Twelve years have passed since Casino graced our screens in 1995, the last "mob" movie we have seen by Martin Scorsese, arguably the finest director of crime pictures. Indeed, since then, with the exception of a couple of films, the mob movie has gradually died out. So when the finest director of crime pictures releases a film of the crime genre, it's difficult not to get excited. As an Italian-American born in Little Italy, Scorsese has always brought accurate, gritty and in part semi-autobiographical crime thrillers to the screen, but the important thing to note is that Scorsese primarily focuses on the way of life of the people he is portraying, rather than sticking to a tight plot. That's what sets the Departed apart from its siblings; it's all about the plot, and less about the day-to-day dealings of its characters that has made Scorsese so popular in the past. In many ways, this is Scorsese taking his films to a new level, and is breaking new ground. However, this is a double-edged sword, which is in part the doom of the Departed that could well leave it shunned in years to come as it's no longer Scorsese concentrating on what he is truly expert in.
Adapted by William Monahan from the Hong Kong thriller Infernal Affairs, the Departed abandons the conventional image of cops and robbers, black and white, from the very first frame, focusing instead on the grey area in-between. Corrupt cops are working for the mobsters on the inside, whilst rough-edge cops are posing as the very men the corrupt cops work for, resulting in a stalemate. Straight-edge, high-flying Colin Sullivan (Matt Damon) and academy drop-out maverick Billy Costigan (Leonardo DiCaprio), similarly, are these very men. They're pretenders, their lives based on false identity and lying, until it comes to the point where the complex web of deceit questions where the loyalties of the two men truly lie. Sullivan is under the thumb of sociopathic but paternal crime
lord Frank Costello (Jack Nicholson), feeding him every shred of information the FBI, Massachusetts State Police, and internal investigations. Conversely, Costigan is a cop who did not graduate, has a shady past, and as a result is placed as a mole in Costello's mob by senior detectives Captain Queenan (Martin Sheen) and his fiery deputy, Sergeant Dignam (Mark Wahlberg). The only way either man can stay unscathed is by lying, their days punctuated by dangerous situations. It is the ultimate test of their integrity, no matter what side of the rickety fence they are on. In a film that is so sharply defined by its plot, moving at break-neck speed, Scorsese has little time to deviate to their way of life. Moreover, the Departed deals with untouched ground for Scorsese, namely that of the police. The new theme and the plot illustrate how in such a picture, Scorsese is going to be upstaged, and though it is a crime picture by the acclaimed director, very little of him is seen.
However, the atmosphere of the city of Boston, (which, again is new ground for Scorsese in his departure from New York) is captured perfectly, as well as Casino captures Las Vegas and Taxi Driver captures New York. One can almost smell the strench of tobacco in the Irish pubs, the scent of cologne in the police department, and the reek of the sewers on the streets. The cinematography is all there, as sky-scrapers loom on the city skyline, and lone yachts are distant on a murky grey sea from the high rise apartments. The police department offices, open glass rooms, show the reflection of its employees in the busy buzz of work. Everything feels modern and developed, a change from the seventies crime Scorsese favours so much; it's all a change because the world the characters live in is the present day, with technology -- flat screen computers and swish cell phones -- a vital part of their way of life. The plot bases itself on the subtle use of cell phones to tip off backstreet dealings, and furthermore, to tip off police raids on the backstreet dealings. No more is crime based on an unwritten code of honour; it's more ruthless, it's more organised, and more deadly than ever before. Everyone, in the grand scheme of things, is out for their own and loyalty is as uncertain as survival after being shot in the head. It's a very different world that Scorsese handles, but he pulls it off to perfection, making the transition from the almost anarchic decades of rock n' roll and cocaine to a ruthlessly ordered decade of cell phones and paranoia.
Despite the subtle but masterful atmospheric and contextual input of Scorsese, one gets the impression that it's not really his film as much as past pictures. The Departed is dominated by its cast. Unlike the shared input of Scorsese and De Niro, Scorsese takes a step back and allows the cast to roam the screen unreigned. Jack Nicholson is so flamboyant, powerful, and even a little pretentious as Frank Costello that the other actors run the risk of being forced off screen if they didn't deliver equally excellent performances. Leonardo DiCaprio brings both a long absent physical presence to Billy Costigan, as well as an undeniable depth and vulnerability, so much so that he proves a great match for the likes of Nicholson in shared scenes. Nor is Matt Damon ever upstaged by DiCaprio; the latter may be more impressive in the flexibility he shows, but Damon builds a complex character whose true motives are constantly unclear, and his sleaziness and corrupt straight-edge quality adds much to what could be a weak role. The supporting cast provide rock solid backbone, with the warmth of Martin Sheen, the unhinged brutality of Ray Winstone, the wit of Alec Baldwin, the sensitivity and charisma of Vera Farmiga, in addition to the highly impressive, motor-mouthed Mark Wahlberg whose charismatic performance is one that brings to mind that of Joe Pesci in Goodfellas. When watching, Scorsese's presence is not a strong one, because he has truly unleashed a brilliant cast to assail the audience with not one bad performance.
