If you've left me a rating on either my Imaginarium of Dr Parnassus or In the Valley of Elah reviews...
If you've left me a rating on either my Imaginarium of Dr Parnassus or In the Valley of Elah reviews, please let me know as they are showing up as 'not yet rated' even though at least fifteen of you have rated each one.
Member since:11.07.2000
Reviews:778
Members who trust:82
In feudal China, power belongs to whoever is strong enough to take it. The Manchurian Ching Dynasty is in control, banning the practice of martial arts in order to avoid rebellion and dealing brutally with anyone that flouts the edict. Local warlord Fire-wind profits from the law by ruthlessly enforcing it. The only place to hold out is Martial Village, the inhabitants of which send envoys to the mystical Mount Heaven. There they find seven master swordsmen and only they can defeat the despotic Fire-wind and save Martial Village.
Vietnamese-born director Tsui Hark is one of the most highly regarded filmmakers in South-East Asia. As producer and director he has helped to create a new wave in Chinese cinema and has revitalised the wu xia genre. This type of martial arts film marries historical fact and mythical heroes and showcases breathtakingly inventive and often balletic martial arts smack-downs. Hark is a master of this, having previously helmed instalments of the "Once Upon a Time in China" and "Chinese Ghost Story" franchises. His take on epic Chinese cinema is faithful to its roots but, thankfully, with far higher production values. He knows his audience and provides romance, adventure, mysticism and cracking fight choreography. The cinematography is crisp and Hark's direction sharp yet reverential to the genre. He shoots in luscious colours that direct the audience in how to feel. The opening massacre appears in muted greys and saturated reds, while the pastoral idyll of Martial Vilage is presented in golden hues and Fire-wind's city in a range of unappetising greys and blacks. His attention to detail is superb, giving each of the seven swords as much of a personality as its' master. They all look and work differently and each has a unique sound that identifies it amongst others. The homely yet ultimately good village is rustic and careworn, but far preferable to the
decadence of Fire-wind's fortress that is little more than a gilded cage for some of its inhabitants.
Hark sets the historical scene quickly, establishing the heroes and villains through an initial attack on a village. Fire-wind's Chinese Goth mercenaries turn up with all manner of implausible fighting gizmos, hell-bent on killing or maiming as many of the inhabitants as possible. The implied violence is brutal and messy, leaving you in no doubt of the kind of people we are dealing with. Leaving desolation in their wake and trying to stop a lone villager from spreading news of their massacre, we are introduced to the daydreaming Fang, who will no doubt be integral to the plot. Issues like good and evil are presented in black and white terms, as are themes like honour and duty. Once you've been told you're a hero, you can't back out and go home. However, there are some issues with pacing as the initial trek up to Mount Heaven is rather long and event free, and passing time is only denoted by time-lapse cloud photography. Hark also has a tendency towards languid shots of sweeping vistas that look beautiful but don't do much to advance the narrative. It's only during the action sequences that the pace picks up and you feel breathless excitement as the actors show off feats of acrobatics and traditional wire-work stunts that make them appear superhuman. And of course many are shot with the now obligatory slow motion. The film clocks in at a whopping hundred and fifty-three minutes and though there are plenty of thrills and spills, it does occasionally drag.
The screenplay by Chi-Sing Cheung and Tin Nam Chun deals in the same superhuman heroes as most epic Chinese cinema. They are all ultimately good, though some may have more shadowy backgrounds than others and are using their quest to help the villagers as a form of redemption. From the venerable old master to the nervous newcomer they are all represented. There is a certain predictability about the film because it follows in the footsteps of traditional Chinese cinema; good will always triumph over evil and there will be a happy ending, so there aren't that many surprises in terms of plotting. There's the usual cycle of skirmishes and setbacks (showing layers of intrigue and betrayal amongst the villagers) before the warriors take on the villain on his own turf to give him a good shoeing. There's even a brief romantic sub-plot that sees Fang mooning after her colleague Han while he's falling for someone else. There is the usual handful of morals for the watching public; everyone has to make sacrifices, yada-yada-yada. Though learning martial arts is used as a metaphor for developing patience and spiritual enlightenment, the movie seems to be saying that brute force is the only way to solve your problems.
I don't think martial arts star Donnie Yen gets his due often enough because the films he chooses to make don't necessarily have massive international appeal. But in terms of fighting skills, he's one of few actors that can match Jet Li for speed as he proved in "Hero". He's also not a bad actor, especially when required to play the strong silent type, like Dragon Sword here. It always looks as if there's something going on behind his eyes and you can practically see the cogs whirring.
