Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
Postage & Packaging: Free!
SHOPPING > DVDs > Drama > The Hours (DVD) > Reviews

The Hours (DVD)

from (5 offers) · Product Information

The Hours (DVD)

Quote-start

Days Of Our Lives (Wasted)

Quote-end

1 Oct 15th, 2003 

23 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Three good actresses (though sadly wasted)

Disadvantages:
Pretentious garbage

Recommendable No:

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

Ryan74

Ryan74

About me:

I'm making headway in my career as a music journalist so I won't be writing for a while and my alert...

Member since:19.03.2001

Reviews:129

Members who trust:99

There are some films out there that like to be deep, like to be clever and like to be intelligent. There are films out there that pull this off well, that can be thought-provoking, incisive and cutting-edge. 'The Hours', based on the novel by Michael Cunningham (which, I admit to you now, I haven't read), is not one of these films. Stephen Daldry's translation of the novel is a sprawling, unwatchable mess and a waste of three remarkably talented actresses. Perhaps I missed the point of the film, but quite simply this was the most boring, limp, lifeless film I have ever seen. You know the films where you say that they 'sent you to sleep', speaking figuratively of course, and then everybody goes wild with laughter, ('hahaha, that film must be boring' they think to themselves) well this film actually does have that effect. As soon as I finish writing this review I am about to head down to my local pharmacist, armed with a copy of this awful film, to reccommend to the delightful person behind the counter, always armed with a sunny smile and friendly disposition, that they offer 'The Hours' as a cure for insomnia. Those people that complain 'I can't get no sleep' will, within minutes of watching this tepid, dull film will soon find that they can doze off for hours on end. Even worse, I found the film to be truly insulting and patronising and by the end of the movie I felt like I hadn't watched a film but had instead been given a lecture.

I suppose I had better get on with explaining the plot. There are, rather ambitiously, three seperate plot strands at work in this film, dealing with three seperate women, each one suffering from depression (a deep theme handled so badly in this film) in three different times in history. The first of these is novelist Virginia Woolf (who's afraid of her?) brought to life by Nicole Kidman, who, in 1923, is attempting to write her landmark book 'Mrs. Dalloway' while seemingly on the verge of a nervous breakdown. The second storyline shifts to 1951 and Laura Brown (Julianne Moore), a weak, simpering nervous wreck of a woman, who is trying to plan a party for her husband but is distracted by reading 'Mrs. Dalloway'. The third, and by far the most annoying, strand of the storyline takes us up to the modern day and the usually fantastic Meryl Streep as the hideous Clarissa Vaughan, a busy-busy modern woman who is so busy-busy and stressed out by the perils of modern life and is planning a party for an author friend of hers, Richard (played by Ed Harris), who is dying of AIDS. The impact of the novel is highlighted by showcasing the woman writing it, the woman reading it and the woman living it.

What struck me more than anything about this film is that the characters are so unlikeable and hideous that this forms a stumbling block in my mind before I can even begin to appreciate the film. Julianne Moore's character, a woman living an idyllic suburban life with a husband and child, is misfiring badly, just what is going on with her? Do real people behave like this? Do real women drop everything because one book, ONE BOOK, has such a dramatic impact on their life that they suddenly decide to reconsider their whole life, whether they are a good mother and wife? The answer is no, real people aren't like that. Laura Brown is an awfully romanticised, unbelievably pretentious caricature of what Daldry, and possibly Cunningham, believes women are like. Moore does her best with a contrived and weak script but she cannot bring the character to life. Her moments are awfully ponderous, as though she is permanently contemplating the meaning of life, and it is hard to have any sympathy for a character who comes across as so unlikeable. The character of Virginia Woolf, is, again, a bad caricature, a stereotype of a woman on the verge of a breakdown, the struggling author forever suffering with writer's block, the woman coming to terms with her lesbianism - the direction and writing of this film is so contrived, patronising and stereotypical it borders on the offensive. The film doesn't aim for entertainment but aims as 'life lessons' for the audience, the director is trying to show us just how clever he is, when it isn't clever at all, it's over-intellectualised, melodramatic rubbish. The despair of Woolf's life is made impossible to empathise with when the character is so distanced from any kind of reality. She is cold, distanced and a very dark character, who comes across as extremely rude and arrogant. I cannot comment on how it is in the novel, but the script and direction here does Kidman no justice at all. Are we meant to feel sorry for poor, poor Virginia, a woman who is absurdly foul and obnoxious, a woman who barks orders at her hard-working servants and affords them no praise despite having them bend over a backwards to please her, a woman whose problems are so forced and contrived? That Kidman won an Oscar for her performance is worrying enough - what exactly does she do in this film to deserve it other than sulk and scream at people? She isn't even in it for half the time! Perhaps the Academy were offering her an Oscar by way of an apology for missing her out for the previous year's 'Moulin Rouge'...

