It’s a small wonder why this movie hasn’t been made up until now. When you come to think of it the story is just too obvious to pass up, staring us right in the face. Well it’s happened and its done rather well both sides of the water, financially anyway, while it isn’t going to be near Shrek’s massive gross its set to gross over $100m in the US and it beat off Rush Hour 2 in the opening weekend. Also while Shrek had the cash and the good reviews Cats and Dogs has had mixed reviews, some calling it the dogs…well you know and others saying its none other than the cats poop tray. You’ll know what I think of it, you’ve seen my rating already, but before I let you in on what’s, well, bad about it, I’ll give the obligatory background info.
Cats and Dogs, then, is a movie about the secret life of our furry pals that we have no idea about. Not only can they talk, drive, make phone calls and operate high tech computers but the cats also have plans for world domination, getting rid of dogs once and for all. Ohh sinister.
It starts with an uninspiring, but mildly amusing chase between a cat and a dog in a typically American neighbourhood (big houses, windows wide open for them to fly through, typically warm pie type thing getting cooked). What makes it slightly different its that by the end the dog is ‘catnapped’ and taken away from his owners, the Brody’s, who think that he has just run off somewhere. Little do they know that this is all part of the master plan devised by Mr. Tinkles the master cat (voiced by Sean Hayes from Will & Grace). Mr. Tinkles is hell bent to get back to the times of Egyptians when cats ruled supreme, not only of dogs but of humans too. He plans to steal the concoction that Professor Brody (Jeff Goldblum) is making, a potion that will make people with allergies to dogs…unallergic to them, when he has that he will reverse the formula and make everyone allergic to dogs.
Of course the dogs aren’t going to let Mr. Tinkles get away with it, they are already on the case and plan to send in some highly trained puppies to guard the Professors potion. However,
as usual, nothing goes to plan and a mix up occurs making Lou (Tobey Maguire) a plucky but nonetheless untrained puppy guarding the destiny of the dogs. Two people aren’t too pleased to see him. Butch, the ‘head dog’ of the area (voiced by Alec Baldwin) who has little time to teach him any new tricks (although he is a young dog so you never know) but is forced to try and at least train him up until any back-up should arrive. The other person none to pleased is Scott Brody (Alexander Margolyes, hmm wonder where his parents are from) who is understandably upset that his old dog has gone and he has a ‘loser’ of a puppy. Typical brat then.
Mr. Tinkles tries in vain to steal the potion, with attempts from the Siamese and Russian cats to try and break in and cause havoc. It is not until he kidnaps Lou’s family that he can come close to getting the potion and his plan to come ahead. It is then up to Lou and his friends to try and save his family and the rest of dog kind. I won’t spoil the ending, but it doesn’t take much working out who wins does it?
So that is the basic gist of the movie, its good, clean fun for kids who should lap it up. However although you cant deny it has some good parts and is nicely (ish) done there are a few flaws to make it worthy of anything other than an average film overpowered by CGI.
Before I go on I must point out that I am nowhere near the age range it is intended for so obviously a child of 6 will love it more than me. Yet I am out to have a good time as well and, well, you can’t deny me that. So bear that in mind. However I want to pick the first fault of Cats and Dogs. It’s not that good for the adult to watch. Now, yes, I have just said it is for kids but adults will go along too and films these days have plenty of in-jokes for adults to chuckle at. Take Shrek and Toy Story 1&2 for example, while the kids (and adults) were wowed at the CGI they could also both laugh but at different times for different things. This film is made with solely the purpose of kids (although the Butch line ‘son of my mum’ was pretty good). This could make the adults just slightly bored whilst watching the movie.
The story is a good, albeit simple, one but it is executed badly. It just plods way too slowly. There is a great deal of time before the kidnap finale and it seems very, very drawn out. It is all the more frustrating when the movie savvy ones among you will know what’s going to happen and when. You will find times wondering when its going to get moving instead of just (pardon the wording but I’ve got to get them all in) pussy-footing around it before it gets to anything meaty. There is also a wasted love story with Butch and a stray (Lady and the Tramp anyone) who obviously liked each other in the past but went their separate ways. Not only is the history not given but the relationship, for what screentime it has, doesn’t go anywhere and only seems to serve the purpose of wasting a few minutes to beef up the movie.
The acting is also under par. However it’s not the animals you have to worry about but the humans. Although this is a movie about cats and dogs and they should, admittedly, get more screentime, the humans are treated second rate in more ways than one. Goldblum is wasted as the bumbling professor, get an unknown in there and it wouldn’t have made the slightest bit of difference. Then there is the major gripe of mine, the child. A problem with all films is how to present him/her to the audience. Well this time it’s the spoilt, snivelling type of presentation. Scott is needed for the relationship with man and boy, but breaks up a lot of action. He predictably rejects then loves his new found friend, what’s worse is the fact we, the audience, are subjected to a loving bonding session of them in slow motion, this doesn’t bode well for the film because it makes it look like some cheesy commercial about dog food.
