If you've left me a rating on either my Imaginarium of Dr Parnassus or In the Valley of Elah reviews...
If you've left me a rating on either my Imaginarium of Dr Parnassus or In the Valley of Elah reviews, please let me know as they are showing up as 'not yet rated' even though at least fifteen of you have rated each one.
Member since:11.07.2000
Reviews:778
Members who trust:82
Having heard that two obese teenagers were suing McDonald’s for making them fat, film-maker Morgan Spurlock decided to see what would happen if he ate nothing but McDonald’s food and drink, three meals a day for thirty days. “Super Size Me” is the result.
The idea for “Super Size Me” came to director Spurlock after an enormous Thanksgiving meal at his mother’s house. His producer said that it was “a really great bad idea” and the rest, as they say is history. The rules of engagement were simple; Spurlock could only eat and drink items available over-the-counter at McDonald’s, he had to eat three meals a day from the chain, he had to eat everything on the menu at least once and if he was offered the chance to super size his meal, he had to accept.
Thankfully he wasn’t stumbling blindly into this endeavour – he had a back-up team that consisted of a cardiologist, a gastroenterologist, a general practitioner and a nutritionist. We are treated to footage of his regular medical check-ups that start with the reassuring news that he is fitter than the average thirty-three year-old and end with all of the experts advising him to give up the experiment or risk damaging his body permanently.
There aren’t many documentary makers that would knowingly put their health on the line for the sake of a film, so you have to acknowledge that Spurlock is either very brave or extremely stupid. After all, he experienced massive weight gain in a short space of time, elevated cholesterol, reduced liver and kidney function, lethargy, depression, and (according to his vegan girlfriend) semi-impotence. You don’t see Michael Moore putting himself in harm’s way to draw attention to the plight of Iraqi
civilians. But then Michael Moore’s probably busy eating Big Macs anyway.
Spurlock uses all the resources at his disposal to get his message across, incorporating footage of obese Americans, diagrams, cartoons, maps pinpointing the fattest cities in the US, talking heads from industry and legal professionals and his own video diaries. Chapters in the film are book-ended by the sinister advertising-inspired work of artist Rob English, which features malign Ronald McDonald-ised children. It’s a lot like being in a really interesting health education class where the teacher is witty and informed and never patronising, so you listen and soak up the information. Amongst the statistics is the shocking but hardly surprising revelation that two-thirds of American adults are obese. We are also told that McDonald’s refers to its customers as “heavy users” and “super-heavy users”. Spurlock obviously revels in reeling off America’s fat-statistics, doing so to the accompaniment of Curtis Mayfield’s “Pusher Man” while Ronald McDonald cavorts around in McDonaldland, like a sinister pied piper luring children to death by clogged arteries and heart-attacks.
Spurlock doesn’t just talk to the experts about the fast food lifestyle, he also chats to ordinary diners to show how his diet compares to that of your average American. In some cases it’s not a million miles away. There is one man who has eaten over nine thousand Big Macs in a lifetime and teenagers on the street profess their love for the Mackie Ds. The only people who don’t have any time for the director is McDonald’s, who avoid him like the plague, refusing (in the most polite way possible) to grant him access to key spokespeople throughout. However, they are clearly interested in what the documentary has to say about their business. Why else would they pay for a cheap advert before the film that directs viewers to a website discussing the issues raised?
The measure of Morgan Spurlock is to be found in his video diaries. He is an engaging host, both funny and informed and it’s interesting to watch how his personality changes as the McDonald’s diet goes on. On the first day he’s like a child, clearly thrilled by the idea of eating junk food for a whole month. On the second day when he gets his first super size meal, it is a different matter as he forces pounds of food down his gullet only for it to make an unscheduled re-appearance moments later. By the last couple of weeks he is bloated and sluggish and looks fit for the knackers’ yard. And he’s really worried when he wakes up with palpitations in the middle of the night. He always tries to keep his sense of humour intact, though, never allowing his ailing health to get in the way of taking the mickey out of the American diet.
