JOAN OF ARC - RATED 12
This is one of the best versions of the legendary Joan of Arc I've seen. The acting is excellent, no cardboard characters. Many well known stars, excellent story line, plus some backing vocals by Charlotte Church, make this a must see movie.
DIRECTOR, CAST, WRITERS:
Directed ... Read review
Starring Milla Jovovich (The Fifth Element, He Got Game), Oscar winner Dustin Hoffman, ... more
Oscar winner Faye Dunaway and Oscar nominee John Malkovich, internationally acclaimed director Luc Besson (The Fifth Element, Leon, The Big Blue) brings you Joan Of Arc - The Messenger - the epic story of a woman who followed her own path and changed the course of history.In 1429 a teenage girl from a remote French village stood before her King with a message she claimed came from God; that she would defeat the world's greatest army and liberate her country from its political and religious turmoil. As this small voice in the heart of a simple girl grew stronger, rulers were drawn to listen, armies empowered to fight and her countrymen inspired to believe.Following her mission to reclaim God's diminished kingdom - through her amazing victories until her violent and untimely death - the life of Joan of Arc is explored in this startling epic.
Production Year: 1998 - Drama - Director: Giles Foster - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring: Emily Mortimer, Joanna Lumley, Peter O'Toole
Production Year: 2004 - Drama - Director: Nick Cassavetes - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over, 12 years and over - Starring: Rachel McAdams, Ryan Gosling, Gena Rowlands
Advantages: Truer To The Historical Legend, Leelee Sobieski Stars, Great Performances, Charlotte Church Vocals, Inexpensive, Captivating Disadvantages: You Might Well Have A Tear In Your Eye By The End, Two Sided Disc, Long Film.
JOAN OF ARC - RATED 12
This is one of the best versions of the legendary Joan of Arc I've seen. The acting is excellent, no cardboard characters. Many well known stars, excellent story line, plus some backing vocals by Charlotte Church, make this a must see movie.
DIRECTOR, CAST, WRITERS:
Directed by Christian Duguay.
Starring: Leelee Sobieski, Chad Willett, Jacqueline Bisset, Powers Boothe, Olympia Dukakis, ... ...spied the Leelee Sobieski as Joan version. Just the one copy there on video, in my local video shop. I thought it wouldn't amount to much, as it said it was a film originally made for a mini TV series, plus it was THE one copy of it there. How wrong I was..................... Despite this, I decided to give it a try.
To watch this one, you need to allow yourself at least three hours where you won't be interrupted. It's long but the ... more
JOAN OF ARC - RATED 12 This is one of the best versions of the legendary Joan of Arc I've seen. The acting is excellent, no cardboard characters. Many well known stars, excellent story line, plus some backing vocals by Charlotte Church, make this a must see movie.
DIRECTOR, CAST, WRITERS: Directed by Christian Duguay. Starring: Leelee Sobieski, Chad Willett, Jacqueline Bisset, Powers Boothe, Olympia Dukakis, Neil Patrick Harris, Robert Loggia, Maximilian Schell, Peter Strauss, Jonathan Hyde, Maury Chaykin. Guest appearances by Shirley MacLaine also starring Peter O'Toole as Bishop Cauchon. Written by: Michael Alexander Miller, Ronald Parker
DVD FEATURES: · Picture Format: PAL 4:3 Academy · Colour Mode: Colour · Region Code: 2 · Feature Duration: 180 minutes approximately · Audio Content: Dolby Digital Stereo · · Special Features: Trailer · Interactive Menus · Scene Selections · Double Sided For Part 1 + Part 2 ·
MY OPINION: I remember watching a really old black & white version when I was a boy. That was very moving to me then, so I was really looking forward to the version starring Milla Jovovich by Luc Besson. More about that one later!
Before that version was due on video, (about a month before) I spied the Leelee Sobieski as Joan version. Just the one copy there on video, in my local video shop. I thought it wouldn't amount to much, as it said it was a film originally made for a mini TV series, plus it was THE one copy of it there. How wrong I was..................... Despite this, I decided to give it a try.
To watch this one, you need to allow yourself at least three hours where you won't be interrupted. It's long but the time goes by very quickly, because the story never becomes boring, it's very captivating actually.
The film is presented in full screen on a two sided DVD, which you have to obviously turn over, about half way through. This gives you time for a cuppa or whatever :-) It didn't distract me, as the break is at a moment which doesn't affect the flow too much.
