Compare Prices
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Postage & Packaging: £1.​21
Postage & Packaging: Free!

I, Robot (DVD)

from (7 offers) · Product Information

I, Robot (DVD)

Quote-start

I, Robot You, Will Smith

Quote-end

4 Aug 20th, 2004 

39 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Intelligent story - telling with high production values

Disadvantages:
Really obvious product placement

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

afy9mab

afy9mab

About me:

If you've left me a rating on either my Imaginarium of Dr Parnassus or In the Valley of Elah reviews...

Member since:11.07.2000

Reviews:778

Members who trust:82

Technophobe Detective Del Spooner lives in a near future where robots are as common as kettles. But when Alfred Lanning, the father of robotics apparently commits suicide, Spooner believes he has been murdered and that the murderer may be a robot named Sonny, who has somehow managed to break his programming. Spooner’s biggest problem is how to get anyone else to believe him. Especially as mega-corporation US Robotics is about to release its latest robot; the NS-5, whose introduction will increase the number of robots to one for every five humans.

Director Alex Proyas has never been one to shy away from a challenge. After dealing with a star dying on set in “The Crow” and a film that existed in eternal night in the aptly named “Dark City”, he decided to take a crack at the heretofore unfilmable work of physicist turned futurist Isaac Asimov. Thankfully technology has now caught up with the ideas Asimov had fifty years ago and Proyas has created that rarest of things; the intelligent action movie. Though there may have been a few more day shoots on this project, Proyas has crafted a dark tale that preys on one of modern man’s greatest fears; what happens when technology is so advanced that we can no longer control it? Though the film is based on the writings of the Russian science fiction author, it is not a straight adaptation of a single story. Instead it is an amalgamation of concepts woven into a cohesive narrative. And thanks to a sharp script by Jeff Vintar and “Spider-Man” scribe Akiva Goldsmith, we aren’t spoon-fed ideas; they are presented and the audience is left to figure things out for itself. Proyas has resisted the temptation to spell out the reasons for Spooner’s mistrust of mechanoids from the outset, allowing us to let our assumptions mislead us. The characters are deftly, if sparsely drawn and it is left to the actors to flesh them out. Relationships are also left pleasingly vague, with the onus left on the cast to build them up. The film makes the most of the advances in computer-generated filmmaking though the film’s biggest asset is action hero par excellence Will Smith.

It seems a long time ago, but there was a time when Will Smith’s summer movies were guaranteed blockbusters and this could be the film to put him back on track. He plays Spooner as a strong man troubled by his memories and the feeling of being different to everyone else. He is the archetypal hard-bitten cynical cop, but he makes the standard character his own. The once skinny Fresh Prince has bulked up considerably (as we can all see in the gratuitous nudie shot of him in the shower) and now looks more convincing as a full-on action hero. He carries himself and his weapons like a man who shouldn’t be messed with and looks at home whether he’s delivering lines or punches and kicks. That’s not to say he’s another meat-headed macho man because he can act too. He has developed since “Fresh Prince of Bel-Air” and he can display a wealth of emotions believably. He is also comfortable enough in his action hero persona to allow himself to come off worst in many of the fights, getting badly mashed on more than one occasion.

Bridget Moynahan is the perfect foil to Smith’s action hero posturings as robot psychologist Dr Susan Calvin. She is the ideal ice maiden; glacial and aloof, whilst also being vulnerable because her world is far removed from that of the normal rank and file. Her character doesn’t even know the story of “Hansel and Gretel”. Her relationship with Spooner builds gradually, although Proyas is not crass enough to incorporate a love story for the sake of it. Calvin prefers robots to humans because they are logical and can’t hurt you (or so she thinks) and her actions are always consistent with this. Her chemistry with Smith is good and more importantly, convincing as a clash of ideologies.

Of all the actors, Alan Tudyk has the hardest job. He is the man behind Sonny, the NS-5 robot accused of murder. He gives a really good performance as the robot that is invested with more humanity than the rest of the “real” cast. What makes his performance all the more remarkable is that we don’t see him on screen. He provides the voice and movement for Sonny, but what we see is a an Apple iMac influenced android, who is only capable of basic facial movement and has a metal skeleton, rather than a full body. I feel kind of sorry for Tudyk, not only because he spent months wearing nothing but a blue leotard covered in sensors, but also because people won’t know his face, despite his great performance.

