Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD)

Review of

Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD)

Overall rating (23): Overall user rating Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD)

28 offers from £10.93 to £473.00  

All Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) reviews

 Write your own review


 


 


charmed series 1

4 Jul 24th, 2007

Advantages:
interesting great actresses

Disadvantages:
could be more scary

Recommendable: Yes 

Detailed rating:

Did you enjoy it?

Story

Characters / Performances

Special Effects

How does it compare to similar films?

more


megz212

About me: Hey can somebody help me and tell me what this review stuff is all about!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Member since:23.07.2007

Reviews:14

Review rated by 3 Ciao members on average: not helpful

This seven track mini album feels like a car that passes inconsequentially in the dead of night. The songs do not gel into a memorable record, which adds to the impression that it was something created to fill the time between William Bloke (1996) and Mermaid Avenue (1998). It is likely to be only passionate Bragg fans that will be happy to pay for this, whereas the casual fan might enjoy a quick listen to the stand out tracks.

The EP kicks off with a poppy single which has Johnny Marr from the Smiths playing guitar and 'other instruments'. On 'The Boy Done Good' (3:23) Bragg tells the story of his love life using football related analogies: "Taking you to the pictures, was a regular fixture." This epitomises Bragg's 'street-cred' humour and is the stand out track of the album- one that is well worth listening to but not worth buying the album that most people will sing along too. (check out the video for it on youtube)

From here the album goes down hill. Track 2 'Qualifications' (1:45) is catchy with a valid social message about intelligent people who somehow end up working at supermarkets and fast food outlets. So it is dissapointing that he doesn't make more of a meal out of this track because it has real potential.

'Sugardaddy' (4:30) and 'Sugardubby' (5:10) appear to be musical siblings that notch up almost ten minutes of filler between them. They have an unfamiliar ambient sound which is interesting to hear but they are not memorable and the convenent label of 'experimental' can be attached to them.

In between these tracks is a cover of 'Never Had No One Ever' (3:35) by The Smiths. Bragg is brave to attempt this song but it only highlights the inadequacies of his vocal emotion in comparison to Morrissey's ineffable talent. The interesting point here is that Morrissey is a typically depressing singer as Bragg can be, but the two styles are incompatible.

Bragg acheives his own graceful melancholy on track 6, 'Rule Nor Reason' (3:09). Splendid to listen to and genuinely moving, it is on a par with the first track. Together the two songs hold the directionless album together with their contast between happiness and sadness. This is a ying and yang formula that Bragg has used throughout his musical career.

Bringing up the rear is 'Thatherites' (4:05), a vehemently militant song about Margaret Thatcher. "You privatise away what is ours", sneers Bragg. "We'll take it back some day" he croons. The sharp guitar riff works well with Bragg's harsh voice to create something fairly incendiary, but listeing to it in 2007 the song now sounds empty.

Overall there are a couple good invidual songs on here but the rest are irrelevant. The album lacks the power to make it something that can be listened to one or two years later. Instead it'll porbably just provide a nice decoration on someone's CD rack. 
Evaluate this review

How helpful would this review be to someone making a buying decision?

Rating guidelines

Comments about this review
Soho_Black

Soho_Black

14.07.2008 09:30

Not entirely sure how this ended up here. Use the "Contact" link (in grey at the bottom of the page) to ask Ciao to move this to the right place.

megz212

megz212

25.07.2007 14:04

wat the frig!!!!!! i didnt rite that !!!!!!!!!!!!!!this fign is so0o0o confusing!!! help how do u work dis fin!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol!!!!!!!!!!!

CaptainColonic

CaptainColonic

25.07.2007 03:04

See comments below.

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment
Compare Prices sorted by Price
Charmed - Series 1 [DVD]

Charmed -​ Series 1 [DVD]

Charmed: The Complete First Seasonrecaptures a period when television's WB ...

more

£ 10.93 amazon dvd 719 Ratings

Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery

Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-​2 business days.​.​.