The CGI is also questionable. There is no doubt that the lip syncing of the animals are almost perfectly done but swapping CGI with real life animals are painfully clear. Obviously the kids who are watching this wont notice, but for people that do notice it will spoil it because you are forever seeing the real from the fake.
The last major gripe is that there are a few plot holes in the movie. Obviously I cant tell you all them all because it would spoil parts of the film however the ending is, not flawed, but it is not entirely resolved for a movie that is supposed to have a happy ending, I will just say, think of what happened at the beginning and what didn’t happen at the end. Then there are minor plot flaws, for example although the cats and dogs in this movie are nimble they aren’t super, I mean how do they buy a car? How does Mr. Tinkle acquire a camcorder? How the hell can the dogs have all that high tech equipment? However this is just me thinking too deep into the film when really it should be taken at face value.
It’s not all bad though. When the CGI is good the action sequences are nicely done. The fighting scenes are not too over emphasised or drawn out and these animals don’t just use their claws, the Russian cat does have some nifty gadgets up his, well, kind of arm things (oh and there is the now much too overused Matrix fight spoof, two words STOP NOW!!!). It is a pity that the action is broken up too much in the movie.
The best parts of the film though has to be with Mr. Tinkles. Hats go off to Sean Hayes for bringing him to life in such a fun way. He is presented as the typically bumbling nemesis that you will know will never win and for this you cant help but root for him just a tad. He is made all the more inadequate as the enemy when he is subjected to wearing some unsightly costumes for a cat, much to the amusement of the other cats. His selfish attitude is fantastic and he really does have the best bits, near the ending he plays a cruel but nonetheless funny turn around on his dogsbody with the simple reason being that he doesn’t like him. Not funny on a computer screen but when you hear Hayes say it you’ll laugh. Well I did.
There are some other funny parts to the film. When humans walk past the dogs will idly dig up the grass or sniff each others ‘butts’. The character Peek is also quite funny and takes second place next to Mr. Tinkles. A loveable if slightly dumb dog who always tries to hide and sneek up but always gets caught.
Despite the good premise and good voice overs from the people involved you cant help but think that Cats and Dogs could have been so much more. Mr. Tinkles needed more screentime, the story needed to happen faster with more action, and a bit more history with characters would have been nice and would have made this film win my heart a bit more.
Cats and Dogs is a fun film but this really is a kid’s film for kids only. I wanted to like it; the trailer looked damn good, but never judged a film by its trailer, eh? If you have kids then they will love this but don’t expect to be bowled over yourselves. Better luck for the inevitable sequel.
CATS AND DOGS IS
A good story but not carried off to its full potential Full of good animal characters Low on jokes for grown ups
CATS AND DOGS IS NOT
A successfully carried off story Full of good human characters Meant for the older generation
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Production Year: 1993 - Family - Original Language: English - Classification: Universal - Starring: Michael Caine, The Muppets, Jerry Nelson, Frank Oz, Dave Goelz, David Rudman, Steve Whitmire
Family - Director: Sarah Ball - Original Language: English - Classification: Universal - Starring: Neil Morrissey, Noddy Holder, Alison Steadman, Stephen Tompkinson, Chris Evans, Elton John, Bob The Builder
Shame, I thought this was going to be quite enjoyable. Haven't seen it, will wait for Sky to show it, now. Helen
davebaggott 28.08.2001 14:09
excellent op, i didn't think the film held great attraction for youngsters either, the cinema wasn't in rapturous laughter when i went. could have been better and the adverts for it seemed to be saying it would be.
oh well. if only i was a kid.
dave
DEATH-TOUCH 24.08.2001 01:42
Excellent opinion. Thankyou for an interesting read. Maria...
How can you hate a movie that features ninja Siamese cats wreaking havoc with their kung ... more
fu prowess?Cats&Dogsis an effects-laden family film that mystifies cat fanciers by casting dogsas the undisputed heroes in all-out warfare with nefarious felines. ...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
How can you hate a movie that features ninja Siamese cats wreaking havoc with their kung ... more
fu prowess?Cats&Dogsis an effects-laden family film that mystifies cat fanciers by casting dogs as the undisputed heroes in all-out warfare with nefarious felines....
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
After years of international crime experience, Bud Spencer is back into action to battle ... more
the crooks in this notoriously hilarious parody of all cops and robbers films. Elaborate action stunts and nonsensical humour is the order of the day as Spencer is...