When Benjamin Button is born, everyone shies away from him in disgust - instead of a pink healthy baby, he is what looks like a little old man. Thankfully, a kind woman called Queenie who runs an old people's home takes Benjamin in and brings him up. He is at home amongst the elderly because he has much of their attributes. As he grows though, he seems to get younger and younger. By the time he is 17, although he looks in his 50s, he decides to leave home, promising to write to childhood friend Daisy from every port of call. Soon, he falls in love and forgets about Daisy, but on returning home after the War, he finds her there, all grown up and beautiful. They eventually embark on a love affair, but bearing in mind Daisy will age and Benjamin will grow even younger, is there any hope for their relationship?
Brad Pitt plays Benjamin Button. I don't think the role demands all that much of him; obviously he is aged at first and grows gradually younger (until he is so young that the role is taken on by a child actor), but apart from that, this is very much a story of someone's life and Pitt isn't required to show all that much emotion. Nevertheless, he still does very well and definitely endears himself to the audience - he reminded me very much of Tom Hanks in Forrest Gump. I wasn't all that convinced about his relationship with Daisy either. There seems to be very little chemistry between the two of them - it felt almost clinical at times. This may have been because it just didn't
seem all that likely that they would get together, I'm not entirely sure. Thankfully it doesn't matter all that much because, for most of the film, Benjamin is alone.
I have a great deal of respect for Cate Blanchett as an actress; she is one of the few actresses that can hold her own against an actor of the calibre of Brad Pitt - on the whole, actresses disappointingly fall into the secondary role category. Not so Cate Blanchett. This film is primarily about Benjamin, but as Daisy, she still more than manages to make her mark. This is partly because of her striking looks, and she looks fabulous in a ballerina's outfit, but also because she has real screen presence. It is a shame that she doesn't seem more comfortable with Brad Pitt; I'm not exactly sure which of them is at fault, but it does feel very cold when the two of them are together. She ages substantially during the course of the film - again, this is done very well.
Tilda Swinton was good as Benjamin's married lover. I'm not all that keen on Swinton as an actress - I find her more scary than appealing. However, here she carried off the role well and, perhaps oddly, because she comes over as being such a cold fish, she appears to have more chemistry with Brad Pitt than Blanchett does. The other character that really stood out for me was Queenie, played by Taraji P Henson. She is just so vibrant and loving that it is a real pleasure to watch her, and, of course, her acceptance of Benjamin is deeply touching.
Based on a short story by F Scott Fitzgerald, this is a really touching glimpse into someone's life. The fact that Benjamin was born old and grows gradually younger, although quite a draw to the film, is somehow unimportant; it is more about gaining life experience, interacting with other human beings and accepting those who are different. It is a really touching story though and I really enjoyed it. I had put off watching the film because of all the hype - but sometimes a film is praised because it really is good, and this is one of those occasions. I really liked the way the story was told - partly narrated by Daisy remembering Benjamin in her old age, and partly by Benjamin, based on a diary he had written and left with Daisy. This added different layers to the story-telling part and made it that bit more absorbing.
The only real downfall for me is the length of the film - at nearly three hours, it is just way too long. I am so glad that I didn't watch it in the cinema. As it was, I had to pause the film a couple of times just to get through it all. I can understand director David Fincher's decision to make the film as long as it is - there really isn't all that much that wasn't relevant and could have been cut - nevertheless any film over two hours is too long as far as I am concerned. Perhaps it needed to be a mini-series rather than a film - although I'm sure that wouldn't have been as lucrative. And for action lovers, there is precious little action - it really is the story, albeit fictional, of someone's life, and apart from the odd moment during the War, it is really a story of making the best of life.
The special effects are outstanding. Everyone in the film who ages, or in Benjamin's case, grows younger, does so very naturally - I never once saw anyone looking overly made-up. In hindsight, Brad Pitt looked a little fake as Benjamin in his 50s, but during the film itself, I was quite ready to be convinced. I definitely preferred seeing him as he really is, but I think that is more because of a fear of freakiness than anything else. Directed by David Fincher, the cinematography is really beautiful, although there is nothing particularly clever about it. It just looks very attractive. The shots of Daisy dancing in the dark for Benjamin particularly stand out. And the locations are lovely (apart from perhaps Benjamin's time on board a ship) - I particularly liked the old buildings that were used as the old people's home and a hotel in Russia. All in all, everything was very tasteful, without being overly in your face, and was a pleasure to watch.
I must admit I didn't watch the extras - after such a long film I couldn't face spending any more time on it, much as I enjoyed it. However, for those interested, there are a couple of features on the single disc version - an audio commentary and a feature on making Brad Pitt's face masks. There is, apparently, a two disc version, but I think that is only available for Region 1 (ie not the UK).
I did enjoy this film. However, I would absolutely not recommend seeing it at the cinema, unless you particularly enjoy getting a numb bum - it is just way too long. Being able to watch it on DVD, pausing whenever the need arises, is much more enjoyable. The target audience, I would imagine, is going to be an older one - although the classification is 12A, I cannot imagine that many children would enjoy watching, because it is just too slow. Still, if you enjoy pondering on the meaning of life and have the patience to watch a long film about someone's life, then this is definitely worth watching. Recommended.
The DVD is available from play.com for £11.99.
Classification: 12A
Running time: 166 minutes
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Production Year: 2004 - Drama - Director: Nick Cassavetes - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over, 12 years and over - Starring: Rachel McAdams, Ryan Gosling, Gena Rowlands
Production Year: 1997 - Drama - Director: Gillian Armstrong - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Ralph Fiennes, Cate Blanchett, Ciaran Hinds, Tom Wilkinson, Richard Roxburgh
This is an anthology of the best stories written by Francis Scott Fitzgerald - including ... more
"The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button" "Bernice Bobs Her Hair" and "A Diamond As Big As The Ritz". People who were unfailingly polite racked their brains for comp...
Postage & Packaging: £0.00 Availability: 3-5 working days
I was born under unusual circumstances. And so begins The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, ... more
adapted from the 1920s story by F. Scott Fitzgerald about a man who is born in his eighties and ages backwards: a man, like any of us, who is unable to stop time...
I was born under unusual circumstances. And so begins The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, ... more
adapted from the 1920s story by F. Scott Fitzgerald about a man who is born in his eighties and ages backwards: a man, like any of us, who is unable to stop time...
Adapted from the classic 1920's story by F. Scott Fitzgerald The Curious Case Of Benjamin ... more
Buttonstars Brad Pitt asBenjamin Button - a man born in his eighties who agesbackwards! The film follows Benjamin's story, set in New Orleans, from the endof Worl...
Advantages: Everything. It's got depth, good characters, good plot, its well thought out, thought provoking... Disadvantages: You have to pay attention... That's it. No half watching this film.
surveysista1988 10.06.2009 (10.06.2009)
·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Fight Club (DVD)