Most people reading this, will already know the story of Joan Of Arc (Leelee Sobieski). The young peasant girl who hears the voices of saints. Which in turn takes her on a journey to her fateful burning at the stake. I'm not saying that the story here is true to the history books exactly, but it looks to me, after reading from other sources, to be nearer the truth as I see it. The story line is very well written, dramatically filmed with some good battle scenes.
This one starts with an insight into her childhood. Being born in the village of Domremy, the year 1412, she isn't what her father (Powers Boothe) wanted. He is disappointed she wasn't a boy. Her mother (Jacqueline Bisset), does her best to give Joan the affection she needs.
Witnessing the raids by fellow countrymen, on the village, seeing her friends killed, the poverty plus stories of France being pulled apart by the English in league with the "Burgundians". Tear at her feelings. She is deep into her religious beliefs, attending the church to pray.
Whilst all this is happening, she hears the voices along with visions, from saints. She feels this is her calling to help bring together her fellow countrymen. She attempts to meet with the King (Neil Patrick Harris). Her only way to do this was by portraying her as the prophet Merlin's saviour of France. Although against her wishes, this was achieved. Things begin to move quickly, she is drawn along by people, events. Plus a letter to her king, stating she was indeed the one prophesied to be the "miracle" which would unite France.
She falls foul to the Bishop Cauchon (Peter O'Toole), who does his best to discredit her. He fails to do this at first, then seemingly here, to regret "opposing" her later in her trial.
She wins over the King, eventually leading her to "be with" the French army. Gradually she becomes trusted by them, as they believe in her calling. She becomes their feared "flag bearer". Leading them into battle, resulting in victories across France. She is the legend they all need, to drive them forward to victory.
As her own sanity comes into question, her believing she really is the chosen one, her downfall begins......................The king betrays her to the English for his own ends, for a vast amount of money. She surrenders herself, knowing she has been betrayed, but also knowing it is "meant to be", for the good of France.
She is accused of heresy by the church. Taken to be tried by the English. Her visions, voices are never truly admitted by her, but she receives no support from anyone. Weary from her trials, she signs a retraction, which to her judges, accusers, enemies use to find her guilty. Her end in 1431 by burning at the stake, is emotionally displayed here, by excellent filming, deep story line with some very good acting.
I haven't given away too much of the actual story, because there are some parts (whether true or not), which add to the "need" to watch factor. All I can say is, that in my view, it is an exceptionally good made for TV movie, which is "gripping", "involving".
In comparison to the other Joan Of Arc made for cinema release, "The Messenger" by Luc Besson, starring Milla Jovovich: Leelee Sobieski plays the part of Joan so much better, an outstanding performance. The story has more substance, belief, historical fact. Choosing between the two as to which one is best was easy. The only thing that makes the Messenger "okay" are the battle scenes. If the battle scenes from the Messenger were put with this "made for TV movie" Or if some of the actors, all of the script from the TV version were put into the Messenger. It would have been a BIG box office hit.
I recommend that you watch The Messenger by video or DVD rental, before buying it, as it could cost you from £9.99p upward. But as this reviewed DVD can be bought for as little as £4.33p, it's well worth buying. (The video version is shorter than the DVD version by about 20 minutes). DVD version is three hours long approximately.
Thanks for reading this opinion, I hope you find it helpful :-)
If you want to see for yourself how the historical facts are perceived to be, by another source, try this link: http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08409c.htm
...Luc Besson's epic film Joan of Arc - The Messenger has most certainly opted for this type of story telling. The plot of the film is simple - and yet confusing. The film essentially portrays the life story of Joan of Arc, from early childhood right through to her untimely demise at the age of nineteen. Raised in a French peasant village, we see right from the start of the film that Joan experiences holy images, and voices which (although we never ... ...the hands of the English, Joan grows into a fiery, passionate young woman. Joan is convinced by the voices in her head that she will lead the French to victory, and ensure that the Dauphin is crowned King of France. Whilst the film covers a significant period of time -nineteen years - there are large, unexplained gaps - the film jumps from Joan as a child to her arrival at the Dauphin's chateau at the age of nineteen. Milla Jovovich plays Joan with ...
LostWitness 08.03.2001
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful Review of Joan Of Arc (DVD)
Advantages: Jovovich's eyes Disadvantages: Over the top
...work, so any film about Joan of Arc is going to be pretty memorable.
I'll come back a little later to the film itself, promise, but let's dwell just a little on the legend of the character first and indulge ourselves...
