If you've left me a rating on either my Imaginarium of Dr Parnassus or In the Valley of Elah reviews...
If you've left me a rating on either my Imaginarium of Dr Parnassus or In the Valley of Elah reviews, please let me know as they are showing up as 'not yet rated' even though at least fifteen of you have rated each one.
Member since:11.07.2000
Reviews:778
Members who trust:82
Imprisoned in a Chinese jail, billionaire playboy Bruce Wayne is sprung by the mysterious Ducard, who invites him to join "The League of Shadows" in a bid to fight global injustice. After intensive ninja training and a clash of ideals, Wayne heads back to Gotham, determined to save the city from insane criminal masterminds with the help of a cape and a pair of pointy ears…
Just when you thought "Batman" had been killed off by Joel Schumacher's garish excesses, along comes British director Christopher Nolan to revitalise the Dark Knight. Thankfully eschewing the pantomime theatrics of the last two sequels, Nolan comes to the series fresh and taking his inspiration from Frank Miller's "Year One" comic books. Thematically and visually dark but never gothic in the same way as Tim Burton's oeuvre this is back-to-basics for the franchise. Though the movie is a comic book adaptation, Nolan never delves too far into the realms of fantasy, setting it in a recognisable world where crime is more of a worry than the luminous-faced lunatics of previous films. Gotham is a thinly-veiled alternate New York with its own seedy underworld and socio-economic problems. The production design is a mixture of rough but cutting edge technology and old world design, with the heaviest influences being art deco and grim Victorian. The city looks like a new industrial world built on old foundations and poverty. The film gives the overwhelming impression of being shot in sepia though the filter is used sparingly. I suppose it's a handy metaphor for the central protagonist's murky morals - determined to bring justice to the world from a personal desire for vengeance. That being said, the beginning of the film is shot with a blue filter, echoing the miserable conditions Wayne finds himself in and the ice-cold efficiency of Ducard's training. Much of the movie takes place at night, fittingly for a picture about a man dressed as a bat. It's a useful conceit for Nolan, as it allows him to tantalise the audience with glimpses of their hero before going for the big reveal, which
is all the more satisfying as a result. Like Bond, the Bat is known for his gadgets and this film is no exception. But instead of the polished gizmos we've previously seen, the whatnots here, although cool are rough and ready and you can see how they might evolve to become the iconic symbols we've been brought up with. The film plays like a creation myth for comic book aficionados, giving a stark glimpse into the man behind the mask. It is as complete a vision of a comic hero as you are likely to find, building his character from the start and setting the scene for Gotham's inevitable descent into darkness.
The screenplay by Nolan and "Blade" scribe David S Goyer is clearly a dark labour of love. They spend the majority of their time building Wayne's character, making it crystal clear to the audience where his motivations come from and making him a more layered individual than in previous movies. There's less emphasis on the colourful villains and more on his inner turmoil, showing him to be a dangerous vigilante in his own right. Supporting characters aren't as well-written, but this is forgivable as fans of previous films or the comic books will recognise them and know who they are destined to become. Though Bruce Wayne clearly takes himself seriously, there is a dark vein of humour running throughout the film. Certain characters have been updated to provide a little light relief; Alfred is no longer the toadying butler but an irreverent sidekick who treats his employer as a slightly irresponsible equal. As a result he isn't adverse to the odd piece of sage advice, put-down or quip. Though this character adjustment works well, it doesn't quite gel with Jim Gordon, who is sidelined as a rather buffoonish second-string character. The real meat amongst the supporting players is to be found in the villains, who are more rounded and therefore believable than past incumbents of the franchise. So we get a reptilian crime boss and a frankly creepy psychologist-cum-mad-scientist who is all the more frightening because he is sane (at least in the beginning). The dialogue is slick but never camp or self-consciously cool.
Bale is ideal in the dual Batman/Bruce Wayne role. He has the physical presence to convince as the Dark Knight but the acting chops to carry off the more emotionally challenging part of Bruce Wayne. He's the first actor to take on the role who differentiates sufficiently between the two aspects of the character, giving each a different presence and even dropping his voice an octave for Batman so it's conceivable people wouldn't recognise him behind the mask. But even when playing up Wayne's image as a capricious playboy, there's always a sense of something altogether more menacing beneath the surface. His relationships with his fellow cast members sparkle in some cases, as with Michael Caine as his long-suffering manservant. But where there should be real chemistry with Katie Holmes, there is nothing more than polite affection.
The supporting cast is of a remarkably high quality, featuring a roll-call of famous names. The most marked feature of all the performances is a tendency to talk in a lower register than normal giving everything the players say a more serious tone. Michael Caine plays yet another variation of himself as Alfred. But he's clearly having such a good time and has great rapport with Bale that it's easy to accept him as the character, especially as he hints at layers that make him better rounded than the script allows for. Liam Neeson continues his run as mentor figures as the shady Henri Ducard, the least French sounding Irishman I've ever heard. He approaches the role in his usual measured manner and gives it life, but with such a dodgy moustache you know there's something more Machiavellian about him from the off.
