Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon (DVD)

Review of

Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon (DVD)

Overall rating (1): Overall user rating Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon (DVD)

3 offers from £0.96 to £5.89  

All Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon (DVD) reviews

 Write your own review


 


 


Sherlock Holmes in the Second World War??

3 Jan 9th, 2006

Advantages:
Entertaining

Disadvantages:
Not a Conan Doyle plot

Recommendable: Yes 

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

more


sunmeilan

About me: I've never been a big message leaver, but I would like to thank everyone that has read and rated my ...

Member since:05.05.2005

Reviews:946

Members who trust:364

Review rated by 22 Ciao members on average: very helpful

Introduction
Basil Rathbone played Sherlock Holmes a total of fourteen times. He is probably one of the most famous actors to play the role and, at his best, does a superb job. This film is not one of his best though - this is not completely his fault - much of the blame has to lie with the director, Roy William Neil, for deciding to make a Sherlock Holmes film that is not based on any of the Conan Doyle stories. It was certainly watchable and enjoyable, but that's the best that can be said for this film.

The director
Roy William Neil directed and produced all of the Sherlock Holmes films starring Basil Rathbone after this one, the fourth in the series. Neil died in 1946, which effectively brought Basil Rathbone's stint as Sherlock Holmes to an end.

The plot
Sherlock Holmes is called in to protect a Swiss scientist, Dr Franz Tobel, who has agreed to share his plans for a bombsight (which apparently helps ensure the accuracy of bombs) with the British government rather than Germany. Holmes rescues him from the Nazis and smuggles him out of Switzerland and leaves him in the safe hands of Dr Watson. Except that they are not safe hands, because Dr Watson falls asleep and Tobel escapes to see his mistress.

When he eventually turns up again, the UK government officials are stunned to hear that Tobel will not share the production secrets of the bombsight, but wishes to oversee production of the instrument himself. Then he disappears. Holmes discovers that his disappearance is the work of Professor Moriarty. All he has to work on is a piece of paper covered in dancing men that Dr Tobel left with his mistress. Can Holmes and Watson save the day and Great Britain?!

The characters/actors
I do quite like Basil Rathbone as Sherlock Holmes. He is madly irritating and patronising at times, but then this is exactly how Conan Doyle portrayed him. His hair, brushed forward, annoyed me, but was probably the fashion of the day in 1942! Give me Jeremy Brett any day, but Rathbone does a good enough job. Interestingly, Basil Rathbone was born in South Africa, but moved to the UK at a young age and eventually took an interest in the acting profession. He is best known for his role as Sherlock Holmes, and starred in 14 films in this role.

Poor Dr Watson. Nigel Bruce, of whom I am very fond as an actor, takes the role to extremes and Dr Watson becomes more of an idiot than anything else. He adds a comedy role to the film, which is probably the intention, but I would have preferred that he had stuck to the more traditional view of Watson, who although is not as smart as Holmes, is certainly not as stupid as he is made to be here.

As Professor Moriarty, Lionel Attwill did not shine in any way, shape or form; in fact, I barely noticed he was there. The odd time I did, he came over as being slightly annoying. Disappointing.

Dennis Hoey plays Inspector Lestrade for the first time in this film. Again, he is portrayed as a total idiot, somewhere along the same lines as Watson.

Technical bits
My version of the disc has an interesting documentary about all the actors who had played Sherlock Holmes before Basil Rathbone. Many of them performed on the stage and as such, I had not heard of them. The documentary was interesting, but not worth buying the DVD for unless you really like the film.

Classification: PG

The film is in black and white, although it is apparently possible to get it in colour as well.

Conclusion
If you like Basil Rathbone in the role of Sherlock Holmes as I do, then you'll probably enjoy this. But you're unlikely to think it's the best film you've ever seen. I personally much preferred Rathbone in The Hound of the Baskervilles, his first film in the role, which stuck quite closely to Conan Doyle's original story. This DVD, and many of the others directed by Roy William Neil, is only loosely based on Conan Doyle's work and characters. This particular one, for example, is based during the Second World War, whereas as anyone with any knowledge of the original work will know that they were written during the late19th century. The clue of the dancing men does come from a Conan Doyle story, but the rest of it, apart from the characters (and that depends on your viewpoint) is completely different.

I do believe that some artistic licence is needed when turning a book into a film. However, to put the character of Sherlock Holmes into a propaganda film is pushing it a little too far for me. Sherlock Holmes was famous for a reason and that was because the public liked him the way he was. Turning Watson into a complete idiot was also unnecessary as far as I am concerned.