But Streep's character, the busy-busy publisher and upper middle-class twit Clarissa, is far and away the most unlikeable and unwatchable. The scenes between her and Harris are clearly intended to be heart-breaking, poignant and moving but are such a wretched exercise in pointless melodrama it is literally drama-by-numbers and Streep gives such a hammy performance it is hard to find praise for an actress whose performances can usually lift even the most awful of films. Harris's author character, dying of AIDS, is a miserly man who is at odds with the world and rejects the attempts of the busy-busy Clarissa, who clearly has feelings for him. Do real people behave like this? Again, no, they don't. The dialogue is stilted and forced. Perhaps we can throw some leeway in to allow such dialogue when we are watching the scenes set back further in history, but the dialogue in the supposedly modern day setting is truly atrocious, so uppity and middle-class, long asides and meaningless, empty words and sprawling paragraphs of heartfelt junk. Real people do not speak like this. Her scenes with the usually reliable Jeff Daniels as Louis Waters, a man who has connections with both her and the miserly Richard, are embarassingly bad, the dialogue exceptionally awful and the acting and direction stiff and wooden.

What annoys me further is the pretentiousness of the film, it is so wrapped up in its own cleverness and intelligence, you can almost picture Daldry watching the film and gloating at his own brilliance, the film is so smug and self-satisfied, 'this is beyond your understanding'-style. This I find extremely insulting and patronising, and that the film can even be considered Oscar-worthy worries me to no end. I have never in my life seen a film so pretentious. The themes are over-intellectualised, the script is truly awful and the characters unlikeable. Tackling three seperate strands of history at the same time is a great idea which, if it could be perfected, would make an awesome film, but 'The Hours' sadly doesn't do this, and instead is a jarring and misfiring viewing, leaving you feeling like you've watched something created by someone smarter than you and just how clever must that person be, ahhh a genius, this film is a work of art, but no, no way should people allow themselves to be fooled by thinking this nonsense is 'art'. This film is, simply, appalling. The film is not streamlined at all, making very little sense and jumping from scene to scene with no room for thought. But of course, this is a work of art, this is an intelligent film, so this is allowed...

Also of irritance is the droning score, which batters any kind of sense or life out of any of the supposedly dramatic scenes, and is melodramatic itself. The sweeping violins and the piano that just won't shut up, making you literally want to shoot to piano player, it's all so annoying and, again, pretentious. The doom-and-gloom piano, with those notes played ever-so-slowly you want to wind the piano player up and get him going, inject some life into him (and then shoot him) is a trusty (and by now tired) method, metaphor even, for telling the viewer that we are supposed to feel sad, it is like being at a talk show when the man holds up the sign saying 'applaud', 'laugh' etc. The emotions, therefore, are forced, not real, and the doom-and-gloom piano is one way the director can show us (now pay attention because this is where the film theory comes in) that we are watching a scene of dramatic importance and of high intelligence. Oh, I'm sorry, did I fall asleep? Must have missed it.