     Visit Shop  

amazon dvd

ROSE MCGOWAN AS PAIGE MATTHEWS, ALYSSA MILANO AS PHOEBE HALLIWELL, HOLLY MARIE COMBS AS PIPER HALLIWELL FROM CHARMED #1 - COLOUR Movie Photo - LARGE Size Print - SIZE 20x16" (50x40cm)

ROSE MCGOWAN AS PAIGE MATTHEWS, ALYSSA MILANO AS PHOEBE HALLIWELL, .​.​.

Movie, music and celebrity photographs are perfect for fans looking for a ...

more

£ 11.99 amazon kitchen 719 Ratings

Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery

Availability: Usually dispatched within 6-​10 business days.​.​.

     Visit Shop  

amazon kitchen

HOLLY MARIE COMBS AS PIPER HALLIWELL, ROSE MCGOWAN AS PAIGE MATTHEWS, ALYSSA MILANO AS PHOEBE HALLIWELL FROM CHARMED #1 - COLOUR Movie Photo - LARGE Size Print - SIZE 20x16" (50x40cm)

HOLLY MARIE COMBS AS PIPER HALLIWELL, ROSE MCGOWAN AS PAIGE .​.​.

Movie, music and celebrity photographs are perfect for fans looking for a ...

more

£ 11.99 amazon kitchen 719 Ratings

Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery

Availability: Usually dispatched within 6-​10 business days.​.​.

     Visit Shop  

amazon kitchen



Compare prices
Charmed - Series 1 [DVD] ROSE MCGOWAN AS PAIGE MATTHEWS, ALYSSA MILANO AS PHOEBE HALLIWELL, HOLLY MARIE COMBS AS PIPER HALLIWELL FROM CHARMED #1 - COLOUR Movie Photo - LARGE Size Print - SIZE 20x16" (50x40cm) HOLLY MARIE COMBS AS PIPER HALLIWELL, ROSE MCGOWAN AS PAIGE MATTHEWS, ALYSSA MILANO AS PHOEBE HALLIWELL FROM CHARMED #1 - COLOUR Movie Photo - LARGE Size Print - SIZE 20x16" (50x40cm)
Charmed -​ Series 1 [DVD] ROSE MCGOWAN AS PAIGE MATTHEWS, ALYSSA MILANO AS PHOEBE HALLIWELL, .​.​. HOLLY MARIE COMBS AS PIPER HALLIWELL, ROSE MCGOWAN AS PAIGE .​.​.
amazon dvd amazon kitchen amazon kitchen
£ 10.93 £ 11.99 £ 11.99
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery
more
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery
more
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery
more
 Visit Shop  Visit Shop  Visit Shop
amazon dvd amazon kitchen amazon kitchen
Similar offers
Charmed - Series 1 [DVD] Charmed Series 1 Dvd Box Set Charmed - Series 1-8 - Complete-DVD
Charmed -​ Series 1 [DVD] Charmed Series 1 Dvd Box Set Charmed -​ Series 1-​8 -​ Complete-​DVD
amazon dvd ebay thehut.com
£ 11.34 £ 10.99 £ 80.93
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery
more
Postage & Packaging: 0.​00
more
Postage & Packaging: 0.​00
more
 Visit Shop  Visit Shop  Visit Shop
amazon dvd ebay thehut.​com
Read more on this product
Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) - review by bimbobrown should you buy this product?
  somewhat helpful Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) review by bimbobrown - rated somewhat helpful
Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) - review by Thecharmedones 3 - THAT'S A MAGIC NUMBER
  very helpful Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) review by Thecharmedones - rated very helpful
Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) - review by HeartOfGold Charmed - Season 1
  very helpful Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) review by HeartOfGold - rated very helpful
Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) - review by melliebird Charmed Season 1
  very helpful Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) review by melliebird - rated very helpful
Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) - review by werewolf Charm offensive
  very helpful Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) review by werewolf - rated very helpful
Show all reviews
Review Ratings
This review of Charmed - Series 1 (Box Set) (DVD) has been rated:

"off topic" by (100%):
  1. Soho_Black
  2. shaaza
  3. MAllen400

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.
Related products on eBay