However, rant finished, if you forget about the similarities to Conan Doyle's work and just consider the film, it is entertaining and I did enjoy it. Don't start with this one though, The Hound of the Baskervilles is a much better introduction to Basil Rathbone in the role.

A new copy is available on Amazon from £5.99, used from £2.19.
 

Evaluate this review

How helpful would this review be to someone making a buying decision?

Rating guidelines

Comments about this review
silverstreak

silverstreak

11.01.2006 11:42

I think that was quite common for the day - turning as much as they could into support for the 'war effort', possibly some justification for making films and other forms of entertainment while the country was at war, and people were suffering. Can't see that happening these days though!

matthewsmum

matthewsmum

10.01.2006 11:14

I agree with you that you need some artistic licence to convert a book to a film - they usually need a little bit of 'padding out'. This sounds like it does work though and I would probably enjoy this. Great review. Carol x

bandcamp

bandcamp

10.01.2006 04:01

I've not seen this but believe that what you've said regarding the characters and storyline seems to cover all the bases. Hope it's shown on the telly soon :P M x

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment
Compare Prices sorted by Price
Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon [DVD] [1942]

Sherlock Holmes -​ The Secret Weapon [DVD] [1942]

Release Date: 2004-07-19, Rating Parental Guidance,

£ 0.96 amazon dvd 719 Ratings

Postage & Packaging: £1.​21

Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-​2 business days.​.​.

     Visit Shop  

amazon dvd

Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon-DVD

Sherlock Holmes -​ The Secret Weapon-​DVD

...

£ 3.73 thehut.com 25 Ratings

Postage & Packaging: £0.​00

Availability: Usually despatched within 2-​4 weeks.​.​.​.

     Visit Shop  

thehut.​com

Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon [DVD] [1942]

Sherlock Holmes -​ The Secret Weapon [DVD] [1942]

Release Date: 2004-07-19, Rating Parental Guidance,

£ 5.89 amazon marketplace dvd 94 Ratings

Postage & Packaging: Free!

Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours.​.​.

     Visit Shop  

amazon marketplace dvd



Compare prices
Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon [DVD] [1942] Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon-DVD Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon [DVD] [1942]
Sherlock Holmes -​ The Secret Weapon [DVD] [1942] Sherlock Holmes -​ The Secret Weapon-​DVD Sherlock Holmes -​ The Secret Weapon [DVD] [1942]
amazon dvd thehut.com amazon marketplace dvd
£ 0.96 £ 3.73 £ 5.89
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
more
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
more
Postage & Packaging: Free!
more
 Visit Shop  Visit Shop  Visit Shop
amazon dvd thehut.​com amazon marketplace dvd
Similar offers
Sheet of 4 Stickers Movie Poster-Sherlock Holmes Secret Weapon 1942 10cm Square Drinks Coaster Movie Poster-Sherlock Holmes Secret Weapon 1942 58mm Large Round Keyring Featuring Movie Poster-Sherlock Holmes Secret Weapon 1942
Sheet of 4 Stickers Movie Poster-​Sherloc​k Holmes Secret Weapon .​.​. 10cm Square Drinks Coaster Movie Poster-​Sherloc​k Holmes Secret Weapon .​.​. 58mm Large Round Keyring Featuring Movie Poster-​Sherloc​k Holmes Secret .​.​.
amazon kitchen amazon kitchen amazon kitchen
£ 3.94 £ 2.94 £ 1.99
Postage & Packaging: Check Site.
more
Postage & Packaging: Check Site.
more
Postage & Packaging: Check Site.
more
 Visit Shop  Visit Shop  Visit Shop
amazon kitchen amazon kitchen amazon kitchen
Review Ratings
This review of Sherlock Holmes - The Secret Weapon (DVD) has been rated:

"very helpful" by (100%):
  1. The_Glasgow_Superstar
  2. JohnGroom
  3. Soho_Black
and 19 other members

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.
Products you might be interested in
Columbo - Series 3 - Complete (Box Set) (DVD) Columbo - Series 3 - Complete (Box Set) (DVD)

This product has not yet been reviewed. Rate it now
Buy now for only £ 3.93
The Miss Marple Collection - Starring Joan Hickson (Box Set) (DVD) The Miss Marple Collection - Starring Joan Hickson (Box Set) (DVD)
Mystery - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring: Joan Hickson
2 reviews
Buy now for only £ 36.88
Sherlock Holmes - The Definitive Collection (Box Set) (DVD) Sherlock Holmes - The Definitive Collection (Box Set) (DVD)
Mystery - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring: Basil Rathbone, Nigel Bruce
1 review
Buy now for only £ 15.70
Related products on eBay