Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
SHOPPING > DVDs > Action & Adventure > Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) > Reviews

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)

from (4 offers) · Product Information

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)

Quote-start

Of Horse And Heel

Quote-end

3 Jun 30th, 2004 

90 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Impressive battle scenes, Agamemnon

Disadvantages:
Brad Pitt doesn't work and Eric Bana gets picked on too much

Recommendable No:

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

Soundtrack

LostWitness

LostWitness

About me:

'Allo! I'm not contributing to Ciao for the time being but if you are bored / desperate / weird enou...

Member since:15.07.2000

Reviews:694

Members who trust:826

Whilst on a diplomatic trip into the Aegean Sea, a young Trojan prince, Paris, has embarked on a passionate affair with the wife of King Menelaus of Sparta, Helen. Such is the strength of their feeling toward one another that they decide that they can no longer bear to be separated and when Paris sets sail in the morning with his elder brother Hector, Helen is stowed away on board. When Menelaus realises that his young bride has gone missing he quickly finds out that she has sailed away with the Trojans, and in a blind rage he engages the support of his brother Agamemnon to declare war on the Trojans. Agamemnon is fairly delighted at the prospect of further increasing the size of his empire and readily agrees to the proposal. But Agamemnon’s chief advisor is quick to remind him that his previous victories have generally been as a result of one warrior named Achilles. Without Achilles, Agamemnon’s chances are greatly reduced, but he and the impetuous young fighter remain estranged and neither is inclined to forgive the other. Finally, with the involvement of the king of Ithaca, Odysseus, Achilles agrees to fight for Agamemnon and the stage is set for one of the greatest battles of all time – the siege of Troy. But victory for Agamemnon will not be the easy task that he suspects.

I’ve toyed with going to see this film for several weeks since it opened in UK cinemas. There were a number of things that appealed to me about it, but I had this nagging feeling that I would be disappointed and I was right. The finished product was too long, too superficial and completely unsatisfying from a characterisation point of view. There are moments of greatness but my lasting impression after three hours of cinematic budget blowing was only that women really do have a lot to answer for.

Troy was always going to be a showcase for its leading characters but even I was unprepared for the superficial nature of much of the film. The film really isn’t far short of being an advertising vehicle for the semi-naked bodies of three of Hollywood’s most fancied actors. This is fine, up to a point, but in much the same way that you grew tired of those slow motion sequences of Pamela Anderson’s breasts bouncing across Baywatch, Troy started to become really rather dull. This isn’t helped by a number of other different factors.

Firstly, I found the character of Achilles completely unattractive and his behaviour throughout the whole film was utterly reprehensible. I’m guessing that this wasn’t entirely accidental of course, but it stopped the film developing that real feeling of good versus evil. In Gladiator, for example, you really knew whom it was that you wanted to root for. In Troy, you never really have this satisfaction. Achilles is arrogant, aggressive and utterly in love with himself, and I really didn’t enjoy seeing Brad Pitt playing this role at all.

Other characters are also equally misplaced. Sean Bean’s continuing cinematic popularity continues to astound me and here he gives a fine performance of a Yorkshire-man cum Greek king. Hmm. Orlando Bloom is quite fetching as the young prince Paris, but I never felt as though he had any real conviction – he seemed to be there to make up the numbers. Eric Bana’s Prince Hector is infinitely more likeable than any of the other characters but this only means that his eventual demise is all the more distressing. To be honest, it was more the elder members of the cast that interested me. The war-mongering Agamemnon and his caustic commentary felt much more at home than Brad Pitt’s preening and posturing through an American accent that was held at bay only by his gritted white teeth.

The story is also rather slow and very depressing. If ever a film portrayed the pointlessness of war then this is it, and it’s interesting to see that the motives behind most conflicts were as superficial back then as they are now. Much of the story failed to make any sense to me. I couldn’t understand why people did what they did from a tactical perspective and victory seems only to come as a result of pure luck, rather than clear judgement. The climactic arrival of the famous Trojan horse really puzzled me and quite why any such ludicrous plan was ever successful, I shall never really know. I probably have far too logical a way of looking at things but at a time when Man was still rather primitive and guided by instinct it all seems rather strange to me.

The battle scenes ARE quite impressive. Hordes of Greek ships crossing the sea make for a stunning aerial shot and the scale of things simply has to be admired. I felt that the director’s vision was appropriate to the story and that whilst he was adventurous he was also realistic. The terrain is therefore used to great effect. There is one particularly effective scene, for example, where the Trojans use a couple of nifty tricks to bombard the Greek soldiers camped out on the beaches. The large-scale scenes of combat are also very effective although it has to be said that at times the action is so fast and noisy that you lose any real feeling of being able to see what’s going on. There is lots of swordplay, some quite brutal hand-to-hand combat and the usual devastation caused by hundreds of men running at hundreds of other men holding spears and spikes. These are battle scenes that thrive on quantity and chaos rather than detail and perfection.

Troy never touches on the slightly mythical quality that I had expected either. Don’t get me wrong – I wasn’t expecting Jason and the Argonauts 2 or anything – but the whole Gods and Mortals thing is really played down in this film. Whilst the Trojans are frequently portrayed as being superstitious and respectful towards their Gods, the film does its best to show how futile this behaviour is. I had expected something a little more uplifting from Troy. A suggestion perhaps or just a moment of mystery. But this never happened and in fact the director seemed intent on showing just how pointless Man’s obsession with Gods really is.

