The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.
Advantages:
Denzel Washington is his usual brilliant self . Thought provoking, and exciting, movie, about a highly contentious and controversial topic .
Disadvantages:
Not a lot
Recommendable
Yes:
Detailed rating:
Did you enjoy it?
Story
Characters / Performances
Special Effects
How does it compare to similar films?
SoundtrackGood
How does it compare to others by the same director?Satisfactory
Diagnosed with an aggressive cancer of the right lung on my 58th birthday (14th July) So not really ...
Diagnosed with an aggressive cancer of the right lung on my 58th birthday (14th July) So not really in the humour for writing much at the moment, although I *WILL* be back before too long...Ken
Member since:06.12.2000
Reviews:678
Members who trust:869
~ ~ Imagine yourself in the situation. Your young child is diagnosed with a fatal heart condition. (or any other type of fatal condition you care to think of) You’re only working part-time because of the economic climate, your car has just been repossessed, and it’s going to be a close call whether or not you can meet the next month’s rent/mortgage. You then discover that your company has downgraded your medical insurance, (without your knowledge) and that the insurance will only pay the first $20K of the required $250K for the life saving operation (heart transplant) that your child needs in order to survive. That’s what I call a fairly desperate situation, but it’s a unpalatable reality to many lowly paid workers in the United States, where the level of medical care you receive is dictated not by your need, but by the size of your bank balance, or the level of private medical insurance that you hold. It’s this theme that forms the storyline in the movie “John Q”, starring the highly talented American actor Denzel Washington, and directed by actor turned director Nick Cassavetes.
~ ~ John Quincy Archibald (John Q) is everyman’s idea of the average American. A blue-collar worker in a local metal foundry, he is happily married to his wife Denise, (well played by Kimberley Elise) and they have a cracker of a ten-year-old son called Mikey. (Daniel E. Smith) Money’s too tight to mention, due to the downturn in the US economy, but the family are struggling along as best they can, and are a strong, loving family unit. Then young Mikey collapses while playing a game of Little League baseball, and John Q rushes him to the Emergency Room of his local hospital. Mikey’s heart is found to diseased and three times the normal size, and could give up entirely at any time, the only favourable prognosis being a heart transplant. No problem there, as the hospital has one of the country’s foremost transplant surgeons, Dr. Raymond Turner, (John Woods) on its books. No problem, that is, until it transpires that John Q’s medical insurance is inadequate to cover the lifesaving (but EXPENSIVE!) operation. The hospital’s resident hard-hearted blond bitch, (aka administrator) Rebecca Payne, (Anne Heche) refuses to place young Mikey on the list for a urgent heart transplant unless his distraught parents can somehow come up with
the required down payment ($75K) for the $250K operation in cash.
~ ~ John Q resorts to every measure known to man in order to raise the necessary money, appealing to his medical insurance company, his employers, his friends, the media, state aid, his Church, (he’s a committed Christian) and finally selling of all of his personal possessions for a fraction of their true value in a vain attempt to raise the required capital. Eventually, push comes to shove, and he’s informed by his now almost demented wife that young Mikey is about to be discharged from the hospital, and quite literally sent home to die. This is the final indignity for John Q, and he decides to take matters into his own hands, taking over the emergency room of the hospital at gunpoint in a final, desperate attempt to somehow break down the layers of unfeeling indifference that has doomed his beloved son to an untimely death.
~ ~ The ER is very quickly surrounded by the forces of law and order, led by veteran hostage negotiator Lt. Frank Grimes, (Robert Duvall) who is somewhat hindered in his attempts to pacify and resolve the situation by the clumsy intervention of a politically ambitious Chief of Police, Chief Monroe. (Ray Liotta) He is hell-bent on resolving the situation quickly, (by the use of deadly force) and positions a sniper to take out John Q. Meanwhile, the previously unenthusiastic and unsympathetic media has descended on the scene like a flock of vultures, (bad news is GOOD news!) and the crowd outside the hospital begins to swell as the breaking news is broadcast nationwide on television. Inside the ER, a dialogue is beginning to develop between John Q and the hospital staff, and with the other hospital patients who have unwittingly got caught up in the unfolding drama. That’s the plot in a nutshell, hopefully without giving away too much of the story as to spoil your viewing enjoyment. If you want to guess the eventual outcome, and how the drama unfolds, then I suggest you either buy or rent the DVD for yourself.
~ ~ I thoroughly enjoyed this excellent, and very thought provoking, movie. However, I have to admit upfront that I would quite literally watch a DVD of Denzel Washington watching paint dry, so highly do I rate him as an actor. His performance in this film is far removed from his Oscar winning performance as Detective Alonzo Harris in the movie “Training Days”, but in this author’s opinion, equally as compelling, although it is hardly likely to gain him any further kudos, praise or Oscars from the Academy. Robert Duvall plays the part of the old, grizzled hostage negotiator Lt. Frank Grimes superbly. Duvall is an actor (now in his early seventies) who in my opinion has never truly garnished the honours he so richly deserves for his many and varied roles over a long and distinguished acting career. A western mini-series (made for TV) called “Lonesome Dove” from the late 1980’s is still one of my favourite ‘cowboy and injun’ flicks of all time. And John Wood’s performance as the somewhat cynical and cash-motivated heart surgeon, Dr. Raymond Turner, is brilliant, with some of the dialogue between himself and John Q in the hostage situation being very insightful as to the current state of play in the medical world in America. (It’s a VERY different role from the vampire hunter he played recently in John Carpenter’s “Vampires”, where he was hell bent on driving stakes through hearts, instead of healing them!) Granted, some of the characters are somewhat clichéd. Ray Liotta is wasted as the politically driven Chief of Police Monroe, and gives a very wooden performance. Personally, I kept seeing him with the top of his skull removed (from the Hannibal Lector movie, Hannibal) throughout the movie. But overall the cast and crew have put together an accomplished and very different film.
