Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
SHOPPING > DVDs > Action & Adventure > The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) > Reviews

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD)

from (3 offers) · Product Information

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD)

Quote-start

The best films ever made, all in one stunning box!

Quote-end

5 May 11th, 2009 

16 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
see review !

Disadvantages:
none

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

Soundtrack

bruffyboy

bruffyboy

About me:

Member since:01.11.2008

Reviews:186

Members who trust:16

Here, in one brilliant box-set, come the three extended editions of the Lord of the Rings – the absolute ‘must-have’ product for all fans of the films. Not only do we have the extended versions of the films, but also each one is packed with behind the scenes documentaries and photo galleries, commentaries and much much more.

PART 1: THE FELLOWSHIP OF THE RING

THE PREMISE:
First off, I am a huge fan of Tolkien, and have read a lot of his work, so I came to this film with a degree of apprehension as well as excitement. 'The Fellowship of the Ring' is the first part of 'The Lord of the Rings' trilogy of books. The most read fiction work ever, LOTR is a fantasy that is so deep and detailed that it feels real. Tolkien spent years and years writing it, and so any film version needed to be a serious undertaking: Peter Jackson rose to the challenge.

THE STORY:
The film begins in Hobbiton, home of Frodo, Bilbo, Sam, Merry and Pippin the Hobbits. Just like in the book, a fair amount of time is spent showing the natural simplicity of Hobbit life. Whilst this is important, in that it shows us just what is at risk of being lost, it does drag on a bit. Things eventually heat up with the discovery of the One Ring, a magical ring that the evil lord Sauron is hunting down to regain the supreme power he once had. Frodo sets off on a long and dangerous journey to destroy the ring. He is accompanied by three other Hobbits, but is soon joined by a whole host of races - Elf, man, dwarf and wizard accompany him in his journey. Together, their travels bring them into dangerous territories that they must successfully battle through in order to survive. In this movie, the first of three, the journey takes them to Rivendell, the beautiful home of the Elves. From there it's onto the deep dark mines of Moria, where Orcs and a Balrog are set to make things tough, and finally there's a meeting with Galadriel before the film's close.

WHAT'S GOOD ABOUT IT:
1) The location is beautiful - set in New Zealand, the film is visually stunning. From snow peaked mountains to lush green valleys, it's a marvel to look at.
2) The CGI - cutting edge computer animation is fused with the aforementioned location to produce some wonderful scenes like nothing seen before or since.
3) The story - largely faithful to Tolkien's original, the story is a masterpiece on every level, with just the right mix of action, adventure, and even fun along the way.
4) The acting - a largely unknown cast do a stellar job with every role well acted, and some amazing.

At 208 minutes in length, this is a long film, but it's entirely captivating. I remember watching it in the cinema and being so gutted it was another year to wait for part 2.

As well as the extended version of the film, you also have hours and hours of DVD extras with this edition. These include 4 complete commentaries over the film (very informative).

There are then two discs full of documentaries, photo galleries, and interview after interview about Tolkien, the book, turning the book into the film, the model making etc etc. I used a lot of this for my Uni dissertation and it really is just mind-blowingly fantastic.

IF YOU LIKED IT: You will have to watch the following two movies 'The Two Towers' and 'The Return of the King'. The Chronicles of Narnia series is a much lower quality stab at a similar genre, and seems to satisfy many (but not me).

PART TWO: THE TWO TOWERS
Carrying straight on from where 'The Fellowship of the Ring' left off, 'The Two Towers' follows Frodo and friends in three different groups. First up, Sam and Frodo journey ever closer to Mount Doom, and encounter Gollum along the way. Secondly, Merry and Pippin have lost their sense of fun as they are held captive by Orcs of Saruman, and thirdly, Aaragorn, Legolas and Gimli are hot on their heels to rescue them.

The split narrative is a little off-putting at times, as you just want to get back to the main story (which differs at varying points). Strangely, the most interesting part of the story revolves around Aaragorn and his crew, and the Battle at Helm's Deep. The kingdom of Rohan is under siege, and the retreat to the safe haven of Helm's Deep produces an unprecedented forty minute battle scene. Yes, for a whole forty minutes, you get to see one of the most exciting battle scenes ever put to film. What makes it even more amazing, is the whole thing was shot at night, with the cast and crew becoming completely exhausted in the process.

New characters are introduced, and more of the religious themes become apparent in this movie, particularly the exorcism of evil spirits from the King of Rohan. Other new characters include Treebeard, a walking talking tree that somehow doesn't seem corny or stupid. Of course, I speak as one who knows the books, and it may seem one bridge too far to have a talking tree.

Talking about the book, the film is (again) largely faithful to the original text, although the portrayal of Faramir differs; Peter Jackson felt Tolkien's original account of Faramir was unrealistic, which I have to say annoyed me about him, but it doesn't change the overall story too much.

The deeper part of the movie comes in the developing relationship of Frodo and Sam, although action lovers may feel frustrated with the subtlety and just want to get back to the battle at hand.

Once again, the CGI is top notch, particularly the Warg riders, and coupled with the beautiful scenery of New Zealand, it's a visual masterpiece. Much has been said about the cutting edge technology used to create the creature Gollum, and it really is amazing, but I'll let you make your own mind up about that.

