Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
SHOPPING > DVDs > Westerns > Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) > Reviews

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD)

from (4 offers) · Product Information

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD)

Quote-start

They just don't make them like they used to

Quote-end

5 Apr 8th, 2009 

25 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Riveting, four main stars, the score, the direction, where shall I stop?

Disadvantages:
None for me, although it's long and slow, which may not be your cup of tea

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

pmcds

pmcds

About me:

Seems like we're getting back on an even keel with the rating viewings now. Quite liking the new pag...

Member since:07.11.2005

Reviews:461

Members who trust:48

A film only review:

Every now and then, along comes a film to make you stop and think. One that makes you wish you had been there. One that reminds you of things you have seen in different snippets of films and books more recently. Essentially, one that is so good that it inspires others and creates future elements in films that are so subtle that you only notice them restrospectively.

And this is how I would class Sergio Leone's epic 'Once Upon A Time In The West'. It is regarded as the fourth in the trilogy of 'Spaghetti' Westerns and provides an apt depiction of the end of the Wild West. 'West' is a very slow film, and Leone relies very much on his style of wide-angle shots immediate close-ups, with a panning camera not the focus as it is in most films. It is this style that we see immediately, as the immesurably long opening sequence sets the scene for what is to come.

It opens on a train station in the Wild West, shortly before the advent of the railroad system that laid waste to the long and stretching plains which were hard to traverse and gave them an easy way to cross. The ominous nature of the film starts here, straight away, as silence and lengthy pauses with closeups focus on three men who take control of the station to wait for the arrival of a nameless drifter (Charles Bronson).

The drifter turns out to be a man playing a harmonica, and the men have been sent by the mercenaric gun for hire Frank (Henry Fonda). Dispatching with the men, we see the true determination of the man who becomes known purely as Harmonica, as he continues on his journey, seemingly without purpose.

Elsewhere, Jill McBain (Claudia Cardinale) is off to join the family she has married into, on a house mysteriously set apart from anywhere else, and with a curious owner who has promised her riches. However, when she arrives to find the family massacred by Frank and his men, she embarks on her own journey to exact revenge.

Into the scene comes a third 'journeyman' as such, that of the notorious bandit Cheyenne (Jason Robards), recently escaped from captivity who has been set up by Frank as the murderer of the McBain family. These three heroes cross paths a few times before combining their efforts to thwart Frank and his employer, the railroad developer Morton, who are trying to gain the McBains' land in order to monopolise the railroad running right through the plains.

The plot is a well celebrated and copied format, with a virtual game of chess unfolding as we see the three 'heroes' calmly go about their quest, and beneath it all lies the unexplained reasons behind Harmonica seeking out Frank. Indeed, throughout the film, Frank continually asks Harmonica his name, only to be answered with the name of various men that the gun for hire has murdered. This frustrates Frank, and while this frustration is very subtle and slight, the direction of Leone by exacting long pauses makes it all the more meaningful.

In fact, the acting and direction are perfectly done by the four main leads. Bronson has always struck me as a bit of a loose cannon when it comes to his performances. Here, he surpasses other films I have seen him in, even The Magnificent Seven, where I believe he is excellent. In West, as a character very much in the mould of Eastwood's Man With No Name, he does Leone's recurring style of character justice throughout, from start to finish, his weathered features seemingly apt for such an obviously disturbed and introvertial character.

On the other side of the scale is the animation of Fonda as Frank, with his ruthlessness being displayed throughout save for one moment where he relaxes and calms down in an intimate moment with Jill. As with Bronson, Fonda's skill is shown through the close-ups, as the lengthy scenes often focus on the characters' faces without moving. In this respect, the acting is done through the eyes. Fonda's cool and calculating eyes are void of emotion, and it's riveting!

Curiously, the gruff and almost afterthought-nature of Robards' Cheyenne releases the immense tension between Frank and Harmonica. It is needed to relax us as an audience as well, as the film is nearly 3 hours long and the intensity would be too much without the comedic element Cheyenne brings, although this is more in the form of the odd awkward posture or a shake of the head as opposed to a quirky one-liner or a funny moment.

Cardinale plays the damaged wife very well, her anger towards Frank so intense that it is displayed extremely in places, her anger seeping through to the other leads as well. Indeed, there are many similarities between the three male leads, with testosterone between the characters zipping back and forth throughout, as the upper hand switches places many times before finding its final resting place. Cardinale, as Jill, sits firmly in the middle of the masculine triangle, as the tenuous links between the four of them flip and change throughout the film. It really is well conceived and excellently executed on the screen behind and in front of the camera.

What amazes me even more is the score from Ennio Morricone and how Leone uses it to announce each character on screen. The different tempos for each of the four main characters (powerful female solo for Jill, heavy guitar for Frank, deft harmonica for Harmonica(!) and gently humourous twangs for Cheyenne) fit perfectly. What is even better are the silences when these four are not on screen and when there are more of them on at a time. The music is excellently placed.