The melodrama of this film also bugs the heck out of me. The drama is so forced, the emotion is so sign-posted, 'cry now' etc. that is starts to wear a little bit thin even after the first fifteen minutes, by which time I wondered whether allowing my friends to rent such a film was a good idea after all (I'd heard it was Oscar-worthy, 'hmmmm, might be good' I thought, how wrong I was). That the film is considered in the same bracket as some all-time classics, and this has been mentioned by same idiotic film reviewers (who are either both blind and deaf, or have probably only ever seen this and 'American Pie 2' so have no benchmark for comparison), is absurd and a sad commentary about the kind of people who actually found this film to be fantastic, which is quite plainly isn't. Those awful accents, that patronising characters, those stilted emotions, the cryptic symbolism and use of metaphor, the right-on, politically-correct, quota-filling use of homosexuality, the constant pondering where the audience are challenged by people evidently more intelligent than our good selves to think deeper about matters such as the meaning of life. The symbolism of the film is patently obvious and, again, aims to be deep, clever, intelligent, when to anybody with half a brain can decipher what the director wants to achieve and can, with any luck, see that we, as an audience, are quite clearly being patronised. The constant literary references (almost thrown out in a 'check-the-boxes' manner) actively tell the audience that we couldn't possibly understand this film, heck no, we aren't clever or well-read enough. Hopefully some audience members are clever enough to see through this veil of intelligence and see the wooden heart of this film.

The film is also so downbeat and depressing, you feel just so miserable and thoroughly drained after watching it. The message of the film is totally screwed up and sends completely the wrong message to society. It portrays women as weak, narrow 'characters' rather than real people, and how this could possibly be a study of 'strong women' is beyond me. Instead the film suggests that if a woman has problems in her life then it is perfectly acceptable and fine and dandy to just drop everything and run away from them, which really isn't the answer, and it is on this note that I found the film to be most offensive. The notion that women are considered 'strong' because they take the coward's way out (Woolf kills herself, Brown leaves her husband and child, Clarissa allows the stress of her busy-busy lifestyle to rule her life and gives no time to herself) is truly frightening and is a warped and distorted commentary on how the director, and possibly even the writer of the novel, views women. The characters don't work to change their depressing situations, they run away from them. How is that a strong woman? What kind of message is this giving out? That it is OK to abandon your problems instead of tackling them? No, this is insensitive and badly-though-out rubbish.

The film also does seem to plod on for, well, hours, and seems at times to be moving in slow motion. To be totally honest, not much happens in this film. It is devoid of impact, life and excitement, the usual things people appreciate a movie for, and instead is a dreary, drudging, droning exercise in stilted melodrama and pointless, pretentious over-intellectualism. The characters are uncharasmatic and truly dull, vapid and unlikeable.

For someone who can usually see good things in truly bad films (I am an avid fan of 'Transformers: The Movie' for example) I think you could say I didn't like this film. If you rate this opinion, please, please, please don't do the obvious thing and say 'you have to read the book'. You don't. This is a review of this film alone, not the book, and a film I found to be exceptionally bad. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Red Curtain Trilogy - Romeo And Juliet / Moulin Rouge / Strictly Ballroom (Box Set) (DVD)

Red Curtain Trilogy - Romeo And Juliet / Moulin Rouge / Strictly Ballroom (Box Set) (DVD)

Drama - Director: Baz Luhrmann - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Tara Morice, Paul Mercurio, Ewan McGregor, Nicole Kidman, Claire Danes, Leonardo DiCaprio

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 17.71

The Notebook (DVD)

The Notebook (DVD)

Production Year: 2004 - Drama - Director: Nick Cassavetes - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over, 12 years and over - Starring: Rachel McAdams, Ryan Gosling, Gena Rowlands

User reviews (60)

Buy now for only £ 0.35

Robert De Niro Collection (Box Set) (DVD) Jack And The Beanstalk - The Real Story (DVD)

Jack And The Beanstalk - The Real Story (DVD)

(+) Disc would make a nice Frisbee
(-) Too many to count.

