclean has delivered a story that boasts triple and quadruple crosses, and a plot so convoluted that one wonders what the point of it all was come the end. It is a good excuse for some rollicking action, but try and examine the logic of the movie and it will unravel before you. I advise you to have a pen and piece of paper ready about midway through the movie, or to make sure that you have friends and family with you in order to play the 'Whos working for who' game.

That said, the twists and turns do enliven a lengthy feature, whether they work or not is entirely up for debate, but it's difficult to imagine 'Eagles' running to just under three hours as a pure actioner.

Going in it's favour are a couple of top notch lead performances. Burton actually seems interested in the project and is all trademark snarls and contempt. Eastwood delivers the usual Eastwood role, and yes he may as well be in a poncho clasping a cigar between his lips, but it works, and if it ain't broke, don't fix it. Mary Ure and Ingrid Pitt both get to provide strong female support roles, and it must be said that Miss Pitt has alot to need supporting, ahem, but they are unusually strong roles for both an action picture and one made in the 1960s. Scattered about Burton and Eastwood are a mixture of familiar British character actors, who while entertaining are given little to do other than sit about in sets while Burton and Eastwood destroy acre after acre of Austrian countryside.

Destruction is key to 'Where Eagles Dare's success, because, should you dare think about becoming bored or turning away, Maclean and Hutton will contrive to introduce something else that needs blowing up. They do it so well too. Some of the most breathtaking scenery committed to film gets used as a backdrop to Burton and Eastwood's two man mission against the entire German Army. It is undoubtedly exciting stuff, and the literal high point of the film, the break into the high security high altitude castle is edge of the seat stuff.

Hutton is clearly at his best with the action material, occasionally shines with the characters interplaying, but mostly captures events like we're watching a live storyboard. It is often possible to sit and imagine the pencil lines on screen as Hutton ponderously blocks out his next sequence. That's the story with 'Eagles' though, a wildly hit and miss affair. The locations are as mentioned wonderful, but when not being nicely lit and photographed by Arthur Ibbetson, we are subjected to some dreadful day for night shooting. Murky blues, the action difficult to pick out, huge sharp shadows, and let us not forget that other staple of 60's cinema. Back projection. There's plenty of that, and considering the dangerous nature of most of the stunts, well, they had little alternative. In line with the rest of the film, some works marvellously, some fails miserably.

Consistently good is the work of Ron Goodwin, who created one of his signature scores for 'Eagles'. No straightforward military soundtrack this, and there is some lovely work to be heard on this score, lots of powerful ascending minor chords that add to both the bombast and edge of the seat antics onscreen.

Production design is simply superb, with massive chunks of the castle, interior and exterior, being recreated on the sound stages of Borehamwood. Peter Mullins would never get a budget like this again, and his design work makes the most of every penny available to him.

Costume design comes up trumps with plenty of Nazi regalia on display and we must thank Arthur Newman for all of those low cut traditional Alpine dresses that Miss Pitt gets to heave her bosom in.

The stunt team do themselves proud with all manner of Bond-worthy sequences, the best probably being a nail-biting fight atop a cable car, something 007 would fail to better, or even equal, in the 1979 outing Moonraker.

So, it would seem that 'Eagles' has much to commend it. Well, it does, but where one hand giveth, another yanks away. Where it scores with action, it loses marks with some pedestrian and uninspired direction. Where the leads succeed, then some of their glory is snatched away as they are forced to play out some overly contrived scenes. Where the screenplay rattles along efficiently, well, round the next mountainous bend lies some inconsistencies and illogical holes that a Tiger Tank could drive through, without the aid of wing mirrors.

Entertaining hokum, that was never going to be Richard III, but still has to be marked down for not quite delivering on all fronts. It stormed the box offices though, and ensured that MGM could splutter away for a few more years until the 1970s began to start banging the nails into the coffin.

Borehamwood closed its doors shortly after completion of 'Eagles' and became a studio for rent until it was allowed to just become a studio and backlot crumbling to the ground.

'Eagles' is now available as part of the Clint Eastwood collection of Warner Brothers titles. As ever Warners pull out none of the stops, and we get a nasty snappy card case, no liner notes, 1 extra in the form of a hilarious contemporary featurette which seems designed to frighten mainland Europe by constantly proclaiming that the Nazis are back. The picture is presented in it's original ratio though, and sound is remastered into a hit and mix surround mix.