PART 3: THE RETURN OF THE KING

WHAT IS IT ABOUT:
As in The Two Towers, there's a split narrative in ROTK: Frodo, Sam and Gollum are within spitting distance of Mount Doom and the destruction of the One Ring. Gandalf teams up with King Theoden to protect Minas Tirith against the armies of Sauron, and Aaragorn must summon the army of the dead to battle for him, but will all this be enough?

WAS IT ANY GOOD:
To be fair, you know by now whether you like these films or not, and if you do this is the biggest and best of all in many respects. Once again, the beautiful landscape of New Zealand combines with state of the art CGI to produce a film visually marvellous to behold. With amost 1500 visual effects shots, it's a thing of beauty to behold.

The film sticks almost totally to Tolkien's original text, which is nice to see, particularly as the first two films made significant changes to the text. Fans of the book may miss 'the scouring of the Shire', but the film manages well without it, and doesn't have the time to put it in anyway: at 201 minutes, it's an epic movie, but the pace never slows, as the adventure rushes towards its final show-down.

After two years of watching these films, it's a very sad ending: one that is reflected on screen as much loved characters say their final farewells. Peter Jackson and co have produced a film that will surely stand the test of time, and never become outdated.
 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

The Lord Of The Rings - The Two Towers (DVD)

The Lord Of The Rings - The Two Towers (DVD)

(+) Yet more great special effects
(-) far too long & dull

User reviews (202)

Buy now for only £ 4.43

Zulu (DVD)

Zulu (DVD)

Production Year: 1964 - Action/Adventure - Director: Cyril Endfield - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring:Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, James Booth, Michael Caine, Nigel Green

User reviews (14)

Buy now for only £ 0.55

Swordfish (DVD)

Swordfish (DVD)

Production Year: 2001 - Action/Adventure - Director: Dominic Sena - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring:John Travolta, Hugh Jackman, Halle Berry, Don Cheadle, Sam Shepard, Vinnie Jones, Camryn Grimes, Zach Grenier

User reviews (56)

Buy now for only £ 2.48

Cypher (DVD)

Cypher (DVD)

Production Year: 2002 - Action/Adventure - Director: Vincenzo Natali - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring:Lucy Liu, David Hewlett, Anne Marie Scheffler, Joseph Scoren, Matthew Sharp, Jeremy Northam

User reviews (2)

Buy now for only £ 1.98

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Box Set) (DVD)

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Box Set) (DVD)

(+) best dvd collection you can own,
(-) need plenty of time to see the film

User reviews (14)

Buy now for only £ 8.14

The A-Team - Series 4 (Box Set) (DVD)

The A-Team - Series 4 (Box Set) (DVD)

Action/Adventure - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring:Mr T, Dirk Benedict, George Peppard, Dwight Schultz

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 0.01

Comments about this review »

redeyes22 12.05.2009 13:12

great review aggy xxx

thereddragon 12.05.2009 11:30

I love these films. I went to see the first of these not expecting much, as I'd never read the book and had always thought it was just some silly kids' story, but was so wrong and now they're three of my favourite films!

midpikyrozziy 11.05.2009 22:22

Nice review, I loved these

Compare prices for The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) »

1 to 3 out of 3 offers for The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD)   sorted by: Price 
The Lord Of The Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy - Special Extended DVD Edition (12 Discs ...

The Lord Of The Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy - Special Extended DVD Edition (12 Discs ...

The Fellowship Of The Ring: In a time before history in a place called Middle-earth a ... more

dark and powerful lord has brought together the
forces of evil to destroy its cultures and enslave
all life caught in his path. Sauron's time has
come and he needs ...

play.com (films)

Postage & Packaging£0.00
Availability3-5 working days
 Visit Shop  >
play.com (films)
The Lord Of The Rings: The Trilogy [Extended Ed.][12 Discs]-DVD

The Lord Of The Rings: The Trilogy [Extended Ed.][12 Discs]-DVD

thehut.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityIn stock - Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
thehut.com


More reviews »

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) - review by david_1967

Advantages: 17 Academy Awards and 247 other awards - say no more
Disadvantages: You may forget to eat!

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) - review by david_1967 david_1967 28.03.2008 (28.03.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD)

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) - review by rip_geoff

Advantages: Rarely do films of this calibre come along
Disadvantages: Requires a lot of popcorn!

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) - review by rip_geoff rip_geoff 02.12.2005 (05.12.2005) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD)

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) - review by insight2005

Advantages: A new insight into the world of film
Disadvantages: None (Lots of time is needed!)

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) - review by insight2005 insight2005 17.08.2005 (17.08.2005) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD)

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) - review by danfellowes

Advantages: Amazing Detail, Funny, Groundbreaking
Disadvantages: May be too long for some people

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) - review by danfellowes danfellowes 15.05.2007 (18.05.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD)

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) - review by I_only_like_good_movies

Advantages: Everything--virtually perfect!
Disadvantages: it had to end :(

The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD) - review by I_only_like_good_movies I_only_like_good_movies 06.09.2007 (06.09.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD)



Are you the manufacturer / provider of The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (Extended Editions) (DVD)? Click here