Abby Barnes (Janeane Garofalo) is a successful radio broadcaster; her daily show "The Truth About Cats & Dogs" helps hundreds of listeners with their pet problems, from over friendly cat's too depressed goldfish. When professional photographer Brian (Ben Chaplin) phones up with a troublesome dog on roller skates, Abby duly talks him through how to calm the free wheeling dog down and out of gratitude for her good advice; Brian invites her out for drinks. Self-conscious about her appearance and being only just over 5 foot, she agrees to go out but gives Brian the description of her neighbour Noelle (Uma Thurman) a tall, slim model.
When Abby explains to Noelle about the deception, she agrees to go along with the plan to help her friend out. Brian has no idea that he is being deceived and after long romantic conversations with the witty Abby on the phone and going out on dates with the beautiful Noelle, he believes he has found the perfect woman. But things start to go wrong when Noelle starts to fall for Brian and the two women start co compete for his attention.
The Truth About Cats & Dogs is a fun, lighthearted, romantic, comedy which draws on the famous story of Cyrano de Bergerac but adds to it, its own twists. Although this storyline is somewhat predictable, and has been used in many other more commercially successful films such as "Roxanne", this film still manages to entertain you through it's light hearted nature and it's brilliantly funny performances.
What is very surprising about this film is that for a romantic, comedy it is not overly sentimental, which I found a pleasant change compared to other films in this genre.
The focus of the film is Abby Barnes the self-conscious pet expert who believes her looks and lack of height won't appeal to her date. In my opinion, she comes over as a far more attractive person than that of Noelle the model who becomes her face for the dates. A lot of the humour in this film comes from her witty repartee with her unsuspecting date, Brian. On top of this, there are some extremely visually funny scenes, starting off with Brian trying to pacify a Great Dane on roller skates. Plus the hilarious scene where Noelle, pretending to be a pet expert, has to perform a rather strange procedure on a tortoise to get it to pop its head out of its shell.
Remembering that this film is a comedy and so the boundaries of believability are always going to be pushed. The only criticism I can have is how on earth does Brian not realize that the tall, sexy Noelle is in fact not Abby. I know within the film they come up with a lame excuse for the difference in the voices, but surely he would question why the beautiful woman he dates can't string an intellectual conversation together, but can talk quite diligently for ages on the phone. This just pushed the boundaries of believability too far, even for such a good comedy.
The lead role of Abby Barnes, the radio pet specialist, is masterfully played by Janeane Garofalo (Cop Land) and a lot of the enjoyment in this film comes from her performance. The numerous witty one-liners that she delivers are excellent, and you can't help but laugh at her dry put downs. As Noelle, the good looking neighbour is Uma Thurman (Kill Bill) and although she doesn't have many funny lines, her performance as a model and wannabe news reader is brilliant. Her performance typifies the stereotypical model who is not very clever and doesn't eat anything, as demonstrated in her line:
"I don't eat anything so I can look good on the outside, but on the inside, there's nothing."
As Brian, the man caught unwittingly in the middle of the deception, is Ben Chaplin (Murder By Numbers), who comes over as handsome, tender and charming. Too be honest there isn't much too the character of Brian, except that he is very likeable and a bit shy around women. Undoubtedly Chaplin's best scene is the one where he has a 7 hour conversation with Abby over the phone, which culminates in them having phone sex. Of course the supporting cast all play important roles in keeping the film moving none more than Brian's best friend Ed played by Jamie Foxx (Ray) who advises him on his relationship.
The Truth About Cats & Dogs is directed by Michael Lehmann who has also directed "Hudson Hawk", "Heathers" and "40 Days and 40 Nights". Personally I feel that this is his best directional outing, as he has let the story take centre stage and the performances and comedy just add too it, rather than detract. Although the soundtrack is not overly special, it is full of the easy listening romantic fodder that you would expect from any decent romantic, comedy.
= The Cast =======
Janeane Garofalo .... Abby Ben Chaplin .... Brian Uma Thurman .... Noelle Jamie Foxx .... Ed James McCaffrey .... Roy Richard Coca .... Eric Stanley DeSantis .... Mario Dechen Thurman .... Bookstore Cashier
Certificate: 15 Length: 97 mins Originally released: 1996
*****************************======= Bonus Material =============
For such an enjoyable film, it is a huge disappointment that the only extras on the DVD, consists of the theatrical trailer for the film itself, along with a couple of trailers for other films.
*****************************======================= The Message & Christian View Point =============================
The message that this film clearly delivers is that beauty is more than skin deep. Although the character of Noelle came across as being stereotypically beautiful, the real beauty in the film came from the character of Abby. Although by no means an ugly duckling herself, she felt that because she didn't match up to the stereotypes displayed on the front of magazines and on the bill boards, that she was unattractive. In reality, her beauty was more than skin deep, as her inner kindness, fun and an interest in others made for a much more appealing package.
The Truth About Cats & Dogs is one of those films, that although is starting to feel dated, still manages to keep you entertained and leaves you with a feel good feeling at the end. A favourite amongst couples on its original cinematic release, I would still say it would appeal to the same demographic now. On that note I would recommend this to anyone who wants a nice film too watch with a loved one, or to anyone who is an old romantic at heart.
The Truth About Cats & Dogs is available on Amazon for £6.97 which is a bit expensive, seeing that there is a lack of any real extras. So I would recommend shopping round too see if you can get this for around the £5.00 mark.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Comedy - Director: Terry Jones, Terry Gilliam - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Carol Cleveland, Eric Idle, Graham Chapman, Terry Gilliam, John Cleese, Michael Palin, Terry Jones
Comedy - Director: Richard Boden, Mandie Fletcher, Martin Shardlow - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Hugh Laurie, Miranda Richardson, Stephen Fry, Brian Blessed, Tim McInnerny, Tony Robinson, Rowan Atkinson
Production Year: 2004 - Comedy - Director: John Hay - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Jennifer Love Hewitt, Jimi Mistry, Kate Miles, Dougray Scott
Comedy - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring: Tessa Peake-Jones, Buster Merryfield, David Jason, Nicholas Lyndhurst
This sounds amusing but I won't be going out of my way to watch it. I think I'd be annoyed that it's obvious that his date isn't who he's been chatting to on the phone.
evilfran 19.06.2006 22:01
i really enjoyed this film, good review
tekin21 18.03.2006 10:53
Not sure if I have seen this or not, the storyline sounds familiar although it obviously didn’t make a lasting impression on me. Jane x
One of the most memorably offbeat romantic comedies of the 1990s begins when a talk-radio ... more
veterinarian named Abby (Janeane Garofalo) takes a call from Brian (Ben Chaplin), the owner of a roller-skating Great Dane. Brian is intrigued by Abby's voice and...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
One of the most memorably offbeat romantic comedies of the 1990s begins when a talk-radio ... more
veterinarian named Abby (Janeane Garofalo) takes a call from Brian (Ben Chaplin), the owner of a roller-skating Great Dane. Brian is intrigued by Abby's voice and...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
Abby, a witty veterinarian who hosts her own radio talk show, is anything but confident ... more
when it comes to men. When a smitten caller named Brian (Ben Chaplin) asks her on a date, she begs her beautiful neighbor, Noelle (Uma Thurman), to take her place. ...
Charming and bittersweet this modern-day romantic comedy starring Uma Thurman Janeane ... more
Garofalo and Ben Chaplin explores the beguiling perils of mistaken identity. Abby a gutsy and witty veterinarian who hosts her own radio talk show is anything ...
Postage & Packaging: £0.00 Availability: 3-5 working days