Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
SHOPPING > DVDs > Drama > Shine (DVD) > Reviews

Shine (DVD)

from (4 offers) · Product Information

Shine (DVD)

Quote-start

SHINE lives up to its name

Quote-end

5 Aug 1st, 2008  (Aug 2nd, 2008)

11 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Great acting, and a strong character story, Wonderful music

Disadvantages:
Controversy as to the accurate portrayal of David's father

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

RippedoffPete

RippedoffPete

About me:

Member since:09.12.2000

Reviews:23

Members who trust:1

SHINE, an Australian film drama was released in early 1997, and later that year its main actor, Geoffrey Rush, picked up both Oscar, Golden Globe and BAFTA awards for Best Actor. Its Australian director, Scott Hicks was nominated for an Oscar as Best Director, and received the prestigious David Lean Award For Direction at the BAFTAs. So pretty impressive credentials. But did SHINE live up to the hype?

To begin with on a superficial level, SHINE, is unfairly perceived to fall into the 'classical arts film'' category, as the story basically concerns itself with a young, gifted Australian classical pianist, David Helfgott, The fact that classical music features abundantly in this film may unfortunately put off many younger viewers who prefer to watch films featuring pop culture, when it comes to music. However, if you are looking for a strong storyline with good characters, emotional involvement and an uplifting conclusion, this may be the film for you. Being a classical music fan isn't really essential to appreciating this film, but of course it probably helps.. There are some wonderful pieces of music in the film, not least Vivaldi's "Nulla in mundo pax", played at a few times in the film, including the end.

The story opens with a disheveled, middle-aged man, stumbling around in heavy rain and constantly muttering apparent nonsense to himself. From here, we flashback to David as a young boy from a poor German immigrant family in the 1950s, and the relationship with his father, who is portrayed as a dominant and obsessive parent, and an old fashioned disciplinarian. It is he who introduces David to music in the first place, branding the immortal words upon his mind early on: "I know life is cruel, but music will always be your friend. Everything else will let you down in the end". From then on David is subjected to intense pressure by his father to learn Rachmaninov's 3rd Piano Concerto, a tortuous work, even for accomplished adult pianists to achieve. Young David is put through music competitions playing recitals of lesser works, but has mixed success in winning them, which only makes his 'determined to win' father bully and humiliate him even further. Eventually Isaac Stern, the acclaimed violinist , hears David's playing, while visiting Australia and offers him a scholarship at an American academy.. This seems like great news, but soon afterwards, David's father steps in, and refuses to let his son go, claiming the family needs his support. After this initial blow, a few years on, when David is now a nervous and awkward adolescent, he is given a second bite of the cherry, when he is offered a scholarship at the Royal College of Music in England. Again his father intervenes, and forbids David to go. However after a serious and violent argument over this, David decides to defy his father and takes up the course. At this point his father disowns David, and they never see or communicate with each other again until many years later.

David moves to England to begin his course. He is personally tutored by Professor Cecil Parkes (John Geilgud). When asked by Parkes which work David wants to specialize in on the course, David suggests Rachmaninov's piano Concerto 3. At first the tutor is dead aganst the idea, as he considers it far too difficult , but David is insistent, and for the first time undergoes tackling this mammoth piece seriously. After months of intense study and practice, day and night and self-deprivation, David finally overcomes all obstacles and masters the concerto, and performs it.publicly with success. However all the preparation and effort beforehand proves too much for him, and after the performance, David has a debilitating mental breakdown which was to afflict him for the foreseeable future.

Now reduced to a shambling and mumbling human wreck, David returns to Australia and is assigned to a mental institution as a day patient. For years, he has given up playing the piano, until one day during a sing-along entertainment session at the hospital, he helps out the pianist, and sits beside her, when he discovers his interest in music, and playing the piano has been re-kindled. Although advised by doctors not to touch the piano again, David ignores the advice, and starts to practice again to realize that his touch has not deserted him. From here on his confidence slowly returns, and by winning new friends over once again he begins to build a reputation for himself in Australia as a pianist of distinction. Eventually against all odds he largely overcomes his mental handicap and even finds marriage.to an admirer.