Spurlock doesn’t confine his jabs to the Golden Arches. He manages to take pot shots at school dinners, the lack of physical education in schools and indeed the lack of general education in some cases. In an exercise in an elementary school, eight year-olds can all identify Ronald McDonald, some can identify George Washington and one little girl wrongly identifies Jesus as George W Bush. So what exactly are kids learning in American schools? Well it isn’t PE in most cases, with most children getting just one gym class a week, lasting forty-five minutes. And even in those schools with a good sports provision, it would appear that children aren’t taught the importance of a healthy diet in conjunction with regular exercise as we are given a tour of the average teenager’s lunch tray. No prizes for guessing that most of them sped their money on chips and crisps.
What is worrying is that in a culture where image is everything, companies like McDonald’s are cashing in on the current healthy living fads by providing salads that contain more sugar and salt than a burger and fries combined. And this isn’t the only cynical marketing ploy being employed – the Big M regularly sponsors sports teams and soft drink manufacturers are hell-bent on putting their vending machines in every school in America. Even the government are involved; providing cut-price processed foods to schools in bulk, so that most kids will only get one or two home-made meals at school every month. No wonder the US is breeding so many big-boned behemoths! In fact the only schoolkids we see that are getting healthy lunches are those at a school for children with behavioural difficulties. And of course there are the marketing strategies aimed at children that according to one legal professional, make children equate fast food with happiness. The soundtrack to the film incorporates as many ironic tunes as Spurlock can shoehorn in. We are treated to acres of American flesh accompanied by Queen’s “Fat Bottomed Girls”, Curtis Mayfield’s “Pusher Man” and Spurlock’s opus “Super Size Me” performed by a band called Toothpick. It’s one of the aspects of the film that creates the most humour.
Though some may find Spurlock’s scatter-gun approach less satisfying to watch than one of Michael Moore’s diatribes, I enjoyed it immensely. For one thing, at a compact ninety-six minutes, the running time is far shorter than most of Moore’s film. Through humour and lots of flashy inserts Spurlock manages to make a serious point about the obesity time-bomb in an accessible and amusing way. Though the film may be about one man’s personal choices it is nevertheless an effective piece of social commentary that makes interesting points about corporate and personal responsibility. Besides, public health is an important issue that needs to be dealt with and the film has already had an impact. In America McDonald’s has done away with the Super Size option (although they swear they weren’t influenced by the documentary) and several school districts have banned soft drink vending machines.
How much you enjoy the film is largely dependant on how much you like Spurlock’s manner of presenting information. If you like your facts in bite-sized pieces, this could be right up your street. If however you prefer your documentaries to incorporate deeper meditations on corporate philosophies and responsibility, you may be disappointed. Whatever you feel about this film, lobby your local secondary schools to show it to their students. God knows if it can inspire my anti-health food other half to eat fruit, imagine what it will do for younger, more impressionable minds.
Interestingly the audience I saw this with was mainly young, slim and healthy looking. I suppose we all need to reinforce our lifestyle choices sometimes.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
I am going to see this tonight, I think it will be very intersting, although I don't think it would make me crave fast food!
feniak 27.09.2004 11:16
I really want to see this movie ... It will probably put me off junk food for ever! Fen
theediscerning 26.09.2004 19:56
Great op, and this is definitely on my to-watch list. It's all convinving, although from some telly I watched, by the American definition of "obese", Brad Pitt is obese. Can't they just leave our language alone?!
Fans of Morgan Spurlock's engaging documentarySuper Size Mewon't want to miss almost an ... more
hour of extra footage on the DVD. Best of all is a 25-minute one-on-one interview with Eric Schlosser, author ofFast Food Nation, but other interesting moments are...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Fans of Morgan Spurlock's engaging documentarySuper Size Mewon't want to miss almost an ... more
hour of extra footage on the DVD. Best of all is a 25-minute one-on-one interview with Eric Schlosser, author ofFast Food Nation, but other interesting moments are...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
Here's a documentary which needs absolutely no introduction. Why is America so fat? This ... more
is the question that Morgan Spurlock wanted to answer. He set out to interview experts in 20 U.S. cities, including Houston - the Fattest City in America - whilst ...