Just finished a few months travelling and suddenly I have a need to write again, I hope you all enjo...
Just finished a few months travelling and suddenly I have a need to write again, I hope you all enjoy
Member since:14.01.2002
Reviews:63
Members who trust:20
Like blood from a stone springs the latest in the Batman series of films, Batman Begins. Having seen the gradual demise of the franchise with films like the heinous Batman forever, it begs the question why they felt a prequel would be the answer. I must admit that I am not a fan of comic books or their associated films; the sci-fi fantasy genres hold very little sway with me.
For some reason, perhaps blinded by the dour nature of other films available or the intoxication of alcohol somehow it always seemed like a good idea to watch this film. With it's inevitable Hollywood Blockbuster advertising overkill, it was unavoidable on it's initial release. Somehow I avoided it though and barely gave it a second thought until I received a suspect package on my Birthday. Quelle surprise there it was the 2 disk Batman Begins DVD. Initially under whelmed but still mildly interested I put off watching it, in fact it was only when I had picked up the flu and was bed ridden for a week that it finally managed to get see the other side of it shrink wrapped casing.
The pretence as I understood it was that the film follows the life of Bruce Wayne from the death of his parent up to his growth into Batman. Essentially filling in the gaps left by the initial Batman film. My main problem with this was that if it was considered so important why did the initial (highly successful) Batman film gloss over this period of growth? This was a question that the film adequately answered for me when I finally came around to watching it.
The other slightly more interesting factor that I knew about the film was the director and more importantly his stance and filmmaking style. The British born and educated Christopher Nolan is something of a purist.
His past success with films like Memento showed a degree of style and simplicity, which I found difficult to see how he could translate this to the action filled comic book fantasy genre. In the few interviews I heard him give about the film it came to my attention that the vast majority of the action was in real time and done on set, rather than the more extravagant recent tendency towards CGI and other animatrix options. Which for me provided the only really tangible points for optimism in the film for me.
Unsurprisingly the film failed to really change my mind. The attempts at combining the serious traumas of everyman and the excesses of typical genre based action capitulated miserably. The slow lumbering tale of Batman's early years are briefly punctuated by violence and action to make a jarring and somewhat awkward film viewing. The portraiture of Wayne as a lost soul looking for a direction to take his life is taken to the typical comic book excesses. Imprisoned in a run down oriental jail for stealing Wayne Enterprise goods, he is released into the world with only a suited Liam Neeson offering any answers. His trials and tribulations in a mountain top martial arts school add little to the story and provides very little in the way of entertainment.
Gotham,as always is a city in turmoil, full of corruption and lawlessness. Crying out for a hero to save them from falling into complete oblivion, the prodigal son Wayne returns to do just that. Fortunately his former girlfriend (the future Mrs. Cruise Katie Holmes) is the one legal secretary standing up for what is right in the city. After a series of forgettable exchanges to make their re-acquaintance, the crux of the story is finally slowly drawn out. An evil crime lord is controlling the cities underbelly, and with the help of a crazed lawyer/doctor is keeping his goons out of prison whilst also subjecting them to tests for the effectiveness of a nerve gas. Confused? Well to simplify there is a twist in which the city is put in peril and Wayne faces unenviable odds in order to save the city from complete annihilation by the mad tyrant who shall remain nameless.
To keep it simple, my opinion is that the film never truly ignites. It is stuck in a half way house where it can't decide if it wants to be an all out action fantasy or a deep study into the human psyche and interaction. Lacklustre acting performances and a fairly woeful script of one liners and sound bites add little to the intensity of the film. Liam Neeson should stick to his 'serious' acting, I don't pretend to be a fan of his work but he looks like a fish out of water in this film. His credentials as a believable martial arts trainer and all round action hero are hampered by his inability to fully engage the audience and present himself as a credible fighter. He still looks like Oskar Schindler strutting around the Himalayas. As for Christian Bale and Katie Holmes I doubt this is the role which will truly galvanize their careers and show their ability to be serious actors. Bale should have stayed on the course he started with American Psycho and Holmes should just stick to doing children's television or something similar, she is far too dainty and cute for what I would describe as 'serious' acting. Michael Caine offers nothing but a little light relief and Gary Oldman's role, as commissioner Gordon is as understated as it is frankly bizarre.
