Just back from my honeymoon so look out for my Hawaiian reviews!!!
Just back from my honeymoon so look out for my Hawaiian reviews!!!
Member since:14.10.2005
Reviews:64
Members who trust:6
Early in the morning of the 5th September 1972, Palestinian terrorists broke into the athlete's village at the Munich Olympics. The terrorist group known as Black September stormed the Israeli apartments, took 9 hostages, and shot two men dead. Whilst the games went on around them, the terrorists demanded the release of hundreds of prisoners from Israeli jails as well as the release of two Germans being held in Germany. Israel refused to bend to the demands and later that night the remaining hostages were all killed in a bungled rescue bid held at Munich airport.
This event happened many years before I was born, but the shock of it has meant that it has never been forgotten. I first became aware of the events of that night whilst watching the brilliant documentary, 'One Day in September' that I saw on a flight to South Africa. Other documentaries have been made about the events of that night but this film concentrates on what happened next.
Several years after the attack, the author George Jonas was approached by a man claiming to have been the head of an Israeli team that had been ordered to track down and kill several men thought to have been involved within the Black September movement. At first he thought that these claims were unlikely, but
after confirming aspects of the mans story with research of his own, he believed that there was possibly truth. This was published in the excellent book, 'Vengeance' upon which this film is based. I would recommend reading the book before seeing the film as you can get an idea of what is happening and Jonas has helpfully added references to his work alongside parts that he was unable to confirm. (My review of his book can be found http://www.ciao.co.uk/Vengeance_George_Jonas__Review_5587449)
This film has been extremely well made and having read the book, is in my opinion, a really good interpretation. As one would expect from Steven Spielberg, this a real blockbuster and is quite thought provoking as you watch the team carry out their attacks before having to live with the consequences of their actions and the moral dilemmas that this incurs. If I had one criticism, it would be that the film was too long. It was a hard balance to maintain between getting enough information across and giving too much but sometimes I would have preferred more information about the hits than exploring the emotional aspects of the characters to such a level.
As I said above, I would recommend reading the book by George Jonas before watching this film or read about the Munich Massacre on something like wikipedia to get the background knowledge. Then allow yourself a completely free evening and sit back and enjoy the film.
STORY
Avner (Eric Bana) is a low level Mossad agent is approached by a senior member of the agency (Geoffrey Rush) to head up a small covert team to undertake retaliatory attacks on those who financed and planned the Munich attacks. Under the orders of Golda Meir (the then Israeli leader), Avner meets the rest of his small team who are all skilled in different aspects of the job. Carl (Ciarán Hinds) is the clean-up man who ensures that nothing linking the Israeli's to the attack is left behind. Steve (Daniel Craig) is a driver, Hans is an expert in forging documents and Robert is there for explosives. It soon becomes clear that they have been chosen because not only they are good at their jobs, but also due to them all originally being from other countries, they are expendable and deniability is assured.
The team start their task slowly picking off the names that they have been given whilst struggling with the morality of their task. Not only this, but Avnet has just become a father and has to deal with being apart from his wife and newborn child as paranoia starts to set in. They go about their jobs based on information given to them by a mysterious French group headed by Louis and Papa. When they themselves start to become the target of attacks, the fear is that they are being double-crossed and they must work out what to do before they all end up dead.
Although some of the aspects of this film may have been exaggerated to increase the intensity and it is plausible that Avner would choose to forget certain things, the film does seem to be possible. I'm not sure of Steven Spielberg's motivation for making this film but there are obvious parallels with the morality of the war on terror today as shown by the doubts of the team. The link is no more obvious than in the closing credits when a skyline shot of New York is shown with the WTC towers digitally placed back into the shot to remind us that terrorism is not dead and neither is the fight against it.
DVD EXTRAS
This DVD is somewhat disappointing when it comes to extras. There are only two and these are an introduction by director Steven Spielberg and then a min-documentary called, 'Munich, the Team, the Mission'.
PERFORMANCES
Eric Bana - I was pleasantly surprised with Bana's performance as, with the sole exception of Black Hawk Down, I have generally not been a fan of his work. He plays the character of Avner very well, almost as if his uncomfortableness in playing the lead carries over to the characters unease in being in charge. Daniel Craig - The new James Bond was very impressive in Layer Cake but was underused in this film I felt. He played his character quite well but his South African accent was a but poor. Ciarán Hinds - I wasn't aware of this actor this time last year but he has been in several things that I have liked recently and he is extremely believable as Carl, the clean-up man. He is somewhat detached from the team and he does this very well.
Director: Steven Spielberg Screenplay: Tony Kusner/Eric Roth
Cast: Eric Bana - Avner Daniel Craig - Steve Ciarán Hinds - Carl Mathieu Kassovitz - Robert Hanns Zischler - Hans Geoffrey Rush - Ephraim Michael Lonsdale - Papa Mathieu Amalric - Louis
Certificate: 15 Running Time: 157 Minutes
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Production Year: 2004 - Drama - Director: Nick Cassavetes - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over, 12 years and over - Starring: Rachel McAdams, Ryan Gosling, Gena Rowlands
Production Year: 1999 - Drama, Thriller - Director: M. Night Shyamalan - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Olivia Williams, Glenn Fitzgerald, Mischa Barton, Bruce Willis, Haley Joel Osment, Toni Collette
I absolutely agree with you that the film is too long. I didn't eat before I went and by the end of the two and a half hours everyone in the cinema must have heard my stomach roaring.
BabelBrilliantly conceived, superbly directed, and beautifully acted,Babelis inarguably ... more
one of the best films of 2006. Director Alejandro González Iñárritu and his co-writer, Guillermo Arriaga (the two also collaborated onAmores Perrosand21 Grams) weav...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Munichis a film with no easy answers, and plenty of uncomfortable moments. It also finds ... more
Steven Spielberg on masterly form behind the camera, telling a relentlessly serious and unsettling story with the gravitas it absolutely requires.Set immediately a...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Advantages: Bana, Lonsdale, Hinds, Rush; moral ambivalence, suspenseful action, authentic re-creation of Seventies. Disadvantages: Unnecessarlly graphically violent a la 'Saving Pvt Ryan', strange later scene conflating sex and violence.
zerbine28 27.01.2006 (27.01.2006)
·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Munich (DVD)
Advantages: Incredibly harrowing; raw and authentic; superb score; politically relevant; takes no sides Disadvantages: Spielburg expects audience to know what the film means; weak in parts; odd end
harlequin21 11.03.2006 ·
Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of Munich (DVD)