SHINE isn't all deadly serious stuff.There are some wonderful humorous quotes scattered throughout the film. For example, when Isaac Stern offers the American scholarship to David who looks puzzled when he tells him it's in America, Stern adds "America. You know, land of the free, home of the brave. You know, Mickey Mouse." And there are other equally amusing lines and incidents.

SHINE is controversial as to how accurately it interprets the events in David's life. Was David's father primarily responsible for the outcome of his son's mental state later on in his life? Was his father 's character reasonably accurate or totally misrepresented for dramatic effect? Was David Helfgott as accomplished or important a pianist as the film tries to portray? I know of a number of famous classical pianists, but had not heard of David before I saw this film. I won't delve further into this, but just say one should perhaps enjoy the film as a fictional story and not worry about how true the events are.

On many levels, particularly in the acting SHINE is a great if slightly disjointed film partly due to the time flashing backwards and forwards, but thoroughly enjoyable nonetheless. I also think it's a film that needs to be seen more than once. It took me 2 viewings with a 6 month gap in between to appreciate it properly. A definite must-see for anyone with a mature outlook and a reasonable attention span. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Snow White (DVD)

Snow White (DVD)

Production Year: 2001 - Drama - Director: Caroline Thompson - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring: Miranda Richardson, Tom Irwin, Vincent Schiavelli, Warwick Davis, Kristin Kreuk

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 5.99

The Notebook (DVD)

The Notebook (DVD)

Production Year: 2004 - Drama - Director: Nick Cassavetes - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over, 12 years and over - Starring: Rachel McAdams, Ryan Gosling, Gena Rowlands

User reviews (59)

Buy now for only £ 2.87

The Way We Were (DVD)

The Way We Were (DVD)

(+) Robert. Robert, HUBBA HUBBA Robert
(-) Sorry, none...

User reviews (2)

Buy now for only £ 2.95

Gone With The Wind (DVD)
Jack And The Beanstalk - The Real Story (DVD)

Jack And The Beanstalk - The Real Story (DVD)

(+) Disc would make a nice Frisbee
(-) Too many to count.

User reviews (4)

Buy now for only £ 0.50

Sense And Sensibility (DVD)

Sense And Sensibility (DVD)

Production Year: 1995 - Drama - Director: Ang Lee - Original Language: English - Classification: Universal - Starring: Emma Thompson, Alan Rickman, Kate Winslet, Hugh Grant, Greg Wise, Hugh Laurie, Robert Hardy

User reviews (13)

Buy now for only £ 0.94

Comments about this review »

n13roy 29.08.2008 22:46

Really well written, detailed and very informative DVD review indeed. I thought this was a brilliant Film when I first saw it, and Geoffery Rush was oustanding in it too.........Roy...........

RippedoffPete 02.08.2008 01:49

Thanks. The film is is very good.

blackmagicstar4 01.08.2008 18:44

Great review, sounds really good, soph x

Compare prices for Shine (DVD) »

1 to 4 out of 4 offers for Shine (DVD)   sorted by: Price 
Shine [DVD] [1997]

Shine [DVD] [1997]

This tearjerker by Australian filmmaker Scott Hicks is a surprising story about real-life ... more

classical pianist David Helfgott, an Australian
who rose to international prominence at a very
young age in the 1950s and 1960s, and suffered a
psychological coll...

amazon dvd

Postage & Packaging£1.21
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon dvd
Shine

Shine

Worldwide critical acclaim and numerous film awards, including Best Actor Academy Award ... more

for Geoffrey Rush, make Shine the must-see motion
picture event of the year!Inspired by the true
story of Australian child prodigy David Helfgott
(Rush), Shine exam...

LOVEFiLM.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityIn Stock
 Visit Shop  >
LOVEFiLM.com
Shine-DVD

Shine-DVD

thehut.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 3 days...
 Visit Shop  >
thehut.com


More reviews »

Shine (DVD) - review by Kozinski

Advantages: Great acting, and a heart warming story
Disadvantages: Possibly not the whole truth of Helfgott

Shine (DVD) - review by Kozinski Kozinski 05.08.2000 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Shine (DVD)



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Shine (DVD)? Click here