For me if the film had a real purpose it could have worked. If it was purely a psychological study of Bruce Wayne it might have been a little tedious but it would have at least explained everything in simple terms. If it was all out violence and comic book capery then at least it would work on that level. But it is the fact that it achieves neither of these and is what I would describe as a film in limbo that draws the main part of my criticism.
The film as I understand it was designed to gratify comic book fans who wanted to see the intervening years between Batman's early years and the start of the first Batman film. But the film jumps around just like the first Batman film and still manages to overlook some of his growth as a man and a boy. The audience is thrust forward from his parent's death to his life in a Chinese prison without barely a mention of what happened in the middle. Only brief cryptic flashbacks provide any kind of answer to the ever-increasing riddle. Sequels rarely work and prequels never work, Batman Begins whiffs of a film that was all too eager to jump on the recent comic book to film conversion bandwagon. I can't pretend to know anything of the story of the Batman comics but as a film standing on it's own merits Batman Begins is a weak and lacklustre display.
The extra features on the second DVD are typical of any that you would expect to find on any special feature DVD. Cast and crew interviews, the making of featurette and a documentary. Irritatingly of course all they talk about is how good the film is how proud they are of it and how the director was the best they ever worked with. It is just a sickening continuation of the typical Hollywood love-ins that occur during the promotional period, when stars flock to talk about just how great the film is. One day I want a bonus DVD to have a 2 hour feature full of obscenities and distraught looking celebrities and directors really saying what they think. The extra features are more scripted and certainly better co-ordinated than the feature film which says it all about the package really.
Overall this is a disappointment, as unimaginative in the film concept as it is in its bonus features. Unless you really fell in love with film I would barely recommend trying this as a speculative purchase. Despite the roll call of distinguished actors and one of Hollywood's top young directors, Batman Begins falls short of its illustrious sequel. It tries to be too much rather than concentrating on what it is. The dark brooding atmosphere that it attempts to create rarely fires up, and when it does it is usually to the detriment of the film and it's characters. It will win no awards for originality and it barely gets going as a story, so in conclusion Batman Begins is best left well alone. Not my cup of tea at all.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Production Year: 2008 - Action/Adventure - Director: Christopher Nolan - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring:Maggie Gyllenhaal, Aaron Eckhart, Morgan Freeman, Heath Ledger, Gary Oldman, Christian Bale, Michael Caine
Production Year: 1964 - Action/Adventure - Director: Cyril Endfield - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring:Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, James Booth, Michael Caine, Nigel Green
Action/Adventure - Director: The Wachowski Brothers - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring:Keanu Reeves, Laurence Fishburne, Carrie-Anne Moss, Hugo Weaving, Monica Bellucci, Jada Pinkett
Production Year: 2002 - Action/Adventure - Director: Vincenzo Natali - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring:Lucy Liu, David Hewlett, Anne Marie Scheffler, Joseph Scoren, Matthew Sharp, Jeremy Northam
Batman Beginsdiscards the previous four films in the series and recasts the Caped Crusader ... more
as a fearsome avenging angel. That's good news, because the series, which had gotten off to a rousing start under Tim Burton, had gradually dissolved into self-p...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 1 to 3 weeks...
Batman Beginsdiscards the previous four films in the series and recasts the Caped Crusader ... more
as a fearsome avenging angel. That's good news, because the series, which had gotten off to a rousing start under Tim Burton, had gradually dissolved into self-p...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Just when you though that theBatmanfranchise was dead and buried--certainly after the ... more
abomination that was 1997sBatman&Robin--along comes director Christopher Nolan to brilliantly bring it all back to life with the astonishingly strongBatman Begins.Nol...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Just when you though that theBatmanfranchise was dead and buried--certainly after the ... more
abomination that was 1997sBatman&Robin--along comes director Christopher Nolan to brilliantly bring it all back to life with the astonishingly strongBatman Begins.Nol...
Postage & Packaging: free Super Saver Delivery Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...