Similar offers
Postage & Packaging: £0.00
Postage & Packaging: Free!
Postage & Packaging: £0.00
SHOPPING > DVDs > Family > Nancy Drew (DVD) > Reviews

Nancy Drew (DVD)

Quote-start

Nancy Drew: Super Sleuth

Quote-end

3 May 29th, 2008 

74 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Entertaining

Disadvantages:
Deviates from the original, could have been better

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

sunmeilan

sunmeilan

About me:

Have a wonderful Christmas everyone!

Member since:05.05.2005

Reviews:977

Members who trust:378

In her hometown of River Heights, Nancy Drew is famous for being a sleuth; even the local police forced looks up to her, and it seems she can put no foot wrong. Then she moves away from home temporarily with her father, Carson Drew, who has been assigned a legal case in California and wants Nancy to concentrate on being a teenager rather than a sleuth. At her new school, Nancy is looked upon as a bit of a geek with obsessional tendencies. Luckily, she manages to rise above her tormentors, and she finds a new case. The house that the Drews are renting previously belonged to a famous actress, now deceased, but there has always been suspicion about her death and a possible inheritance. Can Nancy, along with friends Corky and Ned, solve the years' old mystery? Or has Nancy finally bitten off more than she can chew?

I have a confession to make. I have always been a secret Nancy Drew fan and I still enjoy the occasional fix even now. So when this movie came out, I knew that I had to watch. The Nancy Drew books, created by Carolyn Keene, have been around for years, which obviously created a bit of a dilemma for the director of this film, Andrew Fleming, because he must have wanted both to create characters and a story that would suit Nancy Drew fans and attract a new legion of fans by coming up with something a bit more modern than the original stories. Was he successful? Yes and no....

Emma Roberts stars as Nancy Drew. She just about manages to look the part. Nancy is famous for her red hair (the author refers to it as titian, which used to make me giggle as a little girl - and still does if I'm being honest!); Emma Roberts isn't perhaps as red-haired as she could be, but it is passable, and she generally gives a good performance. However, there are quite a few differences between the original Nancy and this one - obviously not Roberts' fault - Nancy Drew is loved and admired by absolutely everyone around her, so to see her ridiculed by her schoolmates was a bit strange. I know that she needed updating for the film - and the original Nancy could be incredibly annoying with her holier than thou attitude, but to change the way that everyone sees her didn't sit right with me. It didn't ruin the film for me, but this factor really did stand out and detract from the film.

I was disappointed that Nancy's best friends, Bess and George, didn't really feature in the film, apart from the first five minutes. Ned Nickerson, Nancy's boyfriend, was there though, played by Max Thieriot, although again, he seems to have had a personality change. Constantly unsure of Nancy's feelings for him, he comes across as being very insecure, a far cry from the confident Ned Nickerson of the books. The same thing happened to Carson Drew, played by Tate Donovan. Carson Drew is a respected lawyer, always in work, and perfect in almost every way. The film's Carson Drew is a bit of a failure, having to take whatever work he can in order to give Nancy a better life. Both Thieriot and Donovan are good in the roles; I just didn't really recognise them.

I think the director would have done much better to concentrate on characters that weren't regular appearances in the books. I enjoyed watching Josh Flitter as Corky; he adds a real touch of humour to the proceedings and I could sit back and enjoy it, without comparing him to a character in the book. His sister and her friend were also amusing, and, with their modern clothes and hairstyles, really make the film seem that much more up to date, as does the soundtrack.

The storyline wasn't brilliant, but I wasn't really expecting it to be. The original plots weren't too hot either. However, it was an enjoyable enough romp, and although not exactly memorable, it is probably better than most films aimed at this target audience. I think that, characters aside, the director has done a good job at making the story appealing to a modern audience. Nancy has modern appliances at her fingertips to help her solve crimes - the mobile phone didn't exist when the original Nancy was created - but the solution to the crime still comes about by hard work and Nancy's quick brain.

