This is a FILM-ONLY review ---------------------------------------
Take one generic disaster movie plot based on a successful seventies film ("The Poseidon Adventure"). Add in a few generic disaster movie characters, plus a homosexual to make it all cosily politically correct. Throw in a star name or two, get yourself a huge special effects budget, and viola! You have Poseidon.
You may be able to work out from that not only that this film didn't do much for me, but that I'm not a great fan of the disaster movie genre. Apart from Volcano (which benefited greatly from having Tommy Lee Jones as the central character), I really can't name another that truly gripped me. (There may be one or two, but none that I can remember at the moment.) In fact I wasn't going to watch this one at all but as my other half decided she wanted to watch it, I saw it yesterday evening.
Take one generic disaster movie plot… - all seems fine, disaster happens,
lots of people die, a few brave souls try to survive, some of them get killed, some of them survive. Great heroics are shown, at least one act of the ultimate sacrifice is made, at least one female character just stands there screaming without ever doing a single useful thing. The end.
Well, Poseidon can't really help having a predictable "This ship cannot sink!" … … … "Oh dear, this ship is in fact sinking" moment, it has the same inevitability as Titanic. (Oh hang on, I did enjoy that one - oops, there goes my last tiny scrap of credibility…) With equal inevitability there's a rugged male character who unwillingly takes the lead and gains redemption for his previously self-centred way of life, an over-protective father with mildly rebellious daughter who has love interest in tow, a mother who can't do anything but call out her child's name (and scream), and a stowaway. I think it's fair to say that I have no idea if these elements came from the 1972 film, as I don't remember seeing it, but it did all seem somewhat predictable.
From the major disaster (which happens early in the film) caused by a "rogue wave", there are a series of mini-disasters along the way. The tension is sustained and unrelenting, which is another way of saying that it nearly put me to sleep as tension is only effective if it is broken every now and then. Once or twice the plot did stretch believability just that little bit too far (I know people are capable of incredible things when their adrenaline's running but do you really believe that a small boy with an improvised tool and reaching through a small gap could undo screws that would have undoubtedly been put in place by a power tool?!?), and the fact that a few of the early scenes actually looked as though the characters were standing in front of a screen didn't help that.
On the other hand, the effects were undoubtedly good in many places and the music tried its very best to stir some emotion and build atmosphere. (Klaus Badelt's excellent score should have graced a much better film than this.) John Seale's cinematography was also of a very high standard. The cast was very varied in quality… Josh Lucas as the tough loner come team leader Dylan Johns was good, Kurt Russell was okay as slightly over-bearing father and former Mayor Robert Ramsey, and Andre Braugher was good as the ship's captain. (Not much of a part really, but he was good in it!) Most of the other performances were passable or slightly better. Emmy Rossum as Jennifer Ramsey (as mildly rebellious daughter of slightly overbearing father) really didn't convince at all, her emotions seemed completely forced (again…) Maybe that type of acting works fine when most of the audience if a hundred feet away and can't see your face properly, but in films it really fails badly.
Well, there you go. I didn't like it, but then I didn't really expect to, and I'm not a fan of the genre. I wasn't impressed by Wolfgang Peterson's direction, but then he was delivering what his target audience (which didn't include me) wanted, so I can't really fault him too much for that. If you like disaster flicks then you'll probably enjoy this my wife liked it a lot more than I did), but for me this only barely gets 3 stars. It just goes to show (again) that effects and set design do not on their own make a good movie. But then we all knew that didn't we? Apart from many film-makers, apparently...
Production Year: 1964 - Action/Adventure - Director: Cyril Endfield - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring:Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, James Booth, Michael Caine, Nigel Green
Production Year: 1977 - Action/Adventure - Director: Clint Eastwood - Original Language: English - Classification: 18 years and over - Starring:Clint Eastwood, Sondra Locke, Pat Hingle, William Prince, Bill McKinney
Production Year: 2002 - Action/Adventure - Director: Vincenzo Natali - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring:Lucy Liu, David Hewlett, Anne Marie Scheffler, Joseph Scoren, Matthew Sharp, Jeremy Northam
Not a film I have seen. I saw the original. I cannot see the point in remaking a film with a bigger budget and more special effects, so I don't think I will bother. John
missy0303 30.06.2006 19:56
I'm sort of between wanting to see it and not wanting to at the moment.....think I'll wait and see how many bad reviews it gets before making up my mind lol x
Shortsharpshock 27.06.2006 18:27
I still might give it a go despite your dislike for the film.
The 1972 disaster hitThe Poseidon Adventurewas ripe for a big-budget CGI remake, and who ... more
better to helm it than thriller expert Wolfgang Petersen, director ofDas BootandThe Perfect Storm? It hardly matters that a TV movie remake (also based on Paul Gal...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
The 1972 disaster hitThe Poseidon Adventurewas ripe for a big-budget CGI remake, and who ... more
better to helm it than thriller expert Wolfgang Petersen, director ofDas BootandThe Perfect Storm? It hardly matters that a TV movie remake (also based on Paul Gal...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
Mayday... It's New Year's Eve and festivities have begun aboard the luxury cruise ship ... more
Poseidon at sea in the North Atlantic. One of the finest vessels of its kind Poseidon stands more than 20 stories tall boasts 800 staterooms and 13 passenger dec...
Postage & Packaging: £0.00 Availability: 3-5 working days
Its New Year's Eve on the Poseidon - a state of the art cruise liner on its way to New ... more
York - as partying voyagers lift their glasses and toast the future, little do they realise their predicament. Rapidly approaching is a 150-foot rogue wave that when...
![Poseidon [DVD] [2006]](http://picnicb.ciao.com/uk/78462323.jpg "Poseidon [DVD] [2006]")
Jun 26th, 2006
very helpful by (94%):
helpful by (6%):