The cast is rounded out by a series of reliable character actors. Chi McBride brings the requisite bluster to Spooner’s superior, Lt Bergin, whilst remaining a likeable character. Bruce Greenwood is suitably slimy as head of US Robotics, Lawrence, a man more concerned with profit margins than human life. James Cromwell plays the unfortunate Dr Lanning with the necessary gravitas and the no-nonsense approach you’d expect from a scientist. “Holes” star Shia LaBoeuf turns up in a pointless role as a young street grifter, who exists solely to be rescued by Spooner. But this is a Hollywood film, so you have to expect the odd Hollywood convention.

Futuristic films can live or die by their special effects and “I, Robot” is no exception. Where so many of the extras are computer-generated androids, it is testament to the technology and its use that they are photo-realistic and it is very difficult to distinguish between what is real and what isn’t really there. Some thought has gone into the design of the robots, with older models looking like extras from “Star Wars”, whilst the new NS-5s look like a natural progression of the design, with a few more bells and whistles. Their semi-transparent carapaces are reminiscent of current design favourite; the Apple iMac. They move in believable and consistent manner and appear to have weight and mass. There are a few moments when what you can see is plainly CGI because it’s ALL CGI (such as during the mid-movie car chase) but that doesn’t stop them being impressive. However, Proyas has allowed himself to be seduced into adding a few unnecessary effects shots just because he can. For example, in the final battle, there are a few impossible spinning camera shots that aren’t do-able without CG that will make you dizzy.

Proyas and production designer Patrick Tatopoulos have been careful to seamlessly meld old and new, so that the future Chicago looks familiar, yet just different enough to be ultramodern. Architectural styles and fashions are layered on top of each other to create a utilitarian world, where if it is still usable, it is still in use. And it’s nice to see a future vision that doesn’t assume that just because technology has advanced, so has human society. It’s more “Minority Report” than “Blade Runner”. There is some blatant product placement, with the main culprits being Audi (though it is a cool-looking car), Converse All Star trainers (circa 2004 for that future retro look) and Panasonic’s latest sleek CD player. But I suppose production costs have to come from somewhere.

I am somewhat bemused by costume designers’ insistence that in the future we will all be clad in black leather. Whatever happened to the conviction that the fabrics of tomorrow would be bacofoil and silver lame? I know it looks cool, but it’s so uncomfortable to wear in a temperate climate, especially with global warming on the rise. Aren’t we more likely to end up wearing linen or cotton (or raincoats and galoshes if the recent rains are anything to go by)? But this is a minor gripe, that doesn’t detract from the film overall.

The format of the film is nothing new – it is a basic detective story that relies on following clues, so the pacing can be a little pedestrian at times. After all you have to solve clue A before you can move onto clue B and so forth and Spooner has to do it whilst facing scepticism from all angles. So far so unoriginal. But Proyas has created an intriguing whodunit, set in a dazzling futuristic world that manages to be an intelligent film, without skimping on the big action sequences we have come to expect from summer movies. So there will be something for everyone, whether you are a fan of action movies, science fiction, detective stories, thrillers or of Will Smith himself. It’s a satisfying movie on many levels and I thoroughly enjoyed it. You can enjoy as a popcorn movie, or as an intelligent sci-fi film if you want to think a little more about the undertones of fascism, slavery and the relationship between man and machines. So take a punt on it and you won’t be disappointed, as long as you aren’t expecting it to be another “Men In Black”.
 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Harry Potter And The Half-Blood Prince (DVD)

Harry Potter And The Half-Blood Prince (DVD)

(+) Amazing special effects. Excellent acting.
(-) Unfaithful to the book in parts.