Morgan Freeman is warm and hearty as Lucius Fox and it's great to see him in a relatively minor supporting role though it sometimes feels like a waste of his talents. Katie Holmes is far less irritating than I had anticipated. She finally seems to have given up on the lop-sided grinning and girl-next-door shenanigans and has gone for a more mature character and performance. She's feisty and forthright as lawyer Rachel Dawes and hopefully this signals a change in the types of roles she will approach. Gary Oldman is clearly straining at the leash as the under-written Jim Gordon, but this makes for a slightly hammy performance that doesn't do his skills justice. Plus he has a bad 'tache and an even worse wig to contend with.
The real stars are the bad guys. Tom Wilkinson shows his range as slimy mob boss Carmine Falcone. He shows a propensity for cold-blooded cruelty as a man so powerful he is foolish enough to think himself invincible. However his megalomania is nothing compared to that of twisted psychiatrist Dr Jonathan Crane played with disconcerting intensity by Irish actor Cillian Murphy. Just one look at his piercing blue eyes and you're under no illusion this man has a God complex he's willing to act on. Rutger Hauer impresses in a small role as Earle, the bureaucrat determined to strip mine the assets of the Wayne Corporation for his own benefit.
The special effects fall into two distinct camps; physical and computer-generated. The physical include great gadgets and gizmos for Batman that have a rough and ready air about them that makes them feel like they really could exist. The Batmobile is a souped-up military dune buggy, the Batsuit re-sprayed body armour and the bat-shaped projectiles hand-made by the man himself. Even the Bat-Cave looks feasible because we see it being built. The CGI comes in where the Scarecrow sets out to create chaos through chemically-induced fear. The vibrating backgrounds and glowing eyes are common to all the bad trips seen on screen and are effective in showing how scary it could be (and I am reliably informed reflects what a real acid trip can induce). But the piece de resistance is the molten-skinned alternate Batman seen by Dr Crane that is truly terrifying. Not bad for nightmares summoned up by a man with a bag on his head.
The stunts throughout are confidently choreographed and performed, from the Samurai sword-fight on frozen lake, to the ninja training exercises and the Batmobile chase through the streets of Gotham that has the vehicle flattening everything in sight. The fights are brutal and occasionally painful to watch, but that's just because they look real. There are also some impressive pyrotechnics that Michael Bay would be proud of and the pleasing use of miniatures in the finale that shows there are some things that don't need CGI to be effective.
The score has two of the big guns working on it with both Hans Zimmer and James Newton Howard contributing. Neither is noted for his subtlety and as a result there are plenty of booming drums and big horn sections. But it all fits the mood and style of the film. Batman has become an epic character since his humble beginnings and the incidental music reflects this, dispensing with the sense of whimsy and playfulness that was attendant on the other Batman films.
This is a film that I suspect will appeal more to guys than girls. Batman has always been more of a fighter than a lover and that attitude is the only thing that hasn't really changed in this movie. It is dark, gritty and tinged with film noir sensibilities that means there are shadows lurking in every frame. If you're a fan of the comic books, you're going to love this movie. If you're more of a casual observer of the franchise's fortunes, you may be impressed but strangely unmoved. Everything about the film oozes quality from the acting to the set design, but it's hard to engage emotionally with a character whose defining feature is a desire for vengeance. Though I'm not a great fan of the franchise I'm still looking forward to the next instalment.
How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines
Action/Adventure - Director: The Wachowski Brothers - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring:Keanu Reeves, Laurence Fishburne, Carrie-Anne Moss, Hugo Weaving, Monica Bellucci, Jada Pinkett
Production Year: 2002 - Action/Adventure - Director: Vincenzo Natali - Original Language: English - Classification: 15 years and over - Starring:Lucy Liu, David Hewlett, Anne Marie Scheffler, Joseph Scoren, Matthew Sharp, Jeremy Northam
Production Year: 2008 - Action/Adventure - Director: Christopher Nolan - Original Language: English - Classification: 12 years and over - Starring:Maggie Gyllenhaal, Aaron Eckhart, Morgan Freeman, Heath Ledger, Gary Oldman, Christian Bale, Michael Caine
Production Year: 1964 - Action/Adventure - Director: Cyril Endfield - Original Language: English - Classification: Parental Guidance - Starring:Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, James Booth, Michael Caine, Nigel Green
good review. The best batman film out by far at the moment
Ryan74 04.09.2005 21:34
I lost faith in the Batman films after they became increasingly lacklustre, but this looks well worth a view, and I'm yet to read a negative review of it.
thespurs 31.08.2005 23:24
Nice review. I may have to have a beaver at this one!
Just when you though that theBatmanfranchise was dead and buried--certainly after the ... more
abomination that was 1997sBatman&Robin--along comes director Christopher Nolan to brilliantly bring it all back to life with the astonishingly strongBatman Begins.Nol...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Batman Beginsdiscards the previous four films in the series and recasts the Caped Crusader ... more
as a fearsome avenging angel. That's good news, because the series, which had gotten off to a rousing start under Tim Burton, hadgradually dissolved into self-pa...
Postage & Packaging: £1.21 Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days...
Batman Beginsdiscards the previous four films in the series and recasts the Caped Crusader ... more
as a fearsome avenging angel. That's good news, because the series, which had gotten off to a rousing start under Tim Burton, hadgradually dissolved into self-pa...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...
Just when you though that theBatmanfranchise was dead and buried--certainly after the ... more
abomination that was 1997sBatman&Robin--along comes director Christopher Nolan to brilliantly bring it all back to life with the astonishingly strongBatman Begins.Nol...
Postage & Packaging: Free! Availability: Usually dispatched within 24 hours...