It’s also impossible to review this film without commenting on the fact that there is a love story at the heart of it all. Sadly, Helen and Paris’s affair is rather too brisk to be endearing. This isn’t one of those romances that is built up gradually and carefully and this makes the intensity of it all slightly overpowering. I did find it very difficult to accept Bloom as a convincing Paris and as such what should have been passionate, moving dialogue was instead rather stale and scripted.

At nearly three hours in running time, I was surprised to find that these criticisms aside, I never really grew bored of this film. Despite the inevitable and sometimes rather cliched storytelling there always seemed to be enough to keep me interested. There were very few lengthy scenes and as such things tended to keep bobbing along, albeit in a rather superficial way. Some of the battle scenes warranted the film’s 15 certification but otherwise the content would be fairly suitable for all. This will make great Christmas Day television in a few years’ time and to be honest I wouldn’t suggest that you hurry to see it before then.

But until then, I’d probably have to say not recommended.
 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

The Matrix (DVD)

The Matrix (DVD)

(+) Great story, action & special effects
(-) Slow starting

User reviews (242)

Buy now for only £ 5.00

The A-Team - Series 4 (Box Set) (DVD)

The A-Team - Series 4 (Box Set) (DVD)

Action/Adventure - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring:Mr T, Dirk Benedict, George Peppard, Dwight Schultz

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 0.01

Fight Club (DVD) Cypher (DVD)

Cypher (DVD)

Production Year: 2002 - Action/Adventure - Director: Vincenzo Natali - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring:Lucy Liu, David Hewlett, Anne Marie Scheffler, Joseph Scoren, Matthew Sharp, Jeremy Northam

User reviews (2)

Buy now for only £ 1.98

Pirates Of The Caribbean - The Curse Of The Black Pearl (DVD)

Pirates Of The Caribbean - The Curse Of The Black Pearl (DVD)

(+) its is just an excellant film ... what more can i say?
(-) it is in my opionion addictive

User reviews (167)

Buy now for only £ 4.50

Zulu (DVD)

Zulu (DVD)

Production Year: 1964 - Action/Adventure - Director: Cyril Endfield - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring:Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, James Booth, Michael Caine, Nigel Green

User reviews (14)

Buy now for only £ 0.58

Comments about this review »

kelr101 05.03.2006 19:48

I'm about to watch the film this evening, and appreciate an honest perspective. kels x

retrobabe1971 06.10.2005 21:41

Great review, i prefered gladiator myself , Brad pitt just didnt give his best in this other than that i found it watchable.

pdoyle007 21.04.2005 16:08

great film, I felt bad for Hector

Compare prices for Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) »

1 to 4 out of 4 offers for Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)   sorted by: Price 
Troy : The Movie&More (2 Disc Special Edition) [2004] [DVD]

Troy : The Movie&More (2 Disc Special Edition) [2004] [DVD]

Release Date: 2006-08-07, Rating Suitable for 15 years and over,

amazon marketplace dvd

Postage & Packaging£1.21
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace d...
Troy (2-Disc Edition) [DVD] [2004]

Troy (2-Disc Edition) [DVD] [2004]

There are many reasons to recommendTroyas a good ol' fashioned Hollywood epic, especially ... more

if you've never read Homer's The Iliad. Dispensing
with Greek gods altogether, this earnestly massive
production (budgeted at upwards of $200 million)
will surely...

amazon marketplace dvd

Postage & Packaging£1.21
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace d...
Troy (2 Discs) DVD

Troy (2 Discs) DVD

For honour... In 1193B.C. the dandy Trojan prince Paris (Bloom) irresponsibly spirits ... more

away the unhappy wife of Menelaus (Gleeson)  the
Spartan king. Demanding the return of Helen  the
Greeks launch a thousand ships and lay siege to
Troy. Under the com...

play.com (films)

Postage & Packaging£0.00
Availability3-5 working days
 Visit Shop  >
play.com (films)


More reviews »

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) - review by magdadh

Advantages: Looks great in all aspects, entertaining
Disadvantages: Simplified, some bad casting and lines

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) - review by magdadh magdadh 25.06.2005 (25.06.2005) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) - review by CaptainDisaster

Advantages: Fantastic cinematography, Great acting by Bana and Pitt especially, Gripping battle sequences
Disadvantages: Bloom and Bean's performances are flawed , Slightly over-long

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) - review by CaptainDisaster CaptainDisaster 22.07.2005 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) - review by afy9mab

Advantages: Nice costumes
Disadvantages: Dodgy accents, dodgy effects and acting more wooden than the horse

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) - review by afy9mab afy9mab 15.06.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) - review by DarkMark

Advantages: engaging battles
Disadvantages: not entirly true to the "illiard", flawed

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) - review by DarkMark DarkMark 07.06.2004 (07.06.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) - review by frkurt

Advantages: Majestic and sweeping
Disadvantages: A 'corruption' of the original story

Troy (Special Edition) (DVD) - review by frkurt frkurt 20.05.2004 (20.05.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Troy (Special Edition) (DVD)? Click here