User reviews (4)

Buy now for only £ 0.01

Schindler's List (DVD)

Schindler's List (DVD)

Production Year: 1993 - Drama - Director: Steven Spielberg - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Liam Neeson, Ralph Fiennes, Caroline Goodall, Embeth Davidtz, Ben Kingsley, Jonathan Sagalle

User reviews (36)

Buy now for only £ 6.41

Gone With The Wind (DVD)

Comments about this review »

hinasif76 22.04.2005 13:56

Hi, i am so sorry you didn't like this movie. I loved it. Rating your review helpful because it is a well written review. hina.

j_mcb 16.06.2004 16:54

Fantastic review. I read the book, that was equally pretentious. Both Cunningham and Daldry seem to be self-loving egomaniacs, and you're right, you don't need to read the book to see that. I was still impressed with the three protagonist's performances and at times liked the ideal pretentious spontaneity of Moore's character; even though I knew deep down it really was just nonesense. :o) as aforementioned, fantastic. J

FrenchCancan 18.12.2003 16:35

I soooooooooooo agree... I watch the movie on a Sunday afternoon and actually thought that paint drying was more interesting... Did you get the point ???

Compare prices for The Hours (DVD) »

1 to 5 out of 5 offers for The Hours (DVD) Show all offers   sorted by: Price 
The Hours [DVD] [2003]

The Hours [DVD] [2003]

Release Date: 2003-11-17, Rating Suitable for 12 years and over,

amazon marketplace dvd

Postage & Packaging£1.21
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace d...
The Hours-DVD

The Hours-DVD

thehut.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 3 days...
 Visit Shop  >
thehut.com
The Hours [DVD] [2003]

The Hours [DVD] [2003]

Release Date: 2003-11-17, Rating Suitable for 12 years and over,

amazon dvd

Postage & PackagingFree!
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon dvd
The Hours DVD

The Hours DVD

An adaptation of the novel by Michael Cunningham this is the story of three women living ... more

in different time periods of the Twentieth Century
all linked by a work of literature. In 1923
Virginia Woolf starts to write her novel 'Mrs
Dalloway' whilst stru...

play.com (films)

Postage & Packaging£0.00
Availability3-5 working days
 Visit Shop  >
play.com (films)


More reviews »

The Hours (DVD) - review by jeaniecz

Advantages: ........
Disadvantages: ........

The Hours (DVD) - review by jeaniecz jeaniecz 18.03.2008 (16.03.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Hours (DVD)

The Hours (DVD) - review by ickkate

Advantages: Excellent acting with decent roles for actresses combined with an intriguing plot structure
Disadvantages: A little ponderous at times

The Hours (DVD) - review by ickkate ickkate 09.10.2003 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Hours (DVD)

The Hours (DVD) - review by hiker

Advantages: Gentle, beautiful, allows you to draw your own conclusions
Disadvantages: The triple-strand story takes a little settling-into

The Hours (DVD) - review by hiker hiker 05.03.2004 (05.03.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Hours (DVD)

The Hours (DVD) - review by ClaireG86

Advantages: Gripping drama that will keep you guessing even after the film has ended
Disadvantages: none

The Hours (DVD) - review by ClaireG86 ClaireG86 23.11.2003 (23.11.2003) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Hours (DVD)

The Hours (DVD) - review by jenniewren26

Advantages: The DVD has endless special features. The acting is spectacular.
Disadvantages: The films ends with a need to know more about what happened; this could be part of the mystery.

The Hours (DVD) - review by jenniewren26 jenniewren26 07.06.2009 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Hours (DVD)



Are you the manufacturer / provider of The Hours (DVD)? Click here