Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
Postage & Packaging: £0.​00
SHOPPING > DVDs > Thriller & Mystery > In The Cut (DVD) > Reviews

In The Cut (DVD)

from (5 offers) · Product Information

In The Cut (DVD)

Quote-start

The First Cut Is The Deepest

Quote-end

3 Jan 27th, 2008 

33 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Shocking, Great Performances, Great Visuals

Disadvantages:
Bad Story Telling, Slow, A Lot Of Missteps

Recommendable No:

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

JayHall1991

JayHall1991

About me:

Member since:28.04.2004

Reviews:204

Members who trust:41

Frannie is a professor of English, trying to teach bright but under achieving urban kids whilst fighting with her own sexual impulses and slight paranoia. When at a bar, Frannie sees a sex act being performed in the toilet, she cannot see the faces of the people, but can see a unique tattoo on the male's wrist. Disturbed but excited by this event she quickly leaves, but is followed by a policeman who informs her that the girl is now dead, decapitated and left in a dump. The detective is Malloy a hard drinking, fast talking New York police cop, who is instantly attracted to Frannie. As they get involved in a steamy and dangerous affair, which fuels both of their flaws, the murder grows more prolific, leaving a trial of body's that grow closer and closer to the delusional English professor. As their relationship grows ever more violent and as Frannie begins to lose grip of what is real and what is fiction she finds herself in more danger than she could ever of imagined.......

In The Cut is a maddening, beautiful, lyrical mess of a movie; lacking sense or a good story but brimming with sensual style, it flits from brilliant to dreadful in the space of a few frames and is steeped in contradiction -its grubby yet gorgeous, disturbing yet enticing, involving yet detached. A dark thriller that uses New York City like a ferocious character; jungle like, wild and disturbing, a scary urban forest of deceit and fear to create tension. Never sticking with a linear narrative, the film coherency is sacrificed and the flimsy story is never back up with any substance, but it contains imagery that will stay with you long after the credits role and its use of visuals to add horror to the proceedings are genuinely unsettling. Relying on words rather than actions to pile on the anxiety (Frannie's obsessive quote making becomes incredibly emotive), the film lingers to it claustrophobic and dark final chapter. It's never as absorbing as it wants to be, infact it does a good job of keeping the audience at arm's length, and there are huge flaws in both concept and execution.... but it's hard not to be swept away by the gory romanticism of it all, it may not be enjoyable, but it certainly makes an impression.

From the opening scene the 'look' of In the Cut is established; twirling, pink leaves fall over an urban jungle as the screen scratches and the camera jitters, the haunting slowed-down que sera sera humming in the background. It's genuinely startling, instantly unsettling and from there on in imagery and visuals are used to outstanding effect throughout the film. The bright crimson blood is in stark contrast with the gloomy settings; the motif of old-black-and-white skaters, gracefully spinning through the air evokes old French sensibilities and the sprawling, eclectic nature of Frannie's apartment is a wonderful reflection of her mental state. The flickering scenes, jumping and scratching, burning up reels and off skewed camera work give the film a disturbing off kilter quality. The contrast of beautiful and horrifying make both more potent and chilling and the lingering, drawn out, summer heat slow speed with which the visuals bleed into each other makes for a unique and claustrophobic experience. But the most startling use of visuals comes with Jane Campion's recreation of New York City; vibrant, horrifying, exciting, restricting and sprawling, caught between a nightmare and a dream, never really convincing as a city, more a living, breathing terrifying person; powerful, strong and horrifying.

It's a real shame that the filmmaker's ambitious and effective use of visuals isn't matched with their story telling abilities; they leave things too ambiguous, character's motives make no sense, the final conclusion (the big 'reveal') is obvious but disconnected with the story and the dialogue is often stilted. The screenplay doesn't know what it wants to be; a claustrophobic thriller, a study of a fragile mind, a sexual exploration or a slasher and so it is never completely successful at any one thing. The story is allowed to meander, never achieving the kind of punch that it needs and there are too many plot elements that make no sense. The story isn't as complex as it thinks it is and so often comes off as pretentious and the rather puzzling relationship between Frannie and Detective Malloy is erotically charged but never very convincing. The story never seems to go anywhere, a good premise looking for a better outlet and its attempts to wrap things up with a rather convoluted conclusion are annoying. The screenplay does however do a good job of probing into Frannie psyche, examining the effect of loss on her and her intimacy issues throw up some interesting questions about dependency and desire and has more than a few literary flourishes.

