I am back home now and will be on site shortly. I would like to thank everyone who has sent me messa...
I am back home now and will be on site shortly. I would like to thank everyone who has sent me messages regarding my Father's illness. Much appreciated.xxx
Member since:17.01.2009
Reviews:52
Members who trust:84
Dead Man is a bit of a dark horse and probably not a film a lot of people have seen. The film's director is Jim Jarmusch who I have a lot of respect for. I have always described his work as visionary and along with Tim Burton seems to have established himself in the upper echelons of Hollywood. A former film student, he first came to the public's attention in 1984 with his low budget black and white piece, Stranger than Paradise, and then two years later Down by Law. But he is probably best known, however, for his obliquely observed study of foreign students adrift after hours in Elvis haunted Memphis in 1989's Mystery Train, and for his stunningly visualised Night on Earth three years later. So he has some pedigree and cult status and I guess it makes sense for Depp to take the lead role in his hypnotic and slow-moving, sometimes astonishing western that seemed to have more in common with Ingmar Bergman's The Seventh Seal and Sam Shephard's musical western Silent Tongue from 1993 which was River Phoenix's last movie, than it had with any characteristic Hollywood outing.
The story is of a young man's journey, both physically and spiritually into very familiar territory. William Blake (Johnny Depp) travels to the extreme western frontiers of America some time in the second half of the 19th century. Lost and badly wounded, he encounters a very odd, outcast Native American named Nobody (Gary Farmer), who believes Blake is actually the dead English poet of the same name.
The story, with Nobody's help, leads Blake through situations that are in turn comical and violent. Contrary to his nature, circumstances transform Blake into a hunted outlaw, a killer, and a man whose physical existence is slowly slipping away. Thrown into a world that is cruel and chaotic, his eyes are opening to the fragility that defines the realm of the living. It is as though he passes through the surface of a mirror, and emerges into a previously unknown world that exists on the other side.
My
Thoughts ~~~~~~~~~
This isn't a film for everyone. Although it is a beautiful, intiguing story it stretches out to 2 hours and the pace is slow. It is artistic and humorous and there is what I would call a kind of ominous visual philosophising which some people will think is pretentious, I am sure. Jarmusch is a very independent director and has always put his artistic energy into developing characters rather than plot. I would probably say he is pretty hopeless when it comes to plot. This is not a commercial film in any way and if you are looking for a heavy plot driven film or an action packed film then this is not for you. If you like black and white photography, poetry, rhythms and have an interest in Native America then this is for you.
The central characater is Nobody who sees himself as the ghostly embodiment of William Blake, the famous English romantic poet. He plays the 'foreigner' role and through his eyes we see the disgraceful way that Native Americans are treated in America. The portrait painted by the director is one of grimness and is very dark but never threatening. The pace is calm and poetic. Having researched Native American cultures he portrays a picture of life in America in the nineteenth century. He never patronises or idealises. His picture of white Americans is somewhat different. We see a primeval, chaotic world of malicious bounty hunters, mentally insane trappers and generally cantankerous individuals who look upon every outsider as a quick way to make a buck.
The friendship between Blake and Nobody dominates the film. It is warm and humorous and although they seem to have a strange bond neither really understand each other.
The character Johnny plays is another 'innocent.' A young, naive guy who's trying to get his life back together again. He is trying really hard to make his life work and things go wrong. It was as if he was made for this role. I am not sure I can find anything more to say about Johnny Depp except in this fim I love his subtlety. He is very interesting physically, which is underplayed; he has amazing eyes, which he uses to great effect. He is so precise. He doesn't make any false moves or over do it.
Much the same can said about Robert Mitchum who is also in the film. One of America's accomplished actors of the western genre, who four years before this film had returned to the screen for a cameo role in Martin Scorses's Cape Fear - the director' gripping remake of Mitchum's 1962 original. I think a lot of moviegoers think of Mitchum as a celebrity first and an actor a poor second, and that his career, his work and even his personality are judged accordingly. I have always found him to have a kind of silent dominance in most films. In Ryan's Daughter he gave an outstanding performance. His sheer size - god knows how tall he is, is dominating enough. In Dead Man he is in great shape physically and I think does a terrific job.
