note: also appears on my film review website, ShaunMunro.co.uk, and Dooyoo!
Sidney Lumet returns to top form in Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead - a devilishly tense (pun intended), sprawling, melodramatic puzzle of a film. The film’s title comes from a famous Irish blessing, which declares, “And may you be in heaven half an hour before the devil knows you're dead”, verbiage very much apt for protagonist brothers Andy (Philip Seymour Hoffman) and Hank (Ethan Hawke).
In short, Andy and Hank, both short of money for various reasons, are looking to rob a “mom and pop” jewellery store, yet the sting in the tail lies in the fact that this store is owned by their parents. The focal point of the film is this robbery’s result, which leaves various individuals dead or near death, and Andy and Hank must attempt a clean getaway as their father, Charles (Albert Finney), seeks to get revenge on the perpetrators. Embroiled in the turmoil is Andy’s wife Gina (Marisa Tomei), who is torn between the two brothers in a very twisted love triangle.
Lumet enjoys utilising non-linear narrative to great effect in this film – we open on the day of the robbery, and subsequently
dart around various days before and after it, which reveals to us a wealth of important and, at times, shocking information. The initial robbery is an intense, gripping scene of intrigue, ending in a violent eruption, yet soon enough, we are sent plunging backwards to three days prior to this. Such flashbacks are often disorientating and ancillary to the plot, yet in this instance, they are satisfying, and moreover, necessary – they work quickly in familiarising us with the two brothers and their various motivations (monetary, sexual, and familial) to rob the store.
The wildly slick robbery plan is orchestrated largely by Andy, who plays things extremely cool, whilst Hank initially balks at the idea, yet, with various large and looming debts, he ultimately decides to ride shotgun. In moments such as these, as Andy sits behind his desk, almost pontificating the need to pull this scam off, smoking a cigarette, he himself assumes a rather Faustian, devil’s advocate-like persona, and it’s wonderful to watch.
These flashback interludes, even in their effectiveness, fortunately do not last for the rest of the picture, and soon enough, we are thrown back into the intense robbery scenario, yet this time, thanks to said flashbacks, we now have context established. Lumet does decide to dip the viewer in and out of Andy and Hank’s lives from days before the robbery, yet rather than suffocate the film, the puzzle-esque format exists to suture together the various plot strands, endowing the viewer with essential information and character development.
Following the botched robbery, Hank states to Andy that “it’s all come apart”, and this is truer than the brothers know. The fallout of the robbery has greater ramifications than either could have ever expected. With the introduction of their father, the flashbacks begin to encapsulate his life also, introducing a more sinister, foreboding, and dangerous element into the narrative.
Hank in particular seems to become more and more neck-deep in trouble (mostly monetary) as the film progresses, yet Andy is hardly keeping himself above water either. Their own tribulations, combined with the emergence of their disaffected, enraged father, causes the tension to ratchet up to highly unnerving levels, setting up for what is one of the most thrilling, and shocking finales of the year. If anything, Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead is a film about downfall – the death of a very twisted American dream, if you will. There certainly are cathartic moments before the fall, in that these are, to a degree, sympathetic characters, although aside from Finney’s tragedy-imbued person, you have to wonder if they’re worthy of such sentiment. Andy, in particular, is of dubious moral character, and Hank, driven by a need to stay afloat, is dragged down into the abyss with him.
It is a massive credit to the picture to be endowed with such acting powerhouses as Hoffman and Finney, that one is able to find all of the film’s familial issues to be convincing precursors to their present problems, without at all seeming forced. The finale is almost unbearably tense, serving up its fair share of surprises, and whilst one may declare that it “descends” into melodrama, I attest that it shamelessly (and rightly so) does so, with no descent or decline in the film’s integrity or quality. The final twenty minutes is so chock full of unpredictability (yet still manages to be tangible), and so masterfully acted, that even if you find the melodrama to be several steps too far, there is nevertheless an assortment of reasons to both watch and revel in this electrifying, dramatic character study.
Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead is packed with Oscar-worthy material – the tragic, spiralling plot is unflinching in its portrayal of man’s desperation, thanks to Kelly Masterson’s sharp and inventive script. However, what without question raises this film above similar pictures is its acting – Albert Finney is perfectly smouldering as a vengeful man thrown into an impossible situation, Philip Seymour Hoffman is spot-on as the unquestionably slimy sibling, and Marisa Tomei does an appropriately ditzy job. One mustn’t forget Ethan Hawke either, whose role is not as meaty as Hoffman’s, yet he still brings a flare to the role of an unspeakably desperate individual. Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead is a winning, daring concoction of skilful writing, deft performances, and schooled direction.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Production Year: 2004 - Drama - Director: Nick Cassavetes - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over, 12 years and over - Starring: Rachel McAdams, Ryan Gosling, Gena Rowlands
Master filmmaker Sidney Lumet directs this absorbing suspense thriller about a family ... more
facing the worst enemy of all - itself. Andy (Philip Seymour Hoffman) is an overextended broker who lures his younger brother Hank (Ethan Hawke) into a larcenous s...
Postage & Packaging: £0.00 Availability: 3-5 working days
Sep 26th, 2009
very helpful by (100%):