In some ways it's a shame, because Scorsese misses out in his usual master class direction. His direction is not weak in the film, with some hard-hitting moments, and his flawless trademark of the tracking shot is there, but the Departed is by no way as audacious as projects as Gangs of New York, Casino, or Raging Bull, for example. He doesn't really try anything new, and breaks no new ground, so in the end the direction is solid and better than most directors' best, but it's not brilliant, as seasoned Scorsese fans have come to expect. Moreover, the editing by Scorsese's usual editor, Thelma Schoonmaker, overdoes it at times, often ending up being too choppy. It keeps a fast pace, but does not always work, and it is sometimes unclear as to whether or not there has been a large lapse of time in the story. Scorsese's use of music, which literally carries his best work, is also not quite up to scratch. There's some good songs, and the recognisable use of the Rolling Stones at times, but one instance sees a 'Stones classic "Gimme Shelter" starting up in a scene, only to suddenly start again as if on repeat half-way through. It doesn't quite have the same effect or genius as it has done in the past. But the mistake that many people will make when going to watch the Departed is in believing that it's like Scorsese's old work, when it is in fact quite different. It's not a crime biopic or crime drama, it's a top-notch crime thriller that combines a couple of elements from Scorsese's usual style.
The Departed, in terms of genre and plot, is a new venture for Scorsese. But when it comes to direction, there's nothing new or overly original. The direction, perhaps for the best given the plot, weakens. It's not a hugely daring project, something which shows, but it's top calibre entertainment with superb acting to boot. However, whilst the Departed may not be as ambitious and heavy as Gangs of New York, it's a much more accomplished project on a more even keel. It's proof that when Scorsese's not being ambitious, but focusing his attentions on a smaller-time thriller, he can produce results that any other director would envy. His characters, even though they're Irish rather than Italian-Americans, have the sense that Scorsese knows what he's doing when he's not on home turf. Nor does he pass up the opportunity to shove in the face of the viewer some graphic violence which both intrigues and appalls. It's one of the best and most complex and superbly crafted thrillers in years, from a director, who whilst not on the top of his game, still has the ability to blow the audience away with a project which simultaneously breaks and doesn't break new ground.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Thriller - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Timothy West, Neil Morrissey, Tara Fitzgerald, Annette Crosbie, Pauline Quirke, Rob Brydon, Denise Van Outen, John Thomson, Kevin Whately, David Suchet
Production Year: 2002 - Thriller - Director: Bharat Nalluri, Rob Bailey, Andy Wilson - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Matthew MacFadyen, Keeley Hawes, David Oyelowo, Peter Firth, Jenny Agutter, Lisa Faulkner
Excellent review... I haven't seen this yet but no doubt will sometime, it's just that I didn't think Infernal Affairs was that great, I couldn't keep up with it!
daylehall 19.03.2007 21:22
I watched this last week and thought it was excellent!! Certainly deserved the Oscar! xx
Martin Scorsese makes a welcomed return to the mean streets (of Boston, in this case) ... more
withThe Departed, hailed by many as Scorsese's best film sinceCasino. Since this crackling crime thriller is essentially a Scorsese-stamped remake of the acclaimed 20...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Rookie cop Billy Costigan (Leonardo DiCaprio) grew up in crime. That makes him the perfect ... more
mole, the man on the inside of the mob run by boss Frank Costello (Jack Nicholson). It's his job to win the perfect mole, the man in the inside of the mob ran by...
Martin Scorsese makes a welcomed return to the mean streets (of Boston, in this case) ... more
withThe Departed, hailed by many as Scorsese's best film sinceCasino. Since this crackling crime thriller is essentially a Scorsese-stamped remake of the acclaimed 20...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
Cops or criminals; when you're facing a loaded gun what's the difference? A big-budget ... more
Hollywood star power remake of the Hong Kong classic crime thriller Infernal Affairs. Two men operate on different sides of the law; one a mole with the Boston Sta...
Postage & Packaging: £0.00 Availability: 3-5 working days
Advantages: Witty, gritty, thrilling... the best gangster film I've seen in years. Disadvantages: A bit of a Deus ex machina ending, some predictable moments...negligable really
Entwife 08.06.2007 (04.02.2008)
·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Departed (DVD)