No room at the inn
Dec 10th, 2007
Advantages:
Superb acting, deeply moving story
Disadvantages:
It really happened and we all let it
Recommendable:
Yes
Detailed rating:
Did you enjoy it?
Story
Characters / Performances
Special Effects
How does it compare to similar films?
more
 sunmeilan
About me:
I've never been a big message leaver, but I would like to thank everyone that has read and rated my ...
Member since:05.05.2005
Reviews:946
Members who trust:364
Review rated by 56 Ciao members on average: very helpful
Paul Rusesabagina likes his job as hotel manager and is a good husband and father to wife Tatiana and their three children. When a politically active friend of his warns him that the Hutus are ready to rise up against their neighbours, the Tutsis, he dismisses it as war talk. Little does he know that everyone's worst nightmare is about to happen and thousands of Tutsis are to be slain. Paul is forced to shelter his family and neighbours in the hotel where he works, along with tourists and refugees. When the UN forces arrive, Paul thinks they are all safe; little does he know that for anyone who is African, their troubles have only just begun, because the UN cannot or will not help them and they are left to their own devices. Suddenly, Paul is responsible for the lives of the hundreds of people sheltering in the hotel. Will he manage to save their lives from the marauding Hutu militia? And will his family ever be reunited again? Don Cheadle plays Paul Rusesabagina. He was apparently the director's first choice for the role, although funders wanted someone better known to attract more attention and therefore bums on seats. I am so glad that the director held out for what he wanted. Don Cheadle was superb in this role. It can never be easy to play the part of someone who is still alive, for Paul Rusesabagina is no creation and gave advice as to how the role should be performed, but Don Cheadle does
it with aplomb. He does not make Paul out to be a hero; rather he is a man who wants to save his wife and children and just happens to have to shoulder the burden of the lives of many others. Don Cheadle made me sympathise with Paul right from the beginning of the film and deserves every award for which he was nominated. One of the most spine-tingling moments of the film is when he leaves the hotel to find supplies and finds himself in the midst of a sea of bodies - all dead - men, women and children - and I utterly believed that I was watching a man in denial of what was in front of his face. Superb.
Paul's wife, Tatiana, is played by Sophie Okonedo, and again is superb as a woman terrified for her family. Some of her best moments are when she is trying to find news of her brother and sister-in-law and their children - her grief at their possible death is palpable and deeply moving. I liked the fact that, although Okonedo is a beautiful woman, as Tatiana, she looks very gawky and dowdy - of course, this shouldn't matter, but it did make her look more convincing. I also liked her on-screen relationship with Don Cheadle - the pair of them were totally convincing as a loving couple. Nick Nolte and Joacquin Pheonix have powerful, if short, roles in the film as the UN Colonel Oliver and journalist, Jack Daglish. Both are horrified at the events as they unfold in front of them and at the West's refusal to do anything to help the refugees. Their frustration that they don't have the power to do anything to help is painful to watch. One of the best quotes from the film comes from Jack Daglish: "I think if people see this footage [of genocide] they'll say, "oh my God that's horrible," and then go on eating their dinners." How right he was. I was one of them.
Another role that I admired was that of the Red Cross lady, Pat Archer, played by Cara Seymour, who is one of the few westerners prepared to lay down their lives for the children in her care. Pat Archer's on-screen time was short, but her performance was still deeply moving for all that; her devastation as she tells Paul of a child who promises not to be a Tutsi any more if she be allowed to live is painful to watch. General Bizimungu, one of the militia leaders responsible for the atrocities, is played by Fana Mokoena. Rather than make him out to be a complete devil, he first appears in the film as an apparent friend of Paul, and he certainly seems to be very personable. Again, this makes him seem that bit more convincing as a human being, although his acts later on in the film are much harder to apprehend.
This is not a film for those who have sensitive stomachs. There are a lot of disturbing images of Tutsis and Hutu sympathisers being shot down and attacked by machetes; there are also lots of dead bodies. The images are not particularly graphic, but this doesn't make them any less painful to watch and I think the guidance rating of 12 is possibly a little low. Then again, perhaps it is no bad thing for teenagers to know what goes on in this world of ours. I personally found the film very disturbing; not because of what I saw, but because it is still so easy for genocide to happen in this world of ours. I thought the director dealt with this very well. The message is clear - the West sat by and let the genocide happen - but it could have been much more preachy than it was. Hotel Rwanda was filmed on location in South Africa and Rwanda. I was quite surprised at the latter location; I have to admit I am not overly familiar with the political situation in Rwanda, but I would have thought that the authorities would have preferred not to be associated with the film. To be honest though, the location probably wasn't all that important as most of the action took place within the hotel of which Paul was the manager.
There is no doubt that what makes this film so powerful is the fact that it is based on a true story. If it were fiction, I am not sure that it would have made the hairs on the back of my neck stand up so much. Despite this though, nothing can take away from the superb performances by Don Cheadle and Sophie Okonedo. If you haven't yet seen this film, I recommend that you do. It is uncomfortable viewing, even deeply distressing at times, but it tells the story of a genocide that should never have happened and I think that everyone needs to know a little about it. We are fortunate that it is also well-acted and directed. My rental version had no extras, so I am reviewing the film only. The DVD plus extras is available from play.com for £5.99.
Classification: 12 Running time: 2 hours
Compare Prices
sorted by Price
Read more on this product
Products you might be interested in
|
|
03.01.2008 00:33
Excellent review. Have just made a resolution to watch the second half of it. I'm too young to remember this incident clearly, but would the West intervene if this kind of thing happened again?
30.12.2007 20:24
I found this film an eye opener, and excellent, if harrowing
18.12.2007 19:56
Exceptional film, exceptional review!