It's £9.99 from WHSmiths, Woolworths, and the same online from Play.com. It's certified PG, and when the violence and gore does crop up, it's of the Kensington variety, a red syruppy concoction that not even the most sensitive of youngsters would believe for a second!
 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Saving Private Ryan (DVD)

Saving Private Ryan (DVD)

(+) Storyline, special effects, characters
(-) None

User reviews (15)

Buy now for only £ 3.84

The Beast (DVD)

The Beast (DVD)

(+) excellent photography, intelligent writing, good action, thought-provoking
(-) None

User reviews (6)

Buy now for only £ 3.37

Platoon (DVD)

Platoon (DVD)

(+) powerful film , great value dvd
(-) Not enough scenes with Johnny Depp in

User reviews (20)

Buy now for only £ 2.81

Kelly's Heroes (DVD)

Kelly's Heroes (DVD)

Production Year: 1970 - War - Director: Brian G. Hutton - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring: Clint Eastwood, Telly Savalas, Carroll O'Connor, Donald Sutherland, Don Rickles, Gavin MacLeod

User reviews (4)

Buy now for only £ 4.03

Full Metal Jacket (DVD)

Full Metal Jacket (DVD)

(+) Thought provoking, great one liners, great acting, good story
(-) Too short for both parts. Maybe there should have been 2 separate films?

User reviews (31)

Buy now for only £ 2.72

Studio Classic: Classic War Movies (Box Set) (DVD)

Studio Classic: Classic War Movies (Box Set) (DVD)

War - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 10.56

Comments about this review »

combatcookie 25.03.2008 23:52

Tip Top review, now i remember why i want to buy the film. tvm

giantpanda21 27.06.2006 13:47

This is a great film A great review

pdoyle007 25.08.2005 10:17

good review, I love this film

Compare prices for Where Eagles Dare (DVD) »

1 to 5 out of 5 offers for Where Eagles Dare (DVD) Show all offers   sorted by: Price 
Where Eagles Dare  [1968] [DVD]

Where Eagles Dare [1968] [DVD]

Scorned by reviewers when it came out,Where Eagles Darehas acquired a cult following over ... more

the years for its unashamed and highly
concentrated dose of commando death-dealing to
legions of Nazi machine-gun fodder. In 1968 Clint
Eastwood was just getting ...

amazon marketplace dvd

Postage & Packaging£1.21
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace d...
Where Eagles Dare  [1968] [DVD]

Where Eagles Dare [1968] [DVD]

Scorned by reviewers when it came out,Where Eagles Darehas acquired a cult following over ... more

the years for its unashamed and highly
concentrated dose of commando death-dealing to
legions of Nazi machine-gun fodder. In 1968 Clint
Eastwood was just getting ...

amazon dvd

Postage & PackagingFree!
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1 to 3 weeks...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon dvd
Where Eagles Dare (War Collection) DVD

Where Eagles Dare (War Collection) DVD

Commandos posing as German soldiers parachute into a small mountainside town to rescue a ... more

supposed allied general from a Nazi hideaway
fortress that can only be reached by cable car.

play.com (films)

Postage & Packaging£0.00
Availability3-5 working days
 Visit Shop  >
play.com (films)
Where Eagles Dare-DVD

Where Eagles Dare-DVD

thehut.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityIn stock - Usually dispatched within 24 hours - We cannot guarantee Christmas delivery...
 Visit Shop  >
thehut.com


More reviews »

Where Eagles Dare (DVD) - review by TheNeil

Advantages: Great mix of action, adventure, and mystery
Disadvantages: Long

Where Eagles Dare (DVD) - review by TheNeil TheNeil 21.03.2001 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Where Eagles Dare (DVD)

Where Eagles Dare (DVD) - review by cyberian1969

Advantages: Great action, plot full of twists, Burton and Eastwod
Disadvantages: Dont Expect a Classic

Where Eagles Dare (DVD) - review by cyberian1969 cyberian1969 17.01.2006 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Where Eagles Dare (DVD)

Where Eagles Dare (DVD) - review by Vixterbelle

Advantages: Brilliant, engaging, classic
Disadvantages: None!

Where Eagles Dare (DVD) - review by Vixterbelle Vixterbelle 28.03.2009 (27.03.2009) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Where Eagles Dare (DVD)

Where Eagles Dare (DVD) - review by jimbuck

Advantages: Great entertainment
Disadvantages: Only for the Germans

Where Eagles Dare (DVD) - review by jimbuck jimbuck 02.05.2001 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Where Eagles Dare (DVD)

Where Eagles Dare (DVD) - review by rvb13

Advantages: Brilliant story forged with Burton and Eastwood
Disadvantages: none

Where Eagles Dare (DVD) - review by rvb13 rvb13 25.06.2001 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Where Eagles Dare (DVD)



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Where Eagles Dare (DVD)? Click here