Some of the dialogue feels stunted like the characters are saying things that they don't really mean and some of it stalls the already slightly lagging pace. A lot of the more interesting ideas are not fully explored, being swapped for unnecessary plot twists and the tension of the piece occasionally dips, due to an overlong running time. It has the distinct feeling of someone who has lots to say, but lacks the intelligence or confidence to say it. However, this subsides after a shocking mid-way twist in the tail which throws the characters into hysteria and speeds the pace up immeasurably. The relationship between Malloy and Frannie is rife with tension and the dynamic is the core of the film, offering a meaty and interesting look into a deeply dysfunctional partnership. The sexual explicitness of the film (there are many full frontal scenes, simulated oral sex, anal sex, masturbation, sexual violence and one shot of an erect penis which caused much uproar upon the film's release) is shocking and its detached quality makes it chillingly unemotional, adding to the overall feeling on unease that runs through.

Meg Ryan gives a career best performance; ferociously embodying the paranoia and delusion of her character, injecting Frannie with a maddened energy, giving a performance rubbed raw by despair and smashed by grief. Ably handling the movies emotional scenes with a fierce sadness and is fearless in the films sex scenes, which she instils with a passion and neediness that is extremely engaging. She perfectly puts across the alienation and fear, looking like a rabbit caught in the headlights, scared but incredibly enticed by the dark world in-front of her. A surprising mix of naivety and intelligence she sears through the screen growing more fragile and distraught as her world begins to unravel around her. Her emotions burst into the air like a tornado, a force to be fought with; messy, strong and fascinating - she knows what she's doing, but it never feels calculated. After the initial shock of seeing American's sweetheart naked, you see a dark, seductive, brave study of a woman whose knowledge of reality and fiction is severely and dangerously blurred. Mark Ruffalo is an equally engaging and horrifying figure as Malloy.

Jane Campion's direction swings from the sublime to the ridiculous; the detail with which she builds character development and the beauty which she instils into the thing is astounding, her ambitious use of time structure is unsuccessful but startling and she gives the scenes an urgency that grabs you by the collar and hurtles you through the air. Her vision of the murder mystery element is more exciting than her script allows and her ideas about what make thrillers thrilling are genuinely inventive. Many of the scenes are teeth grindingly tense (one involving a dismembered head, a blood soaked bathroom and a hysterical woman comes to mind) and her mix of the intimate and the boundary laden makes for a disturbing watch. But she lets the story unravel without her control; she doesn't rein the material in, pays too much attention to the silliness of the plot and makes some of it seem damn right banal. She can't seem to get into a groove, she can never get a handle of what she wants the pace to be like and so the film keeps stopping and starting. The ending is thought provoking, but desperately rushed and un-engaging and she fails to make it a thrill, she zaps the fun from a lot of the scenes and messes up some of the interaction between Malloy and Fannie.

Overall In The Cut is a beautiful, impulsive, addictive, brilliant heap of junk; which is a shame as it is genuinely unique, with great performances and an eye popping visual style. The screenplay lets it down though, it never grabs the audience like it should and never really goes anywhere until the final, rather rushed last scenes. Like a ghost; haunting, beautiful but ultimately transparent - should be watched for people interested in ambitious art rather than great storytelling. 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Murder In Mind (Box Set) (DVD)

Murder In Mind (Box Set) (DVD)

Thriller - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Timothy West, Neil Morrissey, Tara Fitzgerald, Annette Crosbie, Pauline Quirke, Rob Brydon, Denise Van Outen, John Thomson, Kevin Whately, David Suchet

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 2.41

Sherlock Holmes - The Definitive Collection (Box Set) (DVD)

Sherlock Holmes - The Definitive Collection (Box Set) (DVD)

Mystery - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring: Basil Rathbone, Nigel Bruce

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 15.12

Spooks - Series 1 - Complete (Box Set) (DVD)