User reviews (26)

Buy now for only £ 6.99

Get Backers Vol.2 (DVD)

Get Backers Vol.2 (DVD)

Production Year: 2002 - Science Fiction - Director: Kazuhiro Furuhashi, Keitaro Motonaga - Classification: 12 years and over

Rate it now

Buy now for only £ 2.37

Doctor Who - Series 2 - Complete (Box Set) (DVD)

Doctor Who - Series 2 - Complete (Box Set) (DVD)

Production Year: 2006 - Science Fiction - Director: James Hawes - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring: Noel Clarke, Camille Coduri, Penelope Wilton, David Tennant, Billie Piper

User reviews (6)

Buy now for only £ 11.99

Independence Day (DVD)

Independence Day (DVD)

(+) Great acting and effects
(-) Obvious computer generated effects

User reviews (63)

Buy now for only £ 2.41

Stargate Atlantis - Series 3 - Complete (DVD)

Stargate Atlantis - Series 3 - Complete (DVD)

(+) Another brilliant season from Atlantis
(-) it has to end at some point

User reviews (1)

Buy now for only £ 3.99

I Am Legend (DVD)

I Am Legend (DVD)

Production Year: 2007 - Science Fiction - Director: Francis Lawrence - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring: Alice Braga, Charlie Tahan, Dash Mihok, Will Smith, Salli Richardson, Willow Smith

User reviews (82)

Buy now for only £ 0.01

Comments about this review »

Grahamrocks 11.01.2007 23:35

Great review, cant wait to read more of your reviews graham

Maniac1701d 28.03.2005 12:39

Brilliant review!

KarenUK 23.02.2005 01:04

Excellent review! I watched the film tonight & enjoyed it.

Compare prices for I, Robot (DVD) »

1 to 5 out of 7 offers for I, Robot (DVD) Show all offers   sorted by: Price 
I Robot - Single Disc Edition [2004] [DVD]

I Robot - Single Disc Edition [2004] [DVD]

As paranoid cop Del Spooner, Will Smith displays both his trademark quips and some ... more

impressive pectoral muscles inI, Robot. Only
Spooner suspects that the robots that provide the
near future with menial labor are going to turn on
mankind--he's just not ...

amazon marketplace dvd

Postage & Packaging£1.21
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace d...
I Robot (Collector's Two Disc Edition) [DVD] [2004]

I Robot (Collector's Two Disc Edition) [DVD] [2004]

Asparanoid cop Del Spooner, Will Smith displays both his trademark quips and some ... more

impressive pectoral muscles inI, Robot. Only
Spooner suspects that the robots that provide the
near future with menial labor are going to turn on
mankind--he's just not s...

amazon marketplace dvd

Postage & Packaging£1.21
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon marketplace d...
I Robot - Single Disc Edition [2004] [DVD]

I Robot - Single Disc Edition [2004] [DVD]

As paranoid cop Del Spooner, Will Smith displays both his trademark quips and some ... more

impressive pectoral muscles inI, Robot. Only
Spooner suspects that the robots that provide the
near future with menial labor are going to turn on
mankind--he's just not ...

amazon dvd

Postage & PackagingFree!
AvailabilityUsually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
amazon dvd
I,Robot-DVD

I,Robot-DVD

thehut.com

Postage & Packaging£0.00
AvailabilityIn stock - Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
 Visit Shop  >
thehut.com


More reviews »

I, Robot (DVD) - review by LostWitness

Advantages: Exciting, interesting, moving
Disadvantages: Not the intellectual outing that some might prefer

I, Robot (DVD) - review by LostWitness LostWitness 31.08.2004 (31.08.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of I, Robot (DVD)

I, Robot (DVD) - review by Zoe

Advantages: A superior sci-fi blockbuster
Disadvantages: It won't be winning any oscars

I, Robot (DVD) - review by Zoe Zoe 09.08.2004 (09.08.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of I, Robot (DVD)

I, Robot (DVD) - review by Ailran

Advantages: An intelligent action movie
Disadvantages: Bypasses a lot of Asimov's intelligent writings

I, Robot (DVD) - review by Ailran Ailran 16.10.2004 (16.10.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of I, Robot (DVD)

I, Robot (DVD) - review by Crib79

Advantages: Great effects, some decent ideas, Alan Tudyk
Disadvantages: Falls victim to the Hollywood screenwriting process

I, Robot (DVD) - review by Crib79 Crib79 11.08.2004 (11.08.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of I, Robot (DVD)

I, Robot (DVD) - review by Worrals

Advantages: Convincing robots
Disadvantages: Unconvincing plot

I, Robot (DVD) - review by Worrals Worrals 08.09.2004 (08.09.2004) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of I, Robot (DVD)



Are you the manufacturer / provider of I, Robot (DVD)? Click here