Thanks for taking the time to read my reviews; sorry I’m unable to reply to everyone
Thanks for taking the time to read my reviews; sorry I’m unable to reply to everyone
Member since:28.04.2005
Reviews:25
Members who trust:4
Released in 1971 Straw dogs caused outrange due to the level of violence and resulted in the film being banned for 18 years. Right, I’m going to try get through this review without using the words ‘cult’ and ‘classic’.
Directed by Sam Peckinpah, whom it could be argued was famed for the portrayal of violence in his work, the film is set in a sleepy Cornish village (filmed only about 5 miles from Lands End in St. Buryan) and it can be difficult to watch at times but the suspense keeps you glued. From the opening it shows a close nit community looking like it by-passed the last 6 decades completely and decided to stay in the post war era, and it’s clear that they don’t take to outsiders. The story centres on the newly married couple the Sumner’s played by a (back then) fresh faced Dustin Hoffman (David) and Susan George (Amy). The couple have moved back to the village where Amy grew up to escape the violence in the U.S. and so American Mathematician David has somewhere quiet to complete his book.
Amy’s character building starts in village when they are picking up supplies and she’s clearly Bra-less, making no attempt to hide the fact and loving the attention. You get the feeling that being back where she grew up she’s trying to shred the girl whom all the locals remember and show them who she has now become. This incites the attentions of not only the locals but also from a former boyfriend. Whilst in the village, Amy obtains an unusual purchase of a Bear Trap which you just know will play a part in the proceedings but in the meantime David go into the local pub to buy ‘American cigarettes’. It’s one of those pubs where as soon as you walk in the place goes quiet and makes you feel uncomfortable. I can vouch for this feeling as I once went into a pub like that and it resulted in a very quick pint and an underpants situation. In the pub we meet the other key players including Tom, a huge drunken man who appears to do what he pleases due to his size and everybody else tolerates. Tom does warn another villager
to keep his brother Henry away as he’s been eyeing up the girls, Henry is the one local that’s not tolerated as he fits in as the local paedophile with learning difficulties. In fact the only character that seems oblivious to the baleful on goings is the Major which, from what I tell, is the law in the community and the small gang humour him with phoney pleasantries.
The Sumner’s live in a farm house away from the village but the local yokels are there as David employed a handful (including Amy’s old flame) to repair the ruins of what was once the garage, this as they say, is where the trouble beings….
David is working on his book while trying to ignore the noise from them working on the garage plus getting more annoyed with Amy’s constant need for attention and her fixation of finding the missing cat. After leaving him peace to take a bath she notices the workmen watching her every move and make no effort to cover herself and seems to invite the extra attention. For the first thirty minutes there really isn’t much to build the tension just rather more on the characters. But do we really so long to figure out that they all want her, jealousy of him and ‘they don’t take kindly to stranger folk round ere’?
The pace quickens when the seemingly naïve David is getting ready for bed with Amy and he finds the missing cat hanging dead in the wardrobe. After an intense conversation with Amy he believes that ‘Anybody could have done it’ whereas Amy points out that could only be the locals working on the garage. This spirals into her accusing him of being a coward when she asks that he confronts the workman about the cat. David refuses to accuse them directly and due to his cowardice the workmen end up inside helping to put the Bear trap on the wall for him. Displeased Amy brings out drinks for them including a saucer of milk but the only reaction is from David who was trying to find out the truth in a more discreet way. The locals then ask him if he shoots and the awkward situation takes a further anxious step as they arrange a hunting trip into the surrounding fields, but this has an evil underlying plan to get him away from the house and leave Amy alone.
Once out in the fields David is told wait and they will flush the ducks towards him so he can catch them, there he is left. We cut to Amy answering the door to her old boyfriend and him asking to come in. What happens is the difficult and uncomfortable semi-mutual rape to which Amy seems to relent to in the end until a further accomplice arrives and turns it into a graphic double event that I’ll leave the details out of the review for obvious reasons. An interesting side bar is Susan George (only 20 years old at the time) found out what Peckinpah wanted on screen she flatly refused until he threatened her with legal action for breech of contract. No doubt she felt uncomfortable shooting this but it did have an on screen impact that is impossible to forget and probably was a career maker for her. She also claims she was battered and bruised after the filming but now in retrospect says she ‘enjoyed the violence’ and ‘it was in the name of art’.