Gary Farmer, a native American, being born into the Wolf clan played his role as Nobody, superbly. I found myself drifting off in a trance some of the time just listening to his voice and his presence was at times really funny but so beautiful with all the headgear and traditional costume. A wonderful performance.
There is a rag bag of stars also in the film, like John Hurt, Iggy Pop, Billy Bob Thornton and Michael Wincott but they fade into one as I thought they all over acted and I lost interest in them.
This definitely isn't the sort of western I used to watch with my Dad when I was a nipper. I know exactly the words he would use to describe this film - probably along the lines of '......a load of nonsense'. But then my Dad thought Clint Eastwood had gone a bit weird when he starred in The Good, The Bad and The Ugly so I never take my Dad's criticisms to heart. So you know what's coming next - this is one of the most bizarre films I have ever seen but it is beautifully haunting. The poetry and the William Blake theme running all the way through the film mixed with Robert Muller's black and white photography is stunning. Sometimes, we see shades of grey, interrupted by fade-outs and sometimes the screen is jet black. Not the easiest film to watch. In lots of ways the cinematography and some of the repetitive music (I will explain next) reminds me of Japanese cinema. It is the natural beauty tainted with depravity that reminds me of the work of Kurosawa and Mizoguchi. Exquisite stuff.
There are some very bizarre depictions of human behaviour, like the greedily chewing of a human hand and a crushing of the head of a corpse under the boot of one of the marshalls. We have Iggy Popp wearing a frock (which is probably quite normal for Iggy!) and a marshall sleeping and talking to his teddy bear. All very hallucinatory. It's as if the whole cast are on acid.
The musical soundtrack is performed by Neil Young. In my younger days I quite liked the odd track off his Harvest album and when he plays electric he can rock on. However, he does tend to get on my nerves generally. The minimalist score that is present in the film is monotonous but actually very complimentary. Most of the sound is from an electric guitar with masses of feedback and repeated over and over again. There are some acoustic sounds with a whining, out of tune piano and organ which give the soundtrack a rough, uneven sound. This all adds to the feeling of desolation. Even though Blake and Nobody are together as friends they are both solitary in their individual existence.
What I do think is beautiful is the way Nobody recites some of Blakes (the poet) proverbs to Blake, the young man, and he thinks they are normal utterings from a Native American because when Nobody speaks his own words of wisdom they have very similar meanings and he doesn't know the difference. It is really weird to see a Native American rambling away like a romantic poet stuck miles out in the wild west. There is a wonderful scene where Blake, lost and forlorn in the wilderness, curls up against a young deer that has accidentally been killed. This is Depp at his best - not moving or speaking - just looking with his doe eyes.
I think I will leave it there. Don't let the slowness of this film put you off or the darkness - there are very funny moments. Some great one liners like when Depp, now transformed from the ginky accountant look to the moody, Bohemian, New-Romatic, is confronted by a gang of marshalls who call out, 'Are you William Blake?' With one slight swish of his body, his painted face staring straight at them, says 'Do you know my poetry?' And he blasts them to hell.
Trust me on this one, it is a fabulous film - dark, beautiful, funny, poetic and haunting. Highly Recommended.
Summary: A Beautiful, funny and haunting film
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Production Year: 1995 - Westerns - Director: Joseph Sargent - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring: James Garner, Sissy Spacek, Sam Shepherd, Randy Quaid, Ned Beatty
Fantastic review - I can only echo hillhead and denella's thoughts on the H rate.
hillhead 09.10.2009 00:42
I think you should be made leave a comment on a helpful rate. I know it's not too bad, but it would be nice to see what and where you go wrong to help improve. (If any)