Joan of Arc was a passionate, legendary hero of the French people in the 15th Century, when the country was seen as fair game for looting, pillage, rape and occupation by her near neighbour England. She had a meteoric, inspiring ... ...top and truly manic, with Joan being depicted as veering between madness, hallucination, self doubt, guilt and obsession. It's very powerful and bizarre and awesome, yes all that, but I'm not sure it's actually that good.
I'd resisted its individual charms for an awful long while, repelled by the over earnest seriousness of it all, but finally relented the other night and sat through the entire two and a half hours of The Messenger. Can't say I ...
dave27 29.03.2002
· Read full review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful Review of Joan Of Arc (DVD)
Did you enjoy it?
Story
Characters / Performances
Special Effects
How does it compare to ...
Similar reviews »
Reviews which might be of interest for "Joan Of Arc (DVD)"
Advantages: Hypnotic film with an understated yet compelling performance by Florence Carrez. Disadvantages: -
scene pregnant with unspoken horror.
Just as Jacques Rivette's 'Joan the Maid' did, Robert Bresson's 'Procès de Jeanne d'Arc' served to reinforce this writer's own admiring fascination with the historical figure. Simply put, a work of genius.
~~~~~~~~~
NOTES:
A word about the preceding Carl Dreyer silent classic, 'The Passion of Joan of Arc' (1928), to which the Bresson film cannot seem to escape comparison: Dreyer's Joan is emotionally naked, overwrought, and unbearable to the point of torture. Personally (and I contradict hallowed dogma here), I prefer Mr Bresson's - and Mr Rivette's, for that matter - interpretation of Joan of Arc.
I originally caught this film on the excellent Turner Movie Classics channel on US cable TV.
~~~~~~~~~~
DVD NOTES: (added 3/27/06)
I've finally viewed the M2K DVD, by the UK ...
Advantages: excellent story, good action, battle Disadvantages: blood
It has a breathtaking story about Joan of Arc - a teenage girl from French village of 1429 who stood before the King with a message from God. She claimed that she would be able to defeat the worlds greatest army and save her country. The film is full of action, battles, blood, emotions, and violence. But it shows the cruelty of 15th century and bravery of unusual village girl who leads the French army to the battle, believe that she may change something but eventually she is betrayed by her own king.
The DVD lasts approx.151mins and starring excellent Mila Janovich, Dustin Hoffman, Faye Dunaway and John Malkovich. It was directed by Luc Besson .
The DVD include 24 minute featurette. It has English and German languages and English, Polish, Czech, Hungarian, Icelandic, Hindi, Hebrew, Dutch, Bulgarian, German, Turkish, Danish, Swedish ...
Advantages: great battle scenes Disadvantages: Milla is in every single scene and she's simply not very good...no...DAMN ANNOYING
no character development to be had in someone like Charles VII and I'll call you a fool. Luc Besson is obviously that fool, the only character being allowed to develop being Milla's, perhaps in a vain attempt to raise the perception of her own performance but dumbing down on those around her? It doesn't work.
To be able to appreciate this movie at all you would have to be first convinced that the leaders of France and its armies would have been ready to follow the character of Joan of Arc. Milla Jovovich plays a weak, brittle, abrasive and generally odious character, illiterate and generally weak on all fronts. You decide.
Get past this though, maybe you are a big fan of Milla's work, and you have a movie which has some great battle scenes(ignoring the broken wailing coming from the lead) and some beautifully shot scenes. When they ...
A star-studded epic drama based on the tragic true story of Joan Of Arc - the fifteenth-century French peasant girl who's life was changed dramatically when she started hearing the voices of Saints Catherine, Michael and Margaret. Inspired by these voices Joan led her troops to unite against their English Invaders. She was betrayed and stood trial for heresy. At the age of nineteen she was burned at the stake.
Release details
DVD Region
DVD
Studio(s)
ODYSSEY VIDEO; PRISM LEISURE
Release date
24/02/2003
No of Discs
1
Catalogue No
ODX 20006
Barcode
5018011200062
Languages
Main Language
English
Technical information
Special Features
Interactive Menus, Scene Selection, Trailers
Aspect Ratio
4:3
Sound
Dolby Digital Stereo
Dubbing Sound
Dolby Digital Stereo English
DVD Description
A star-studded epic drama based on the tragic true story of Joan Of Arc - the fifteenth-century French peasant girl who's life was changed dramatically when she started hearing the voices of Saints Catherine, Michael and Margaret. Inspired by these voices Joan led her troops to unite against their English Invaders. She was betrayed and stood trial for heresy. At the age of nineteen she was burned at the stake.
Compare Joan Of Arc (DVD) to other similar Drama »