If you've given me an E and I haven't thanked you, I apologise - trying to catch up. Really apprecia...
If you've given me an E and I haven't thanked you, I apologise - trying to catch up. Really appreciate all ratings.
Member since:05.05.2005
Reviews:976
Members who trust:378
Billy Costigan and Colin Sullivan both enter the police force wanting to work their way up. The only thing is, Colin is really a mole, planted by Irish mob leader, Frank Costello, whereas Billy, because of his family's mob connections, is planted undercover and becomes Costello's right hand man. A first, neither man is aware of the other; Billy's point of contact is through agents Queenan and Dignam, and Colin, who works for Queenan and Dignam, has a hot line direct to Costello himself. But then it becomes clear that there is a mole on both sides of the law; will Billy and Colin be able to continue to fight for their sides without being uncovered? Or is one of them doomed to die a painful death?
Based on the Hong Kong thriller Infernal Affairs, I've long wanted to watch this film. Usually, I stay clear of remakes of Asian films - I haven't exactly been persuaded to watch them after watching the odd one or two and realising how poor they are in comparison. This film seemed to be different though; certainly the critics seemed to love it. I have deliberately not yet watched Infernal Affairs though, although it's ready and waiting on my shelf, simply because I wanted to watch this film without any prior conceptions. Apparently, the basic structure is the same in both versions, although a certain amount of their own identity has been maintained, but obviously I cannot comment on this at the moment.
I thought Leonardo DiCaprio, who plays Billy Costigan, was outstanding. DiCaprio has been much maligned by critics for his acting in the past; personally, I think
if anyone has any doubts about his capabilities, then they should watch this film. Whereas I think many actors would play the role of Costigan with complete bravado, at least to the viewer's eye, DiCaprio really shows the fear and confusion that must have gone along with having such a dangerous job. At the same time, he is enough in control of his emotions to be completely convincing in his role as a mole. For me, he turned the movie from being a good thriller into being an exceptional one, he really is that good.
Matt Damon is also great as Colin Sullivan; by ordinary standards, I would be more enthusiastic about his performance, but he didn't quite blow me out of the water in the way that DiCaprio did. I think this is probably just because of his character. Sullivan is extremely cool, calm and collected, safe in the knowledge that he is trusted both by his police bosses and Costello, which perhaps doesn't give Damon quite as much scope to turn in a moving performance. Still, it is a very good one, and his descent into cruelty as the film progresses is great to watch.
When I realised the Jack Nicholson was playing the Irish gangster that is Costello, I must admit I was slightly taken aback - not at the gangster bit, but rather the Irish. I think Nicholson can be many things, but convincing me that he is Irish is not one of them. Thankfully, he doesn't pretend to have an Irish accent - he may be of Irish descent, but he sounds very American. The Irish thing aside, I thought he was great. I'm not sure that it was exactly a great stretch for him to play a psychopath, but he does do it all so convincingly.
This film is stuffed full of well-known actors. Martin Sheen and Alec Baldwin are great as FBI agents Queenan and Ellerby - the roles could have been made for them. I was quite surprised by Mark Wahlberg (or Marky Mark as he will always be known to me - I'm that age!) as Dignam. For a start, I didn't recognise him, but I was also taken aback at the vehemence I felt for his character - Dignam definitely needs a visit to charm school. I think the vehemence is the sign of a good performance though, so well done Marky Mark. Ray Winstone also makes an appearance as one of Costello's men. He certainly looked the part, although I wasn't too sure about his American accent, and it's always good to see a Brit in a Hollywood film.
The story is very intricate and it took me a while to get to grips with it. This is not a film that you can have on in the background and still be able to follow. Having said that, the thing that confused me the most to begin with is that DiCaprio and Damon actually look quite alike, and the constant swapping between their characters just did my head in. Once I'd sorted out who was who, it was different, but that initial twenty minutes had me scratching my head a bit. Don't do what I did though and go to wikipedia for clarification - I accidentally found out how the film ended before I'd got there, which was a bit annoying.
Obviously, the story was in existence before director Martin Scorsese and screenwriter William Monahan got their hands on it. Nevertheless, they do deserve full credit for their adaptation of it. As we know from other Hollywood remakes of Asian films, a good story does not necessarily translate over, but in this case, I think they have done very well. The script is tight, and initially perhaps a little overwhelming, but it works really well, especially when handed to the experienced actors that Scorsess picked. It is ultimately an action thriller, so clever cinematography was not really necessary; neverthless, Scorsese has come up with a slick film that looks as good as it sounds.
For those that dislike violence, the 18 rating should keep you away anyway. It is incredibly violent, and the slaughter of people is pretty much relentless from start to finish, with body parts flying all over the place. There is also an incredible amount of swearing, drug use and some sex. However, I think this is par for the course for a film that focuses on gang violence and the policing of it; certainly, I wasn't shocked by anything I saw or heard. Just be warned in case you somehow come across the film without realising what it is.
There are a couple of special features worth noting that come with the film on a separate disc. One is the story behind Jack Nicholson's character - a real mob leader in Boston. This is actually very interesting and I would definitely recommend watching. Then there is a documentary about how gang-related violence in film has affected Scorsese's work - again, interesting to watch. There is also a selection of additional scenes with commentaries by Scorsese - worth a quick look, but the documentaries are more interesting.
I really enjoyed this film. It is one of the best films I have seen in the last few months; everything about it just worked as far as I am concerned. Even the fact that, at 150 minutes, it is way longer than I like a film to be didn't seem to matter, although I must admit I'm glad I had control of the DVD control to break it up a little. Of course, if you don't like action thrillers or violence, then this isn't going to be for you, but otherwise, I think it is well worth a watch. Highly recommended.
The two-disc DVD is available from play.com for £3.99.
Thriller - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Timothy West, Neil Morrissey, Tara Fitzgerald, Annette Crosbie, Pauline Quirke, Rob Brydon, Denise Van Outen, John Thomson, Kevin Whately, David Suchet
Production Year: 2002 - Thriller - Director: K.C. Bascombe - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Jesse James, Rachel Skarsten, Charles Powell, Linda Purl, Kevin Zegars
Production Year: 2002 - Thriller - Director: Bharat Nalluri, Rob Bailey, Andy Wilson - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Matthew MacFadyen, Keeley Hawes, David Oyelowo, Peter Firth, Jenny Agutter, Lisa Faulkner
Advantages: Witty, gritty, thrilling... the best gangster film I've seen in years. Disadvantages: A bit of a Deus ex machina ending, some predictable moments...negligable really
Entwife 08.06.2007 (04.02.2008)
·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Departed (DVD)