The Invasion (DVD)

Review of

The Invasion (DVD)

Overall rating (3): Overall user rating The Invasion (DVD)

 

All The Invasion (DVD) reviews

 Write your own review


 


 


Idea Evasion

2 Nov 5th, 2007

Advantages:
A couple of nice performances .

Disadvantages:
A film unwilling to commit to a single idea or style .

Recommendable: No 

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

more


afy9mab

About me: Why does the damned site keep logging me out when I'm trying to upload reviews?!?

Member since:11.07.2000

Reviews:771

Members who trust:81

Review rated by 21 Ciao members on average: very helpful

When a space shuttle crash lands, those that come into contact with the wreckage begin to change into something not quite human. Psychiatrist Carol Bennell and her friend Ben Driscoll learn the truth about the alien epidemic, which attacks its victims in their sleep and renders them emotionless and inhuman. As the infection spreads, Carol fights to stay awake, desperate to find her young son, who may hold the key to halting its progress.

"Downfall" director Oliver Hirschbiegel changes tack for this update of the science fiction classic "Invasion of the Body Snatchers". Sadly his inexperience in sci-fi shows in a film that has potential but never commits to an idea. The original is a movie of creeping paranoia, where the everyday slowly becomes alien. But the director is too anxious to get to the nuts and bolts of the science fiction concept as you can tell from the flash cut intro. It shows a confusing series of images and whispers to show how nightmarish Carol's life will become. This kills the tension, as does the director's habit of using flashbacks to things we've seen more moments before. It feels like the audience is being treated like idiots. Then we're taken through a bunch of news stories about the shuttle crash before going back to her everyday life. Hiirschbiegel doesn't make enough of the gradual transformation of the populace into inhuman drones. The obvious thing would be to show Carol going through her daily routine several times with the presence of the infected becoming more patent every time. So you would go from a rowdy day in the city to ones where fewer and fewer and fewer people were behaving normally. In the director's hands it appears that the world falls in a couple of days without a fight. This is in stark contrast to a handful of relatively tense chase sequences that would fit into any action movie. But the director doesn't follow through - so you often feel cheated.

The pacing stutters and you're never sure what sort of movie you're watching. The director is too dispassionate about his characters for it to be a drama, there's little exploration of the science fiction concepts and though there are a few nasty moments, there isn't enough creeping menace for it to be a horror movie. The result is a film that feels too cold and clinical throughout. There are some good ideas, such as peace breaking out as the infection takes hold, but there is little passion in their execution. This makes the film drag, as you don't care about the characters or their situation, so it feels much longer than ninety-nine minutes.

The screenplay by Dave Kajganich tries to be a personal take on the original "Invasion of the Body Snatchers" but doesn't have enough heart to draw the viewer in. The world the characters inhabit is too generic and we don't get to see how the infection affects so many people on a personal level. Those that are taken away or killed are faceless members of the masses, so you'll feel nothing as they are dispatched. There isn't enough detail in either the situations or the characterisation. The alien takeover is too swift as is the resolution which I kept hoping was going to be turned on its head by a sucker-punch ending that never came. And the story is riddled with plot holes. Why is Carol's ex-husband trying to settle old scores if he is no longer troubled by his emotions? How could a group of scientists escape when everyone else is so easily infected? With a majority of the population transformed, why would they care about a few people that are immune to the virus? If the armed forces and police have been infiltrated to such a great extent, who would deliver the cure to the masses? And come to think of it, who would be able to produce it in such great quantities if the world was overrun? There are too many things that just don't add up.

We are supposed to empathise with a heroine who is too aloof. We don't see enough of her as a mother to establish her as a sympathetic character. She's presented more as the psychiatrist - a neutral observer that doesn't really invest in situations. Most of her interaction with her son is at a remove; either by text or picture message, so you don't feel the bond between them. So it's hard to understand why she's so desperate to find him. Similarly her relationship with best friend and would-be lover Ben is one she keeps at arm's length, so you won't connect with it. The dialogue is heavy on jargon and cod-scientific explanations and the odd bit of philosophising on the nature of humanity. And to try to keep the non-sci-fi fans happy, there's a rather dull explanation of the hive mind created by the virus. But it all sits at odds with the B-movie proclamations of "My husband is not my husband..." and "Nobody touches my child!" So it all feels rather clunky.

Though Nicole Kidman may be a good actress, I think she's miscast as Carol. She has a frosty demeanour that doesn't make her the most sympathetic heroine. In conjunction with her whispery delivery and fragile damsel in distress persona, you almost wish she would be turned just so she'd stop being so pathetic. She's very good at being fluttery and panicking, but it makes her survival feel contrived. She seems more like the sort of woman who would just give up.

Daniel Craig is again another fine actor but is stymied by a lack of chemistry with his female co-star. Regardless of how warm and twinkly he is, their relationship rings false, making it difficult to invest in it and them. Jeffrey Wright is completely wasted in a role that requires little of him other than to spout pseudo-scientific jargon at pace. He's likeable enough but he doesn't have enough screen-time to really establish the character of Dr Galeano as anything more than an expository plot device. Jeremy Northam is well cast as Carol's ex-husband, demonstrating the creepy Prozac behaviour of the infected with precision and detail. Jackson Bond, who plays young Ollie is confident on screen but not overburdened with stage school teeth-and-eyes acting techniques. He's cute and naturalistic, so you'll probably find him the most sympathetic of the characters.

The original music by John Ottman starts off in a futuristic vein with electronic noises and squeals before shifting into a more traditional orchestral score. The arrangements are mainly string-led, using cello and violins to create a sense of foreboding or to unsettle the viewer. These are married with tense brass or brassy stabs on occasion to add excitement or suspense, though they can occasionally fall into B-movie horror arrangements. Though effective, it's hardly original, especially when the composer throws in heartbeat rhythms for a chase sequence. So it doesn't add an extra dimension to the movie.

"The Invasion" is a film that fails because of directorial indecision. Oliver Hirschbiegel refuses to take the movie in a single direction and by trying please so many masters, he ends up pleasing none. The film is neither scary nor intriguing, neither bold nor ballsy. Instead it is bland and without a solid focus. The performances are generic and the writing is confused and the film is consequently cold and uninteresting. A missed opportunity. 

Evaluate this review

How helpful would this review be to someone making a buying decision?

Rating guidelines

Comments about this review
monkpunkgaming

monkpunkgaming

06.11.2007 11:35

Awesome review. Greatly written. Bravo!!!!!

n13roy

n13roy

06.11.2007 09:29

I saw the trailers for this in the Cinema last week, and it certainly looks a more entertaining and suspenseful Film than you have written about it here, but there again, thats what they are supposed to do really !!!!.........Roy......

digitalenvironmentalist

digitalenvironmentalist

05.11.2007 21:46

you did justice to the film. well done!

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment


Similar offers
The Invasion The Invasion The Invasion Movie Poster
The Invasion The Invasion The Invasion Movie Poster
LOVEFiLM.com LOVEFiLM.com amazon kitchen
£ 3.93 £ 10.93 £ 9.99
Postage & Packaging: 0.​00
more
Postage & Packaging: 0.​00
more
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery
more
 Visit Shop  Visit Shop  Visit Shop
LOVEFiLM.​com LOVEFiLM.​com amazon kitchen
Review Ratings
This review of The Invasion (DVD) has been rated:

"exceptional" by (5%):
  1. monkpunkgaming

"very helpful" by (90%):
  1. Amazingwoo
  2. Julieshobs
  3. abcdefg
and 16 other members

"helpful" by (5%):
  1. HokaHey

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.
Related products on eBay