Spooks - Series 1 - Complete (Box Set) (DVD)

Production Year: 2002 - Thriller - Director: Bharat Nalluri, Rob Bailey, Andy Wilson - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Matthew MacFadyen, Keeley Hawes, David Oyelowo, Peter Firth, Jenny Agutter, Lisa Faulkner

User reviews (7)

Buy now for only £ 9.47

Columbo - Series 3 - Complete (Box Set) (DVD)
The Transporter (DVD)

The Transporter (DVD)

(+) Brilliant fight sequences
(-) A good but occasionally weak storyline which can rely on the action a bit too much

User reviews (5)

Buy now for only £ 1.38

The Miss Marple Collection - Starring Joan Hickson (Box Set) (DVD)

The Miss Marple Collection - Starring Joan Hickson (Box Set) (DVD)

Mystery - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring: Joan Hickson

User reviews (2)

Buy now for only £ 38.87

Comments about this review »

patriciat 01.02.2008 08:49

Very well written and I'm almost tempted to want to watch this pile of junk as you describe it. Pat.t x

ilusvm 30.01.2008 20:25

nice review. Not a film that i enjoyed. Em x

martint1983 28.01.2008 17:20

Fantastic review

Compare prices for In The Cut (DVD) »

1 to 5 out of 5 offers for In The Cut (DVD) Show all offers   sorted by: Price 
In The Cut [DVD] [2003]

In The Cut [DVD] [2003]

Based on Susanna Moore's novel,In the Cutcentres on Frannie (Meg Ryan), an emotionally ... more

stifled English teacher who gets steamy with
sultry Malloy (Mark Ruffalo), a cop who's
investigating a series of brutal murders--but
Frannie soon suspects that Mallo...

amazon marketplace dvd

Postage & Packaging£1.21
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace d...
In The Cut

In The Cut

Meg Ryan stars in this dark psychological thriller, where desire and death mix in the ... more

shadows of New York. Frannie (Meg Ryan) is a
lonely but determined woman living alone in
Manhattan, who becomes involved in an
investigation, following he gruesome sl...

LOVEFiLM.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityIn Stock
 Visit Shop  >
LOVEFiLM.com
In The Cut-DVD

In The Cut-DVD

thehut.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 3 days...
 Visit Shop  >
thehut.com
In The Cut [DVD] [2003]

In The Cut [DVD] [2003]

Based on Susanna Moore's novel,In the Cutcentres on Frannie (Meg Ryan), an emotionally ... more

stifled English teacher who gets steamy with
sultry Malloy (Mark Ruffalo), a cop who's
investigating a series of brutal murders--but
Frannie soon suspects that Mallo...

amazon dvd

Postage & PackagingFree!
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon dvd


More reviews »

In The Cut (DVD) - review by Borg

Advantages: Meg Ryan, a little bit different.
Disadvantages: Badly done, thin plot, arty mess!

In The Cut (DVD) - review by Borg Borg 17.11.2003 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of In The Cut (DVD)

In The Cut (DVD) - review by kairi

Advantages: None
Disadvantages: Extremely contrived, extremely dull

In The Cut (DVD) - review by kairi kairi 18.05.2005 (18.05.2005) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of In The Cut (DVD)

In The Cut (DVD) - review by gijoe1974

Advantages: stylish, atmospheric
Disadvantages: a lack of warmth character-wise

In The Cut (DVD) - review by gijoe1974 gijoe1974 12.04.2008 (12.04.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of In The Cut (DVD)

In The Cut (DVD) - review by cellarboy

Advantages: Beautifully shot, gentle engaging phycholical thriller
Disadvantages: May not have enough action or to slow for some

In The Cut (DVD) - review by cellarboy cellarboy 12.02.2004 (12.02.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of In The Cut (DVD)

In The Cut (DVD) - review by mrihatepoorservice

Advantages: Meg Ryan in't Nude
Disadvantages: Everything else

In The Cut (DVD) - review by mrihatepoorservice mrihatepoorservice 19.03.2004 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of In The Cut (DVD)



Are you the manufacturer / provider of In The Cut (DVD)? Click here