What I am not so sure about is whether the film will have persuaded a new legion of fans to the Nancy Drew franchise. The series is obviously set in the US and I am sure that there are many more fans over there than in the UK, so it is perhaps hard for me to judge. However, I don't really have the impression that the Nancy Drew character went down all that well here. People seem to have thought that the film was okay, but I don't see masses of interest in Nancy Drew as a character, which is a shame - I feel as if a marketing opportunity was somehow missed. I do hope that there will be future Nancy Drew films though, so perhaps there is still hope. I would love to think that a whole new generation can enjoy the same stories that I have known and loved for years.

It is hard to tell what age group this film is aimed at - obviously it is not really aimed at my generation (late thirties), although I am sure there are many who have enjoyed it! I think it would probably be most suited for early teens, like the books, although Nancy is old enough to drive, so they may not be able to immediately identify with her. Nancy's chasteness does mean that the film is open to younger children - she kisses Ned on the lips towards the end and that is the most exciting it gets! I presume the guidance rating of PG is because of some minor violence rather than anything Nancy gets up to. Ultimately, this is a typical good will outweigh evil type of film and traditional values, such as politeness, smartness and tidiness, are very much stressed throughout.

I did enjoy this film, despite the discrepancies between the original characters and the way they are portrayed in the film. But I am already a Nancy fan. I just don't think that this film will have won over that many more fans, which is a great shame. Perhaps I am wrong; I do hope so. If, like me, you have enjoyed the Nancy books in the past, then this is definitely worth a look - just be prepared for the changes. If you are new to Nancy, I'm not sure that you will be all that impressed. Recommended then, with reservations.

The DVD is available from play.com for £5.99.

Classification: PG

Running time: 99 minutes 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

The Snowman/Father Christmas (DVD)

The Snowman/Father Christmas (DVD)

Family - Director: Dave Unwin, Dianne Jackson - Original Language: English - Classification: Universal, TBA - Starring: Mel Smith, David Bowie

User reviews (6)

Buy now for only £ 4.97

Anne Of Green Gables (Box Set) (DVD)

Anne Of Green Gables (Box Set) (DVD)

Family - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance

User reviews (3)

Buy now for only £ 31.99

Harry Potter - Years 1-5 (Box Set) (DVD)

Harry Potter - Years 1-5 (Box Set) (DVD)

(+) Surprising, Adventurouse, Entertaining, and good animation.
(-) Dialogues are not that much clear according to the small kids.

User reviews (11)

Buy now for only £ 6.85

The Land Before Time (Box Set) (DVD)

The Land Before Time (Box Set) (DVD)

Family - Original Language: English - Classification: Universal

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 17.85

Shrek (Animated) (DVD)

Shrek (Animated) (DVD)

(+) Good price
(-) Takes to long to get you into the film

User reviews (309)

Buy now for only £ 3.49

Shrek The Third (DVD)

Shrek The Third (DVD)

Production Year: 2007 - Family - Director: Chris Miller, Raman Hui - Original Language: English - Classification: Universal

User reviews (24)

Buy now for only £ 0.01

Comments about this review »

silverstreak 06.06.2008 10:43

Do you know, I've never read any of the books, well as they say, it's never too late to learn!

carcraig 03.06.2008 14:29

I used to love the books...a real blast from the past reading this! Good review, Caroline xx

bigfatdogs 03.06.2008 02:36

Excellent review !!

Related offers for Nancy Drew (DVD) »

Amazon UK 723 Ratings

Amazon UK

Find "Nancy Drew (DVD)" New and Used on Amazon. Free UK Delivery on orders over £25.

 Visit Shop  >
Amazon UK


More reviews »

Nancy Drew (DVD) - review by eve6kicksass

Advantages: Mostly triumphant return to the screen of Ms. Drew; Emma Roberts is outstanding
Disadvantages: Some needless supporting characters; toning down of familiar character

Nancy Drew (DVD) - review by eve6kicksass eve6kicksass 22.06.2007 (23.06.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Nancy Drew (DVD)

Nancy Drew (DVD) - review by wantaratgirl

Advantages: A fun, slightly cheesy, happy family film.
Disadvantages: A little bit girly and quite predictable.

Nancy Drew (DVD) - review by wantaratgirl wantaratgirl 18.10.2008 (18.10.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of Nancy Drew (DVD)



Are you the manufacturer / provider of Nancy Drew (DVD)? Click here