Upon David’s return she doesn’t interrupt his ravings about being left out there and withholds her afternoon’s trauma from him even though she has to see her perpetrators later at the annual town hall fate. Arriving there David is greeted by Janice, a young girl and daughter of Tom, and he replies ‘Hello’ in a rather unfriendly manner that leads you to the conclusion she wants him and could well be former friends with Amy. Feeling rejected, Janice seeks the attention of Henry (the kiddy fiddler) and they disappear into the foggy night. For Susan, it’s clear that being among them is too much of an ordeal and David recedes from his efforts to fit in with the heavy drinking regional folk to take her home. After an incident which accidentally leaves Janice dead, Henry is running through the heavy foggy night when David hits him with the car. Feeling he must help him, seemingly not knowing of Henry’s background, he takes him up to the house where he calls for the Major and a doctor. Meanwhile back at the village hall word has gotten out that Henry has disappeared with young Janice and Tom flies into a rage fuelled by alcohol and wants her found, but not before warning Henry’s brother of the consequences if he finds anything has happened to his daughter. David is trying to get help for Henry while at the same time arguing with Amy who doesn’t want him in the house, even though he explains he’s responsible and has to get a doctor. By now the drunk mob have discovered the whereabouts of Henry and are banging at the door. He lets them in but a semi-conscious Henry can’t, or refuses to tell them where Janice is and this sends Tom over the edge. David manages to lock them outside again but this is the spark that lights the fuse for the final conflict in a Ned Kelly style surroundings.
He won’t give Henry to them in spite of Amy’s pleadings and the trouble really starts with bricks coming through the windows followed by rats from the barn. The violence escalates to where David is pushed to his breaking point and fights back using various methods including boiling cooking oil, wire and guns. This unexpected turn in his behaviour shocks Amy and she is reluctant to help when he starts to bark orders at her. From here on in it’s a psychological see-saw from placid to violent avenger for David as he offers reassurance that they can’t get in and fits of rage to inflict as much pain as possible on the attackers to defend his home. The Major arrives who is accidentally killed in the skirmish leading David to the conclusion ‘they’ve gone to far to stop now’ and while fighting back the intruders descends into bloodshed and he knows there is no way back from the violence he’s stumbled into. The siege is a gripping eye opening encounter that gives the film a thrilling and suspense climax with a final twist on Amy’s part that makes this cult classic (daaaam it! nearly made it all the way through) as powerful today as when it was released.
It’s difficult to say whether I should recommend this film or not. I’ve had to tick yes as when talking to others who ask ‘Have you seen it?’ you feel like part of an exclusive club, due to you can always find someone who’ll say ‘I’ve never heard of it’. If you’re a Peckinpah fan by all means yes (the film was coined ‘The British Wild Bunch’) but if you’re after a night in with a decent thriller for you and the missus, this isn’t the one. I found Susan George’s performance stronger than Hoffman’s and the pace starts off a bore, picks up gets interesting an hour in with the last thirty minutes filled with suspense and thrills in a claustrophobic setting.
A final point is price. HMV will ask you for £16.45 of your British pounds which is a lot. You can get it though Amazon for around £4.99 plus postage but I was lucky to find a pristine example in a charity shop for £2. All I can guess is some old dear bought it looking at the cover ‘Ooo I like Dustin Hoffman. I loved in that one where he counts tooth picks and plays cards’?
Thanks for reading
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Production Year: 2004 - Drama - Director: Nick Cassavetes - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over, 12 years and over - Starring: Rachel McAdams, Ryan Gosling, Gena Rowlands
Production Year: 1999 - Drama - Director: Dick Maas - Original Language: English - Classification: 18 years and over - Starring: William Hurt, Jennifer Tilly, Denis Leary, Michael Chiklis, Francesca Brown
Production Year: 1945 - Drama - Director: David Lean - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring: Celia Johnson, Trevor Howard, Stanley Holloway, Joyce Carey, Cyril Raymond
I'm not going to give you a NH because ti would be helpful in a small way however people watch DVD's to find out what happens...they don't want to read a review and come on and find out what happens in text! xx
redeyes22 12.03.2009 16:12
nicely reviewed, fab aggy xxx
mythdata 12.03.2009 11:50
Too much plot, but very well written and certainly not worthy of the NH you have recieved.:O)
According to critic Pauline KaelStraw Dogswas "the first American film that is a fascist ... more
work of art". Sam Peckinpah's only film shot in Britain is adapted from a novel by Gordon M Williams calledThe Siege of Trencher's Farmwhich Peckinpah described as...
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
According to critic Pauline KaelStraw Dogswas "the first American film that is a fascist ... more
work of art". Sam Peckinpah's only film shot in Britain is adapted from a novel by Gordon M Williams calledThe Siege of Trencher's Farmwhich Peckinpah described as...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Available for home viewing in the UK for the first time in almost 20 years Sam ... more
Peckinpah's notoriously controversial 1971 classic STRAW DOGS will be released completely uncut on this Special Edition DVD. Based on Gordon M. Williams's novel The Siege ...
Postage & Packaging: £0.00 Availability: 3-5 working days