Who'd have thought university would be so time-consuming!
Who'd have thought university would be so time-consuming!
Member since:19.06.2005
Reviews:131
Members who trust:90
For such a famous director, Sam Mendes has made very few films. Only two in fact; the multi-Oscar winning American Beauty and this 2002 follow-up, Road To Perdition. Although follow-up isn't really the right term, as this is completely different. I was surprised to find that this did not win any major Oscars, although it was nominated for about six, because it really is a brilliant film. I was also surprised that for such a great film, it was not advertised very well; I didn't really know anything about this film before I saw it, and I bet lots of people don't know about it at all, which is a shame.
The story tells of a hit man for the Irish mafia, Mike Sullivan (played by Tom Hanks). He and his two sons have a close relationship with the godfather John Rooney (played by Paul Newman). Sullivan keeps his job a secret from his children, but when his son Michael (Tyler Hoechlin) follows him and witnesses the murder of a rival (Ciaran Hinds, from tv show Rome), he is forced to explain. Things get further complicated when Rooney's son, Connor (Daniel Craig, new James Bond) murders Sullivan's wife and other child, leaving the two Michaels to flee to a relative. They go to Chicago, where they come across Frank Nitti (Stanley Tucci), an aide of Al Capone, and Sullivan offers
to work for him if he is allowed to avenge the murder of his family. However, Frank refuses and sets a psychotic photographer (Jude Law) on the pair's trail, leading to a dramatic showdown.
This is a film about family, betrayal and guilt, rather than about crime and violence, as you may have expected from the subject. The plot has lots of twists and turns, and I like the way that there isn't really a hero in the film: although Sullivan is protecting his son at all times, he remains a cold-blooded killer. Just when you think you can guess what's about to happen, the story switches, and you find out that characters are not as they seem. The many subplots all fit together nicely, leaving a very well-rounded story.
The acting from the top-drawer cast is superb, especially Jude Law, who is played completely against type as a weird and creepy photographer obsessed with dead bodies. In fact, most of the actors in this film are playing unusual roles - when was the last time Tom Hanks played a character so dislikeable? Paul Newman also deserves a mention, as he was nominated for a Best Supporting Oscar. The screen legend shows no sign of letting up despite being 77 when he made this, although his scenes are full of frailty and agedness, which gives some sympathy to a pretty nasty character.
The direction from Sam Mendes is fantastic, and I rate the film so highly due to its technical achievements even more than its story. Both of his films have had a lot of visual flair, and with the help of the famous director of photography Connor L Hall (who also worked on Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid with Paul Newman), he creates some striking scenes. Everything from the tiniest little details - a puff of cigarette smoke, or a streaky winter sky - right up to a brutal murder and the final rain-soaked showdown, looks fantastic. This cinematography deservedly won an Oscar. Mendes even finds time for a little gun-slinging action scene, which he does equally well. The sets and locations all look stunning, with the buildings of Chicago put to good affect, and everything has an authentic 1930s depression-period feel.
But the aspect of the film which I found most striking was the Oscar-nominated musical score. This film has music in practically every scene, but it's not in an obtrusive way, and it creates a very mystical atmosphere. I think it was composed by Thomas Newman, and it reminded me of American Beauty (he worked on that film with Sam Mendes), but also The Shawshank Redemption, with lots of piano and soaring violins. I would say that the music carried me through every minute, except that the film didn't really need carrying since it was so absorbing in its own right.
My favourite part of the film was the finale. Not the very last scenes, but when Sullivan confronts those who betrayed him, most notably Paul Newman's character. The scene is shot in heavy rain at night, and it's completely striking and original. John Rooney is standing in the streets surrounded by his henchmen, when suddenly someone opens fire and they are all killed one by one around him, in a kind of slow-motion. You may be thinking this sounds a bit violent, or even a bit Matrix Revolutions, but only because I can't describe it properly. Well it turns out to be Sullivan, and he kills everyone but Rooney, and slowly walks up to him, and it's really tense because you don't know whether he will kill him or not. And I won't tell you.
If I had to pick out negative points with the film, they would mostly be about the ending. I found that the story got a bit confused, and ended up with a lot of bloodshed just because it didn't really know where else to go. It's probably that Sam Mendes was trying to make a point about the soul or something, but I thought it could have been ended slightly better. The last scenes also verged on the schmaltzy and predictable, including Michael Jnr playing on a beach with a dog. But since these were preceded by something quite unexpected, I can allow them.
Overall, I think that this is one of the best - and most overlooked - films of the last few years. Up there with Mystic River, it goes down in the list of films that surely should have won Best Picture but didn't. This was the year when Chicago won them all, and as good as that is, I think this is probably better. But anyway, this is a film I would heartily recommend to everyone, whether you like mafia films or not, whether you are familiar with Sam Mendes or not, or even if you're not a particularly big film fan; you can't miss this wonderful film.
This film is available to buy quite easily online or on in DVD retailer; the cheapest price I could find online being £5.99 from www.blahdvd.com. I am only reviewing the film.
Directed by: Sam Mendes Starring: Tom Hanks, Paul Newman, Jude Law, Daniel Craig, Stanley Tucci, Jennifer Jason Leigh, Ciaran Hinds Running time: 117 minutes Classification: 15
Pictures of Road To Perdition (DVD)
Paul Newman getting wet
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Production Year: 2004 - Drama - Director: John Duigan - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Charlize Theron, Stuart Townsend, Penelope Cruz
Production Year: 2004 - Drama - Director: Nick Cassavetes - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over, 12 years and over - Starring: Rachel McAdams, Ryan Gosling, Gena Rowlands
A movie with an impeccable pedigree,Road to Perditionis director Sam Mendes' impressive ... more
follow-up toAmerican Beauty, and features remarkable contributions from veteran cinematographer Conrad Hall, composer Thomas Newman and a cast of thespian brillianc...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
He shouldn't have been there. But in the moment that Michael Sullivan's son witnessed a ... more
brutal slaying, the lives of this 12 year old and his gangster father are shattered irrevocably. Now, targeted by the mob he's devoted his life to, Sullivan and his...
Advantages: The soundtrack was amazing, and so were the actors and direction. Disadvantages: I felt the film did not actually go anywhere, it had no intriguing plot, and went no where new in terms of cinema.
Skeptik 19.11.2002 (19.11.2002)
·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: somewhat helpful
Review of Road To Perdition (DVD)