As sole female warrior in the movie, Fang, Jingchu Zhang-Liu has a tough task. But she keeps the right balance of power and softness. I think it helps that she's playing the unwilling apprentice role. She comes across as a bit of a tomboy and therefore isn't required to show the exaggerated ideal of Chinese movie femininity. So she's allowed to be graceless, clumsy and a touch comical. But once she gets the bit in her teeth with the action sequences, there's no stopping her and she brings real driving force to the action sequences.
It's hard to believe that Liu Chia-Liang is seventy. The guy otherwise known as Gordon Liu and star of many a shoddy Shaw Brothers chop-socky actioner from the 70s is still going strong. Here he plays yet another in a long line of wise mentor types as Mount Heaven's Fu Qing Ju as well as choreographing all the stunts. Admittedly he doesn't do as much punching, kicking and flying around as the other characters, but you've got to admire his chutzpah at an age where most people's idea of excitement is a Barbara Cartland novel to go with your Ovaltine.
As warlord Fire-wind, Honglei Sun does stereotypical megalomania complete with ludicrous 'tache and maniacal laughter. I'm not sure how to refer to his performance as it goes way beyond pantomime into some realm that is always inhabited by Chinese movie villains. He does so much scenery-chewing, you can't help checking the set for teeth-marks.
The fight choreography is superb; speedy and accomplished. It incorporates a great deal of traditional and quite obvious wirework - people just aren't able to defy the laws of physics quite as easily as the film makes out. They hang in the air just a fraction longer than is plausible and can make leaps and bounds that usually requires a serious trampoline. The movement is fluid and acrobatic and the fights, though elegant can be extraordinarily brutal. The highlight is definitely the corridor fight between Dragon Sword and Fire-wind that barely touches the ground and features the two men flying at each other like whirling dervishes.
The score by Kenji Kawai follows the lead of the rest of the film going for an epic score that references the traditional Chinese roots of the story. It's a large-scale orchestral work that makes the most of stabbing strings to grab the attention and cellos to add aural depth. The music is never less than full-blooded using traditional Chinese motifs such as gongs, chimes and Mandarin vocals to set the scene. During the fight sequences, the ante is upped with insistent rhythms and kodo drums. The climactic attack on Fire-wind's city is accompanied by frenetic brass that embodies the chaos of the moment, while triumphal flutes and drums celebrate the heroes' inevitable victory.
"Seven Swords" is the sort of movie you will enjoy of cross-over films such as "House of Flying Daggers" whetted your appetite for period martial arts epics. However, if you're hoping for chop-socky without context, you'd be better off renting a Jackie Chan film. You do need to read the excellent subtitles to follow what's going on. Here the emphasis is on detail. That being said, there is a lack of character development where some protagonists are concerned and there are perhaps too many concessions to the traditional wu xia format. But it is beautifully shot and the stunt choreography is great. It may not be the best introduction to the genre, but to fans it may be a worthwhile addition to your collection, even if it is a trifle overlong and hammily acted in parts.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Production Year: 2003 - Martial Arts - Director: Paul Hunter - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring: Chow Yun-Fat, Seann William Scott, James King, Karel Roden
Martial Arts - Director: Prachya Pinkaew - Original Language: English\Vietnamese\Thai\Mandarin - Classification: 18 years and over - Starring: Tony Jaa, Bongkoj Khongmalai, Petchtai Wongkamlao
Production Year: 1981 - Martial Arts - Director: Kenji Misumi, Robert Houston - Original Language: English - Classification: 18 years and over - Starring: Kayo Matsuo, Minoru Ohki, Akiji Kobayashi, Shin Kishida, Masahiro Tomikawa, Tomisaburo Wakayama
Martial Arts - Original Language: English - Classification: 18 years and over - Starring: Bruce Lee, Sho Kosugi, James Ryan, Jim Kelly, Jimmy Wang Yu, Bolo Yeung, Christopher Lee
I remember seeing the trailer for this and it seemed to be a bit of a lost film: if it had come down before crouching tiger, hero et al then it might have been more successful but judging by your review it might be worth catching, almost as a bit of an 'almost period' piece. Certainly your comment about it not being Jackie Chan-esque (who irritates me no end) adds a little in the incentive to watch it.
wolfatgoogle 03.12.2006 10:10
Sounds good to me. Good review - i like your title! Wolf x
perfectlypolished 02.12.2006 20:39
Not heard of this before but interesting review. Lin