For power and honour, two worlds will go to war, thousands will fall in pursuit of the glory. A nation will burn to the ground, and all for love...
This is Homer's story, a Greek writer and philosopher from 800BC, his famous Iliad, which is a mixture of Homer's opinions, mythology and fact.
Troy is a movie written by David Benioff, and loosely based on Homer's epic tale. A two and a half hour epic (UK: 163 min / Germany:162 min cut version, and is directed by Wolfgang Petersen, who is himself, no stranger to blockbuster movies, with such movies as, The Perfect Storm, Outbreak and Air Force One, among his successes. Now if you have lived under a rock all your life, and have no idea what the Iliad is, then first I will tell you a little about it, so that you will have a better understanding of the review.
In the Iliad, a plague is inflicted on Achilles' fellow warriors, killing hundreds of them, for which Agamemnon is responsible, this being instigated by Apollo. Of course, in the film, this is omitted, and a trivial reason for the feud between Achilles and Agamemnon is set up, which really doesn't bear any weight. A big beefy warrior, Achilles, would have been unlikely to have acted so, over such a trifle. The half Human, half god, Achilles fights for glory, for vanity, and power. His reputation is the factor that spurs on Agamemnon's armies.
Also, a much more important piece of information
is omitted from the film, which would have easier explained the reason Helen left her husband suddenly for the young Prince of Troy, once a humble shepherd. The Iliad tells us, Zeus chose Paris as the catalyst for the destruction of Troy, because he chose Aphrodite as the fairest Goddess at the wedding of Achilles' parents, Thetis the Goddess, and Peleus, a mortal. Aphrodite rewards Paris with the love of the most beautiful mortal woman, Helen of Sparta. With this vital piece of information missing, it is hard to see just why Helen leaves her husband, for Paris, and instead of some solid reason, we are given some silly love story.
Then we get a power hungry tyrant (Agamemnon) sending the ships to conquer Troy, instead of 1000 ships being launched because the rulers of Greece had pledged to come to Helen’s aid, as is told in Homer's epic. We all know the saying, the face that launched a 1000 ships. So the story is set up as the Trojans being the good guys in the fight, and the Greeks being the bad guys. Incidentally, the scene in which Achilles cries at the death of his cousin Patroclus again omits to tell the audience the severity of the situation, which is that Patroclus is Achilles lover according to the Greek tale. Also omitted was the real reason Achilles wanted revenge on Hector, and why Achilles acted the way he did after the battle scene with Hector. If the audience were clued up on this, it would have made sense.
Now, having pointed out the missing plot details, what did the film have to offer the cinema going audience? Well, much of the original story actually does remain intact. We do see the young prince Paris, played by Orlando Bloom, steal Helen away from her husband, King Menelaus, and the Greeks do send 1000 ships to attack the fabulous city of Troy. Also Achilles, does indeed argue with Agamemnon over a woman, and refuse to fight again, that is, until someone close to his heart dies, then he flexes those muscles once more. And the most famous part, the wooden horse, an idea born of Odysseus in the tale, the downfall of Troy, does appear.
Petersen, having to condense a ten year story into one single movie, has done a mean job of it. I feel the critics and purists are rather harsh on him, and if a definitive film adaptation of Homer’s The Iliad, is what you crave, then this is not for you. But, on the other hand, if good old fashioned escapism without too much to think about is more what you are after, look no further, you will enjoy it. Yeah, sure, it deviates from the original path, but who said it shouldn't? Who says it has to faithfully represent Homer's poem? This is Hollywood, remember? They didn't set out to make a documentary, they made a movie, 'based' on the tale, and did a fine job of it too. I wish that he had included the gods though, that's the only down part for me.
The cinematography and elaborate CGI sets, added to the rich feel of the film, and though they staged this with daylight shots, the footage is perfectly put together. Seeing all those troops on Troy's beach was quite a sight to see, as were the fleet of ships sent on the invasion. Rumour has it, Peterson had around $185 to spend on the sets in England, Malta and Mexico. The production had to move from Morocco to Mexico, because of the war in Iraq.
Of all the characters, Achilles was the most profound, and whatever the critics have to say, Pitt, in his new beefed up bronzed body, certainly shone through. Maybe at last, he will be taken seriously as an actor. Goodness knows, he has tried for so long. He did a fine job as the half Immortal, adding some complex emotions to the character, even, dare I say, some humanity. Achilles with emotions? Come on! Yes, it is true, Peterson fixed Achilles up with a very complex set of emotions along with that bronzed body, and I think it worked pretty well.
I think the chosen actors did a splendid job with their respected characters, with the exception of Orlando Bloom, who I feel was very out of place, and didn't do his character justice. Paris was very dull, and one could not share sympathy for him, a shame, because the young Prince deserved it, having to live in his brother Hector's shadow. Trying to live up to his father's expectation of him, and his brothers reputation, must have been hard. A different actor playing Paris, may have made that more apparent than Bloom did. Instead, Paris appeared as a wimpy bore, and quite frankly, I couldn't have cared less whether he lived or died.
It was quite a different matter when Hector took on the lengendary Achilles. That fight scene was the highlight of the whole film. Hector is Troy's own hero, magnificently played by Eric Bana, and is O'Toole's real life son, and I also have to say at this point, Peter O'Toole can still cut the mustard. Here is a polished actor, showing, at 72, how to win over the audience. I found his humble speech, appealing to Achilles to show compassion, very moving. What a superb piece of acting from the old guy. He brought King Priam to life. Such class, well done sir!
Troy, set 3,200 years ago, will certainly become one of the classics. It was superbly made, and makes a compelling story, set against some wonderful vistas. Beefcake men, beautiful ladies, stunning scenery, epic battles and political intrigue, what more could you want? I found it to be a very watchable film. Yes, Peterson omitted some key parts of Homer's poem, but at the end of the day, it doesn't matter. What matters is, a great film was born, and is certainly worthy of anyones attention. Settle down with your popcorn and cola, make yourself comfy, and be prepared to be entertained.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Production Year: 2002 - Action/Adventure - Director: Vincenzo Natali - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring:Lucy Liu, David Hewlett, Anne Marie Scheffler, Joseph Scoren, Matthew Sharp, Jeremy Northam
Production Year: 1964 - Action/Adventure - Director: Cyril Endfield - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring:Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, James Booth, Michael Caine, Nigel Green
Critics slated it - but after reading this i will give it a go. nice 1 :D
blackbeard 01.12.2004 00:41
I've wanted to see this film for some time, great review, need to catch it soon.
Cheers
Allan
rocksthatkill 21.11.2004 01:19
I enjoyed reading the review more than i enjoyed the film, thought it was very long winded & a bit boring (and Im a proper history nerd...) anyway good review :-)
There are many reasons to recommendTroyas a good ol' fashioned Hollywood epic, especially ... more
if you've never read Homer's The Iliad. Dispensing with Greek gods altogether, this earnestly massive production (budgeted at upwards of $200 million) will surely...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
For honour... In 1193B.C. the dandy Trojan prince Paris (Bloom) irresponsibly spirits ... more
away the unhappy wife of Menelaus (Gleeson) the Spartan king. Demanding the return of Helen the Greeks launch a thousand ships and lay siege to Troy. Under the com...
Postage & Packaging: £0.00 Availability: 3-5 working days
Advantages: Fantastic cinematography, Great acting by Bana and Pitt especially, Gripping battle sequences Disadvantages: Bloom and Bean's performances are flawed , Slightly over-long