~ ~ I’ve read a few very uncomplimentary reviews of this film both in the print media and on the Web. The main criticism seems to be that the idea of a father taking the law into his own hands in this fashion is ludicrous, and lends credence to the idea that justice can be obtained from the barrel of a gun. Another complaint seems to be that it has approached a very contentious political issue (health insurance) in a over dramatic manner, without ever seriously addressing the very real problems that exist in this area. I think that those critics have totally missed the point! I believe that the director didn’t particularly set out to provide any pat answers to a problem that is endemic throughout western society. (not just the USA) Even here in Ireland we have two levels of health care. If you are at the top of the pecking order, and can provide the necessary insurance cover, then there is no such thing as a waiting list, and every facility and medical expertise will be yours for the asking. If, on the other hand, you are a ‘medical card’ (welfare) recipient, then you will probably end up dead or crippled before you move to the top of the ever-expanding waiting lists that now exist in our vastly overburdened health service. I think that the director of “John Q”, Nick Cassavetes, along with input from the main actor himself, Denzel Washington, simply intended to place the question at the forefront of people’s minds, while at the same time making an excellent and entertaining motion picture. I don’t think they ever intended to provide an answer to the problem, but merely to pose the question. I personally don’t see anything fundamentally wrong with the precept of investing your hard earned cash to provide excellent health cover for yourself and your family. On the other hand, I HATE the idea that anyone would actually die simply from the lack of the necessary readies to save their lives. It’s a thorny question, right enough. People nowadays seem to be of the mindset that they should NEVER die, and if they do, then the surviving relatives immediately seem to look around for someone to blame. (or sue!) The public liability cover in one of our main Maternity Hospitals here in Dublin (the Rotunda) has jumped from only 2% of their gross budget in 1995, to over 20% of their budget today. So less money is actually used where it is needed the most, in actual health care.
~ ~ Hopefully I am managing to get across what I thought was the main strong point of this film. It’s ability to make people think more deeply about the issues it poses. In fact, the director poses some of those questions himself during the dialogue between John Q and his hostages. At one point, one of them states, “So I have good health insurance. What you gonna do? Shoot me for it?” And Dr. Raymond Turner (John Woods) makes an impassioned speech about how his hands are tied by the ‘system’, and how often he cannot do what his conscience dictates he should. The movie is also a love story extraordinaire. The love between John Q and his wife and child, and how a loving and caring father will literally go to any lengths to protect his child and family. And the love that John Q has for his God, who he trusts throughout the film, even when his faith is sorely tested. It would take a very hard heart indeed (far harder than mine) not to be moved to tears by this movie, and it comes with the very highest recommendation from the ‘mad cabbie’.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
DVD Extras
1.A plethora of deleted and unused scenes, including an alternate ending. (I preferred the original) These can be viewed either with or without the director’s commentary. Interesting viewing. 2.Audio commentaries on the movie from the screenwriter James Kearns, the director Nick Cassavetes, producer Mark Burg, and the director of photography Rogier Stoffers. 3.Theatrical trailers. 4.A documentary called “Fighting for Care” which addresses in more depth the crisis that currently exists because of the lack of suitable organs for transplant, and the many lives that have been affected as a consequence. 5.A short “behind the scenes” feature on the making of the movie.
The picture quality is superb throughout, and the sound comes in various formats. Dolby Digital 5.1, Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround Sound and DTS 5.1. (Dolby is a trademark of Dolby Laboratories)
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Some other Denzel Washington movies I have enjoyed
Training Day - 2001 The Hurricane – 1999 The Siege – 1998 Fallen – 1998 The Pelican Brief – 1993 Malcolm X – 1992
~~~~~~~~~~~~
John Q has only recently been released for rental here in Ireland. John Q on DVD doesn’t yet appear to be for sale at the Amazon UK website, but is listed at the American site for $22.99.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Copyright KenJ December 2002
~~~~~~~~~~~~
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Drama - Director: Kevin Smith - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring: Ben Affleck, Liv Tyler, George Carlin, Jennifer Lopez, Jason Biggs, Matt Damon
Production Year: 2004 - Drama - Director: Nick Cassavetes - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over, 12 years and over - Starring: Rachel McAdams, Ryan Gosling, Gena Rowlands
Production Year: 2002 - Drama - Director: Michael Caton-Jones - Original Language: English - Classification: 18 years and over - Starring: Robert De Niro, Frances McDormand, James Franco, Eliza Dushku, William Forsythe, George Dzundza, Patti Lupone
without a shadow of a doubt one of the best films of all time.... in my opinion anyway. its just amazes me that no matter what the role, Washington pulls it off time and time again; absolute genius. Alex
salem_witch 24.10.2004 13:20
I saw this in the cinema by pure chance and I loved it. I now have it on dvd as well.
glitterprincess 07.01.2003 16:29
I never watched this film, it just didn't appeal to me. I'm not sure why, perhaps I should give it a go. Jami xx
A nine-year-old boy is in desperate need of a life-saving transplant. When his father ... more
John Q. Archibald (Denzel Washington) discovers that his medical insurance won’t cover the costs of the surgery and alternative government aid is unavailable ...
Postage & Packaging: £0.00 Availability: 3-5 working days
John Q. (Academy Award-winner Denzel Washington) is an ordinary man who works at a factory ... more
and takes care of his family. His wife Denise and young son Michael are his world. But when Michael falls seriously ill and needs an emergency heart transplant t...