Let's not beat about the bush. The film is long, and it is not for the faint hearted. It is a very well executed Western, and has a genuinely believable set of grievances at its heart, providing the fuel for the characters' dedication to their causes. The long and expansive camera shots and the extensive silences may not be your cup of tea, but it is hard to not appreciate how riveting this makes the film. The Coen Brothers successfully managed to mimic this in No Country For Old Men, with the visual doing a lot of the talking, and Leone earlier trilogy of Westerns featuring The Man With No Name are also very much in the same mould, but West has to be one of the best Westerns, if not films, I have ever seen. I was thoroughly riveted for the entirety of the film.

Apparently, there are references throughout the film to other Westerns, although I missed this. Perhaps I was focused too much on the plot at hand, too engrossed to let my mind wander to find tedious links to other films or previously visited elements. I feel it is a shame that the release of this film in the US was held back for legal reasons as battles were ongoing at the time, but perhaps this has helped to make the film an even more appreciated 3 hours of genius.

The phrase, 'They don't make them like they used to' really odes apply here. I can't remember a Western that was so powerful. 'Forgiven' and 'Open Range' have come close in using blunt and visual approaches, and are great films, but these still don't touch the surface of Leone's excellent show here. I can see how Leone has affected Stephen King's portrayal of his hero Roland of Gilead in his 'The Dark Tower' saga, and no doubt for the next few years I will spot other bits and pieces that remind me of this film. It's no surprise. If I was a director or an actor, I'd probably look here for inspiration, too.

Once Upon A Time In The West has been released on various DVD formats. Sadly, I only have the privilege of having seen it as a film only production, but I'm likely to go and buy the film in all its glory and plethora of extras. Rarely am I bothered by extras, but this may just be the one exception. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Western Union (DVD)

Western Union (DVD)

Production Year: 1941 - Westerns - Director: Fritz Lang - Original Language: English - Classification: Universal - Starring: Randolph Scott, Dean Jagger, Barton MacLane, Robert Young

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 4.47

The Return Of A Man Called Horse (DVD)

The Return Of A Man Called Horse (DVD)

Production Year: 1976 - Westerns - Director: Irvin Kershner - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Gale Sondergaard, Geoffrey Lewis, William Lucking, Jorge Luke, Richard Harris

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 2.34

James Stewart Collection (Box Set) (DVD)

James Stewart Collection (Box Set) (DVD)

Westerns - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring: James Stewart

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 10.93

Wyatt Earp (DVD)

Wyatt Earp (DVD)

(+) extremely accurate
(-) early years of Wyatt Earp feel a touch rushed

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 0.01

MacKenna's Gold (DVD)

MacKenna's Gold (DVD)

(+) Great action scenes and a very interesting story line...
(-) Not many

User reviews (2)

Buy now for only £ 2.85

Western Classics Collection (Box Set) (DVD)

Western Classics Collection (Box Set) (DVD)

Westerns - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 14.89

Comments about this review »

mumsymary 17.04.2009 08:08

you made this sound interesting

marcellep2 09.04.2009 20:50

Great Review - Rob

Gladiator007 08.04.2009 17:03

nicely reviewed....:)

Compare prices for Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) »

1 to 4 out of 4 offers for Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD)   sorted by: Price 
Once Upon a Time in the West -- Special Collector's Edition (2 discs) [DVD] [1969]

Once Upon a Time in the West -- Special Collector's Edition (2 discs) [DVD] [1969]

Sergio Leone had to be persuaded to return to the Western forOnce Upon a Time in the ... more

Westafter the success of his "Dollars" trilogy.
The result is a masterpiece that expands the
vision of the earlier movies in every way.  It
could as easily have been c...

amazon marketplace dvd

Postage & Packaging£1.21
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace d...
Once Upon a Time in the West -- Special Collector's Edition (2 discs) [DVD] [1969]

Once Upon a Time in the West -- Special Collector's Edition (2 discs) [DVD] [1969]

Sergio Leone had to be persuaded to return to the Western forOnce Upon a Time in the ... more

Westafter the success of his "Dollars" trilogy.
The result is a masterpiece that expands the
vision of the earlier movies in every way.  It
could as easily have been c...

amazon dvd

Postage & Packagingfree Super Saver Delivery
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon dvd
Once Upon A Time In The West-DVD

Once Upon A Time In The West-DVD

thehut.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityIn stock - Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
thehut.com


More reviews »

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) - review by cladach29

Advantages: Stunning scenery, stars Henry Fonda, clipped dialogue
Disadvantages: Long, lack of dialogue may not appeal to everyone,

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) - review by cladach29 cladach29 05.10.2006 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD)

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) - review by dreamstar70

Advantages: Too Many To Mention!!
Disadvantages: Beware of shorter prints, go for the full 165min version

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) - review by dreamstar70 dreamstar70 27.01.2001 (27.01.2001) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD)

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) - review by peel.rebekah

Advantages: Waaay to many.
Disadvantages: Nada.

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) - review by peel.rebekah peel.rebekah 12.10.2001 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD)

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) - review by richkw

Advantages: Too many to list.
Disadvantages: One or 2 scenes are a little long.

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) - review by richkw richkw 12.07.2005 (12.07.2005) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD)

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) - review by newty1977

Advantages: Digitally Remastered with Widescreen version enhanced for 16:9
Disadvantages: Not for those with short attention spans

Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD) - review by newty1977 newty1977 19.01.2006 (08.04.2006) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD)



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Once Upon A Time In The West (Collector's Edition) (DVD)? Click here